Stardew Valley

Stardew Valley

Ver estatísticas:
Snowy Sprout 5 nov. 2021 às 23:57
Roleplay: I am Linus (ideas/discussion thread)
I was doing a challenge to sleep past year 1 and begin game play on year 2. I was watching the TV for recipes, though.

Then Marnie showed up and gave me a cat. So I had to get out of bed each day just to water the cat bowl.

Then I thought, heck, the world is full of forage just sitting there, gonna go to waste if I don't pick it. I should do that. Not plant any crops, but just pick forage and store it in a chest to see how much I get.

Then I was walking past people and thought how rude it would be not to just say hi.

Then I realized: I AM LINUS!

So I got curious. If all I did was gather weeds and forage, how much would that be worth in a year, if I never planted anything? Who could become a really good friend if I gifted them certain types of forage? Would anyone else be my friend after a year of only saying hi to them? What about garbage cans? How much could a year's worth of garbage add up to?

What about if I planted some seeds, but never watered, and only allowed rain to water my crops? If I'm Linus then I'm not a farmer, but surely I do believe in the power of natural rain. It would be a shame to let that power go to waste. What could I grow? What would it be worth? Would it make good gifts?

Then I wondered about fishing. Linus does fish, and sometimes sends you fish in the mail, and has the recipe for wild bait. What if I might fish, but only if I used wild bait (or the original bamboo pole)?

Then I wondered about mining. Linus has no need for rocks or gems, and I can't see him wanting to fight mobs. But he does find you in the mines if you pass out, so he definitely goes there.... Probably to forage mushrooms! So then I had a reason to mine, and figured Linus could just hold any gems/ores he found in a chest for a year until they were needed. He could also gift people with some of the gems. But his real reason for going there is to look for the Mushroom Floors.

I figured this playthrough would be best on the Beach farm, which gives the most interesting variety of foragables and loot crates. The intention is to do one year as Linus, just to see what you collect.
*You would try to fill Help Wanted requests, if you could.
*You would try to befriend people, if they didn't hate the stuff you had to offer.
*You would stay broke pretty much all the time, and put valuable things away into a chest and not sell them at all the first year.
*If you do get any seeds you could plant them but you wouldn't ever water them.

What would live? What skills would you raise? Who would love you?

After your year of hermitage, you could change your play style if you want, and continue as a regular player. Maybe by then, Linus could feel safe to come out of his shell?
Última alteração por Snowy Sprout; 6 nov. 2021 às 0:27
< >
A mostrar 16-30 de 38 comentários
Queen Droxxanna 7 nov. 2021 às 1:42 
I didn't say he didn't like artisan goods, I just don't see him make wine, since he's adverse to making money, and we never see him drinking in the saloon.
He loves blueberry cobbler, and yams, and Dish of the Sea, so I think if he did any farming, it would be for the ingredients of his two favorite meals:
blueberries, wheat, beets for sugar, sunflower for oil, and potatoes, and yams, and a pet chicken for eggs. And maybe a fish pond for the sardines, so he didn't have to spent too much time on the beach.
He might make juice from beets and potatoes, as well as pickled yams, and blueberry jelly.
He would also need a mill for the wheat and sugar, or have a trading arrangement with Pierre to exchange crops for baking ingredients.
Snowy Sprout 7 nov. 2021 às 5:15 
You seem to equate making wine with making money. I don't see it that way. I don't see him selling his wine, or beer, or mead, or any keg products really. I see him offering them as gifts to the townsfolk.

I don't see blueberries as a very viable crop under the conditions I've set, where watering is something he avoids. It's unlikely that natural rain would water a blueberry plant enough to bring it to harvest even once, let alone multiple times, so the cost per berry would be prohibitive unless he used a sprinkler. But again, sprinklers are super rare to receive as gifts or treasure, which is an artificial limit I have chosen to define this role with.

Beer is a very viable product he could make, which is liked by many people. Just because it's not his own favorite thing doesn't mean he wouldn't produce it for the sake of friendship.

