Stardew Valley

Stardew Valley

View Stats:
Paralt Feb 15, 2019 @ 1:18pm
No fishing?
Is it possible to play this game without fishing? I can't seem to learn how to catch a fish no matter how hard I try. I've read guides, watched videos, and am trying to do it at the supposedly most easy place to do it, the forest lake. I haven't caught a fish yet except for the very first one when I got the fishing pole. Makes me want to stop playing what is supposed to be a fun game.
Feeling like a loser not fun.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 18 comments
Tinner Feb 15, 2019 @ 1:24pm 
Technicaly you could but would not be able to finish the community center (unless maybe you buy the fish)
Last edited by Tinner; Feb 15, 2019 @ 1:25pm
Ilucie Feb 15, 2019 @ 1:41pm 
If you go the joja way: yes. But anyways its a farming game, not a fishing game. You dont have to do anything. If you want to go the community way, just cheat or buy the fish. :)
WildKhaine Feb 15, 2019 @ 2:26pm 
You don't need to do any fishing in the game if you don't want to. You'll probably want to go the Joja route if so because completing the community center will be a bit of a challenge though you could manage to buy the fish you need. If you don't mind modding the game, there are some mods that can make fishing easier or even go as far as doing it for you pretty much.
Eye Aye Feb 15, 2019 @ 2:34pm 
Try fishing up by the mine. carp are very easy to catch.
Tap the left mouse button do not press and hold but tap a fast as you can to raise the bar and stop tapping to lower it.
If all else fails fish for trash in your farm pond its slow but you will catch trash and it will give xp which in turn will give you a larger bar which will make fishing easier, do it to use up your last bit of energy before going to bed.
The other way is to do the crab pot bundle in the community center by foraging on the beach for shells and getting a crab from the hermit crab in the mines, crab pots will give fishing xp and once again make that darn fishing bar bigger.
Nakos Feb 15, 2019 @ 3:26pm 
Originally posted by Paralt:
Is it possible to play this game without fishing? I can't seem to learn how to catch a fish no matter how hard I try. I've read guides, watched videos, and am trying to do it at the supposedly most easy place to do it, the forest lake. I haven't caught a fish yet except for the very first one when I got the fishing pole. Makes me want to stop playing what is supposed to be a fun game.
Feeling like a loser not fun.

Fishing sucks. There are lots of us who hate it. Don't get discouraged, and don't let the pro-fishing crowd make you feel like your opinion is invalid either.

That having been said, even though I personally despise fishing, I have managed to master it enough to do the Community bundles.

Here's what you should do:

First off, try fishing in the Mountain Lake near Robin's house. The most common fish in that lake are Carp. Carp are sluggish. It is frequently possible to catch Carp without moving the green bar at all. If you hook something that's a lot jumpier than a Carp, don't worry about it, just let it escape. Use short casts, not long ones.

Second, Willy sells Trout Soup. Trout Soup gives you a +1 to fishing. It might not seem like much, but it does help in the beginning.

Third, fish in the ponds on your farm. You'll only catch trash, but it'll still give you some fishing skill (not much, but a little), and the junk you catch can be converted into useful building materials with a Recycling Machine.

Finally, complete the Crab Pot Bundle. The Crab Pot Bundle requires 5 items, but the selection you can choose from is quite large. Of those items, 4 are shells you can pick up on the beach, meaning no fishing required. The fifth item can be a crab. Crabs can be found in the mines, and are gathered by fighting, so again, no fishing required.

The reward is three Crab Pots. Bait them and leave them in a body of water, every day you'll get a "fish" of some sort. This will also give you fishing skill.

Once you've actually gotten some skill (via methods other than actual fishing) your green bar will get bigger, and catching the trickier stuff will seem a LOT easier.

Don't give up, even if you hate it, it's possible to do okay at it.
joebing15 Feb 15, 2019 @ 4:45pm 
I'd also suggest buying upgraded rods if you are able to. Attaching lures made it a little better, especially the cork one that made the green slider bigger.
I Kinda Fail Feb 15, 2019 @ 6:55pm 
Can you tell us how you're fishing and what the problem is so we can maybe help you learn to do it properly?

Best way I know how to explain it is, you're supposed to hold and release the mouse button. LOTS of people are under the impression you have to spamclick your mouse, for some reason.
dalgo Feb 16, 2019 @ 2:19am 
Everyone sucks at fishing when they start the game. It is the hardest skill to learn but also the most satisfying when you finally get it right.

By default the 'C' key mirrors the left mouse button and I find that easier to use. Hold C to raise your rod and release it to cast. That's the easy part. A strike is signified by an ! above your head - just tap C immediately. You will either catch trash of get a hit.

When you do get a hit, wait to see what the fish is going to do. Many of the spring fish hardly move at all. When they do move hold C to lift the green bar and release C to lower it. In practice I find it easier to tap C repeatedly, increasing the rate as the fish goes up the water column and slackening off as it drops.

