Who the Hell is Mona? *SPOILER ALERT*

[Hearse]

The main grave stone in the cemetary, "Here lies our Beloved Mona"
Is she Jas and Shane's mom?
Alex's mom
Carolyne's mother
The Wizard's "wife"

[Triesco]

引用自 Proteus：

Was the mayor ever married?
If yes, maybe it could have been his wife

http://imgur.com/LOJ5m0Y
In lewis' room near the coffee cup.
Could be -M for Mona

[Istvan]

引用自 Triesco：

引用自 Proteus：

Was the mayor ever married?
If yes, maybe it could have been his wife

http://imgur.com/LOJ5m0Y
In lewis' room near the coffee cup.
Could be -M for Mona

That M is not for Mona. That relationship is ongoing. I'm also 99% sure that Lewis says that he never married in one of his random dialogues, but rather dedicated his life to mayoring.

[Duncan]

引用自 Triesco：

引用自 Proteus：

Was the mayor ever married?
If yes, maybe it could have been his wife

http://imgur.com/LOJ5m0Y
In lewis' room near the coffee cup.
Could be -M for Mona

Its Marnie lol.

[Triesco]

I know but i was just suspecting things that people have not thought - maybe they want us to think its Marnie.

[Triesco]

Someone like the dwarf/krobus wife who might of died in the element wars?
Grandpas wife [your grandma]?

[Gordito Kawaii]

引用自 Istvan：

引用自 Triesco：

http://imgur.com/LOJ5m0Y
In lewis' room near the coffee cup.
Could be -M for Mona

That M is not for Mona. That relationship is ongoing. I'm also 99% sure that Lewis says that he never married in one of his random dialogues, but rather dedicated his life to mayoring.

Yeah, he says he never married or had children and dedicated his life to being mayor.

Then he bums you out by asking if you think if it was worth it.

[luggage]

引用自 mmmmarygray：

引用自 Landwalker04：

I feel like the Wizard would have known if his daughter were dead. His line regarding having a daughter in town very strongly implies that she's alive. Most common vote is that it's Abigail, due a wide variety of reasons and supporting evidence. Runner-up candidate is Emily.

The most likely scenario is that it's just someone's old relative. If I had to wing it, I'd probably say Penny's grandmother or something.

My vote is on Emily being his daughter personally. Her parents are mysteriously off traveling for an indefinite period of time. Makes a lot of sense that those parents could easily be the Wizard and Witch. It would also explain her interest in magic and spirits.

- Caroline tells you that when she was younger, she liked taking walks to the wizards tower, but you are not to tell Pierre that, else he would get jealous.
- Pierre wonders if Abigail is actually his biological daughter.
- Caroline claims that Abigail dyes her hair, but Abigail says that she cannot remember when she last dyed her hair, which is purple, the same colour as the wizard's hair.
- Abigail has a lot of interest in the occult, and can even get an ouija board to work.

Which overall gives a better indication of Abigail being the wizard's daughter rather than Emily.


As for Mona, she could also be one of your relatives (your grandfather owned the farm previously).

[Troll]

引用自 Hearse：

The main grave stone in the cemetary, "Here lies our Beloved Mona"

Isn't that a pet ?

[Triesco]

I am hoping for a new event for your pets like a pet show - your pet, the dog by the trailer, fish from the comunity center ect. prize could be a unique pet like a turtle then if you win again you win turtle food.

[Moooo]

I think she has some relation with Abigal. I found her standing by the grave once, so she could of been paying respects?

[landman]

引用自 Landwalker04：

Most likely, though, is that Marnie is in fact the biological aunt of at least one of them (in this case, most likely Jas), and possibly both through two different Marnie-siblings.

I think that's the case, but on the contrary, I think Shane is the biological nephew, he, as a friend of Jas parents, took care of her as the godfather, and moved to Marnie's, provably to be in a better place for Jas to grow. It would be easier for Marnie to welcome an unrelated child that an unrelated adult to her house.

[Triesco]

引用自 Triesco：

Someone like the dwarf/krobus wife who might of died in the element wars?
Grandpas wife [your grandma]?

Making people view my old post.

[Guildes]

引用自 Triesco：

Someone like the dwarf/krobus wife who might of died in the element wars?
Grandpas wife [your grandma]?

i agree with triesco and i think i could be someone from the "element wars" or some relative to your grandpa since he was someone respected in the town but still i think its a little weird not only because abigail stand in front of her grave like i was an old friend of her but i also because if it was his wife she would probably be buried near grandpa's gravestone in the farm.



(btw i never thought the most intense episode of x-files would come from a grave in stardew valley)

[YetiChow]

dat necro though... actually, there's a thought -- why don't we just get to 10 hearts with Rasmodius, have him raise Mona for a night, and ask her ourselves? Clearly it can be done, as the skeletons filling up the mines attest

Or another option would be to summon Grandpa from his shrine, ask him to go find Mona's spirit, and get the answer that way.

Or simply contact Welwick -- she could probably use the cash...

Back on-topic: I like the idea of it being the player's grandmother -- it would explain why Grandpa would leave the farm (since he asks you to say hi to Lewis, which implies he hasn't been to the valley in a while); living in the empty house by himself could be a constant reminder of his loss.

The house in the opening cutscene might be the initial farmhouse; but it doesn't line up perfectly... and the phrasing in the letter makes me think that Grandpa's time in the Valley was only one part of his life (even if it may have been the most significant part).

[Ringleader Ren]

引用自 Landwalker04：

引用自 The Red Dragon：

Im thinking it was a friend of abigail or the daughter of the wizard

I feel like the Wizard would have known if his daughter were dead. His line regarding having a daughter in town very strongly implies that she's alive. Most common vote is that it's Abigail, due a wide variety of reasons and supporting evidence. Runner-up candidate is Emily.

The most likely scenario is that it's just someone's old relative. If I had to wing it, I'd probably say Penny's grandmother or something.

引用自 dman_dustin：

Well of course if Marnie is both Jas and Shane's aunt, then they would obviously either be brother/sister OR cousins, assuming of course Concerned Ape didn't include complicated family relations like "Great Aunts."

Aside from the obvious "They aren't siblings, that much is known," it's not technically impossible that Marnie isn't related to either of them, and that "Aunt" is just used as a term of affection.

Most likely, though, is that Marnie is in fact the biological aunt of at least one of them (in this case, most likely Jas), and possibly both through two different Marnie-siblings.

Abigail is Caroline and Pierre's Kid. Not the wizard's.

Mona should be Abigail's Grandmother.