I see Linus as a very friendly guy. Motivated by respect for every living thing, and a wish to live in a non-judgmental world. He has chosen to be a hermit not because he doesn't like people, but because he has experienced too much aggression from folks unwilling to respect his way of life. But in my roleplay, there is a bit more we can work with to change all that.

Maybe it's a roleplay of how Linus' life could have gone differently if he had just a bit of his own land, instead of merely squatting in the woods somewhere.
Snowy Sprout 7 nov. 2021 às 5:34 
II see now that I've made a major mistake! I should have chosen REMIXED bundles instead of regular.

Linus will never own animals, so it's not possible for him to complete the Animal bundle for the CC. Yet he will not go Joja route either. So his only hope for completion is to choose remixed bundles, and hope that "Animal Bundle" is not among them.

I"m not so very far along in my playthrough yet. This is worth a restart.

My next attempt will benefit from all I have learned this time. It's a shame I cannot know how things will be until I'm a ways into it. I cannot have the Animals Bundle in the Pantry, or the Home Cook's Bundle on the Bulletin Board.

That means I cannot know whether it's a viable playthrough until I've turned in my second collection either to the Pantry, or to the Fish Tank, to unlock the Bulletin Board.

I can know if the Pantry is a fail, at least, by the 6th. Probably.

Shame that I have to live in double-suspense now!
Última alteração por Snowy Sprout; 7 nov. 2021 às 5:41
Queen Droxxanna 7 nov. 2021 às 9:27 
lol. Perhaps out disagreement about Linus and wine stems from the fact that Linus has told me more of his back story, which is rare to hear from him unless you have 10 hearts with him.

He came from a very wealthy family, was spoiled rich, traveled the world in luxury and extravagance, but found no pleasure or satisfaction in that lifestyle in the end.
When he arrived in the valley, so saw the beauty of nature and found contentment at last in the peaceful country side.
He decided then to give up all his wealth, giving to those whose needed it, and live as simply as possible. Since wine, beer, etc, would remind him of his old life style that he rejected completely, I don't see him make it, even as gifts.

If you want crops without watering, try planting rice in the 3 squares around any pond or river, as then it doesn't need watering. Its a simple food i'm sure Linus would enjoy.
Tea plants also don't need watering and can be placed in the farm cave if you don't have a green house. They will grow as if indoors.

you know you can restart a new farm without deleting the currant one. Play them both and compare the results.
Snowy Sprout 7 nov. 2021 às 10:12 
Originalmente postado por soaringfreedom:
lol. Perhaps out disagreement about Linus and wine stems from the fact that Linus has told me more of his back story, which is rare to hear from him unless you have 10 hearts with him.

Being slightly arrogant here, hon. I've had 10 (or more) hearts with everyone in the game. I've got thousands of hours of play time, and I've earned my stripes. My interpretation of Linus is not less valid than yours.

Originalmente postado por soaringfreedom:
Since wine, beer, etc, would remind him of his old life style that he rejected completely, I don't see him make it, even as gifts.

I disagree. Making homebrew wine or beer or anything else would be a departure from the life of a rich person, who surely never put in that sort of work, but merely enjoyed the products of other people's labor. When a person changes from mere consumption to actual production, they are generally very proud of their work and eager to share it.

Perhaps Linus would feel uncomfortable with a particular brand of wine he once enjoyed as a rich man. That would have associations for him. But to brew/bottle his own would be a completely different taste and experience. Probably he would feel grateful to expand his appreciation for the various fruits of the valley, rather than the narrow range of grapes used in commercial wines.

You are allowed to have a different interpretation than me. This is not a battle. We can both play the way that makes sense to us.

Originalmente postado por soaringfreedom:
If you want crops without watering, try planting rice in the 3 squares around any pond or river, as then it doesn't need watering. Its a simple food i'm sure Linus would enjoy.
Tea plants also don't need watering and can be placed in the farm cave if you don't have a green house. They will grow as if indoors.

These are excellent suggestions! I didn't know about growing tea in the cave. That will be a great use for the space, after I no longer need it for the fruit it would produce!