Target the easiest fish to catch while you are learning. For instance (as already mentioned) carp in the mountain lake east of robin's house, plus anchovy, sardines and herrings from the beach.

Last edited by dalgo; Feb 16, 2019 @ 2:47am
Dgo Feb 16, 2019 @ 5:27am 
It's absolutely possible but let me tell ya same happened to me and got quite frustrated at first. Then with just little practice was actually super easy and w/o even watchin' tutos. The only pain in the butt was to lvl up from 9 to 10 which it honestly felt eternal in my current playthrough.

So u maybe just need a bit more practice?
Hollow Feb 16, 2019 @ 7:15am 
I'd overhaul fishing. At the moment it's too uncontrolled:
Frustrating new players while with the best rod and maximum skill the Trap Bobber (that makes fish escape slower) feels too mandatory for all the hard to catch fishes so that the other tackles aren't used so much, at least by me.

Regular tools have 4 stages:
basic -> copper -> iron -> gold -> iridium.

Rods get only 2:
basic -> +bait -> +bait & +tackle

I wouldn't mind a 3rd version that can have 2 different kinds of tackles equipped so that the Trap Bobber alone can be used along with some other kind of tackle.

To balance out the issue for starters their fishing skill should determine how hard to catch the fish is that bites: lower skill = easier to catch fish bites only, never any hard to catch fish (until the fishing skill is high enough). The fishing skill should be limited by the type of fishing rod used - no proceeding in skill with bad gearm but still be useful to catch better to best quality fish within that range. The type of rod should determine how fast a fish can be reeled in - fish that escapes more easily is harder to reel ine - requires better (or best) rod while the easy to catch fish can be reeled in fast. On top of that it'd be nice if treasure would be automatically caught if the fish is caught while the fishing bar rests on fish and treasure - even without the treasure bar being 100% filled yet. As for the "treasure": The rod type should also determine what's in there. I don't need 1x bait in my "treasure" for an Iridium Rod. A nice bonus would also be a reduced chance for seaweed and junk the better the fishing rod is: better rod = lower junk chance. Imo the tackle & bait also shouldn't suffer if there was no fish but just trash - as no biting & reeling took place.

In general the tooltips should also be more useful:
They should also state where, during which season(s) and from-to which time certain fish can be found, along with the sell value being listed for all quality types.

Alternatively higher fishing skill could also mean fish is reeled in faster and escapes slower (varying by fish type) and the better rods also add that same kind of bonus - which then could mean to remove the Trap Bobber from the game or decrease it's effect so that the other tackles also get their turn. As each individual type of fish could have it's own number that determines by how much that easy to catch & fast reeled in value is modified certain fish (legendary) could remain hard to catch.
Last edited by Hollow; Feb 16, 2019 @ 7:21am
frogprincess_q4 Feb 16, 2019 @ 2:47pm 
When I realised that I was able to level fishing even without catching anything I felt a lot happier about it, and now it's one of the most fun parts of the game for me.

I also didn't understand what I was supposed to be doing to start with. I thought I somehow was supposed to push the fish to the top with the green "bubble" instead of keeping the fish withing the bounds of the bubble. I can laugh about it now, but I was so confused at the time.
I Kinda Fail Feb 16, 2019 @ 6:30pm 
Originally posted by Hollow:
snip
They're adding a 4th "beginner's rod" that makes fish reel-ly easy to catch, with the condition that you can't get silver/gold/iridium star fish.

I do agree that better fishing rods should get more benefits. Maybe let bamboo have bait, fiberglass have tackle, iridium have 2 tackle? With each tier of fishing rod being able to catch silver, gold and iridium star fish, because right now the best kind of fish, without cheating, is gold star.
Originally posted by I Kinda Fail:
Originally posted by Hollow:
snip
They're adding a 4th "beginner's rod" that makes fish reel-ly easy to catch, with the condition that you can't get silver/gold/iridium star fish.

I do agree that better fishing rods should get more benefits. Maybe let bamboo have bait, fiberglass have tackle, iridium have 2 tackle? With each tier of fishing rod being able to catch silver, gold and iridium star fish, because right now the best kind of fish, without cheating, is gold star.
uh, evidence?
I Kinda Fail Feb 17, 2019 @ 12:51am 
Originally posted by Spectre Knight:
Originally posted by I Kinda Fail:
They're adding a 4th "beginner's rod" that makes fish reel-ly easy to catch, with the condition that you can't get silver/gold/iridium star fish.

I do agree that better fishing rods should get more benefits. Maybe let bamboo have bait, fiberglass have tackle, iridium have 2 tackle? With each tier of fishing rod being able to catch silver, gold and iridium star fish, because right now the best kind of fish, without cheating, is gold star.
uh, evidence?
Calm down dude, lol. You can look it up yourself and find it in about 2 minutes rather than assuming somebody's lying.

https://twitter.com/ConcernedApe/status/1093686536443293697
Paralt Feb 17, 2019 @ 10:11am 
OMG, I caught a carp! Only downhill from here, right?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 18 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Feb 15, 2019 @ 1:18pm
Posts: 18