I do plant rice seeds around water already, but I forgot that rice seeds are something you can now buy. I hadn't given them much thought, as they require a mill to be very useful. I'm guessing a mill would be a second-year project for Linus, as it would take a long time to collect the necessary 4 cloth to build it, merely from recycling newspapers.

I think he will build a mill though. He would feel better about grinding his own flour, and making his own sugar and rice, than he would feel about buying them. Anything that increases self-sufficiency is good, so long as it does not enslave another creature.
Queen Droxxanna 7 nov. 2021 às 11:07 
great thing about this game, is we can each have our own views, agree to disagree. It wont effect our own game play.
If you put a few tea plants in cave you will still get fruit from the bats, as long as there is room to walk around.
Yes I can see Linus using a mill powered by the wind.
Snowy Sprout 7 nov. 2021 às 11:11 
Originalmente postado por soaringfreedom:
great thing about this game, is we can each have our own views, agree to disagree. It wont effect our own game play.

:) Exactly! It's good to have different ways to see things, and fresh interpretations to bring.

It's fun to stretch our imaginations and come up with various explanations for how things are.
Queen Droxxanna 7 nov. 2021 às 11:44 
yes, I have gotten lots of play ideas from conversing in these types of discussions.
Twelvefield 7 nov. 2021 às 16:23 
Originalmente postado por soaringfreedom:
great thing about this game, is we can each have our own views, agree to disagree. It wont effect our own game play.
If you put a few tea plants in cave you will still get fruit from the bats, as long as there is room to walk around.
Yes I can see Linus using a mill powered by the wind.

I just have a few hours into the game, I don't think I see Linus the way you two do at all. The backstory was interesting, thanks for posting that!

What puzzles me about Linus is his collaboration with the Wizard. As far as I can tell, it's the Wizard that keeps you stuck in Pelican Town. You don't get to leave, ever, and the communication with the outside world seems to all be one way. If you do ever come to question your role in Stardew Valley, either the Wizard or some other paranormal force compels you into hallucinations and visions, often enough against your will. Through those visions, you get wrapped up in larger quests that further bind you into staying or settling.

Once you do that, you end up collecting money and power until you are the wealthiest entity in the valley... but to what end? The economy of Pelican Town seems to be geared towards making only you gain in prosperity - or at least the illusion of prosperity, since most of the goals seem to just give you things to accumulate other goals incrementally more quickly.

The other citizens are mostly stuck in limbo. As far as I can see, only Maru ever changes their clothes, for example. Linus seems to know, and so does the Wizard. There are a few times you can see them together, especially at Hallowe'en, but you can't interact with them. Very mysterious.

The other thing I cannot figure is the relationship between the townfolk and the people of the mines. Again, Linus seems to be a clue, since he lives right there and obviously goes into the mines. But again the Wizard provides a conundrum. I got a quest from him to go into the mines to slay some people and take their stuff. I cannot figure out why. He's a Wizard, certainly he can slay his own enemies himself. But more uncomfortably, I don't know why the Wizard would want me to murder the people in the mines at all. The resources from the mines aren't uncommon, but the people in the mines protect them with their lives. Other than that, though, the mine population seems to present to threat to Pelican Valley. No doubt I'm overthinking this, but one of the things I find interesting in the game are the clues Concerned Ape leaves regarding all of the characters. They all have facets to their lives that they hide for as long as they can. Likely they would all resent me barging into their lives if I didn't go out of my way to give them gifts.
Queen Droxxanna 7 nov. 2021 às 17:21 
The SVE mod provides a great deal of more back story, and other locations to visit outside of the valley, and a series of quests from the wizard. But I wont give anything away here.
Oh and there's a secret about the wizard and one of the town's people that takes some time and effort to learn.
Última alteração por Queen Droxxanna; 7 nov. 2021 às 17:27
Snowy Sprout 8 nov. 2021 às 0:02 
Originalmente postado por Twelvefield:

I just have a few hours into the game, I don't think I see Linus the way you two do at all. The backstory was interesting, thanks for posting that!

What puzzles me about Linus is his collaboration with the Wizard.

...you end up collecting money and power until you are the wealthiest entity in the valley... but to what end? The economy of Pelican Town seems to be geared towards making only you gain in prosperity - or at least the illusion of prosperity, since most of the goals seem to just give you things to accumulate other goals incrementally more quickly.

I was in a discussion group where it was suggested that the Wizard, the Junimos, and Linus are all connected somehow. That magical forces protect the Valley from fire, flood, or other damage, and even cause chopped trees to quickly regrow. Linus was mentioned as someone with "forest magic" or at least the ability to see Junimos. His own personal demons drove him away from society and wealth, but he is now part of their healing therapy.

The Wizard knows about the Junimos, and studies them, but does not interact with them directly. He does not have the true gift of "forest magic" because his academic (and somewhat arrogant) approach is not in line with their motivations. They know about him, but are wary of his intentions. He seems content to observe, for the most part, but also holds knowledge of how to create a Junimo Hut on the player's own land. The question that lingers is whether the Junimos living there are enslaved, or enjoying the hospitality?
Queen Droxxanna 8 nov. 2021 às 0:23 
You can see the full story of the wizard, the Juminos, Linus, and your own character if you use the SVE mod. Yes the wizard protects the valley and Linus is friends with the Juminos, but they are not enslaved in any way. The fact that after you finish the CC in the vanilla version, you get to hire the juminos to work on your farm, because they are happy with your efforts to restore the CC,, They actually do alot of work around the valley, (you know that already).

But with SVE, you get to visit their village in the woods, (if you can find it) and become close friends with one little fellow. Your affinity for the creatures of the woods bodes well for you and the wizard gives you even more magic skills.

On my farm I also have the mod BETTER Juminos, where I have to option to PAY the Juminos everyday, and they will not work until they get their payment. I'm happy to pay them since I have so much extra fruit and berries. By doing so they will also fertilize, water, and replant my garden. My Juminos are very happy.
Snowy Sprout 8 nov. 2021 às 7:45 
Originalmente postado por soaringfreedom:
You can see the full story of the wizard, the Juminos, Linus, and your own character if you use the SVE mod.

On my farm I also have the mod BETTER Juminos, where I have to option to PAY the Juminos everyday, and they will not work until they get their payment.

Since these are mods you are mentioning, I do not believe they are canon. One may choose to believe that storyline in their heart, if that is fun. Or one may choose to come up with any other storyline/scenario they prefer, if they are playing a vanilla game.

I'm sure you're just excited about the story the way you see it. But I take umbrage at the implication, however unintentional, that the story the way others see it is somehow less valid. It's important to maintain respect for alternate interpretations, and not state too emphatically that a particular storyline is THE story, if it is not part of the original game.
Snowy Sprout 8 nov. 2021 às 8:20 
Originalmente postado por Twelvefield:
... you end up collecting money and power until you are the wealthiest entity in the valley... but to what end? The economy of Pelican Town seems to be geared towards making only you gain in prosperity - or at least the illusion of prosperity, since most of the goals seem to just give you things to accumulate other goals incrementally more quickly.

I forgot to finish answering this point in my last post to you. Sorry!

I agree that the game is set up to be unbalanced in the player's favor, with the huge plot of land given to us for free, no taxes, no crop failures, no prices ever changing, no market ever having a glut and refusing to buy your products, and no disease or death in animals, and no risk of fire or tornado or other disasters. It's not very realistic. But of course, that is why it's a fun fantasy, about a world that pretty much always goes right, and where efforts pretty much always bring rewards. It is that soft guarantee which is so relaxing.

But your point about the illusion of prosperity is very key to my Linus playthrough. Linus has rejected the use of money or the accumulation of wealth, for the most part. It is an extremely different point of view from which to play the game.

It leaves one to wonder what the focus IS, if not money? To me the answer is friendship. Linus does not sell crops, and does not work hard at anything that isn't directly tied to his ability to help others or make friendships. Most of what he creates are to be used as gifts. If he collects more than he needs, it is supposed to just sit in a chest and not get sold, because it's just my own curiosity about what can be collected.

Finding ways to help the Junimos and the community by completing the CC is extremely tricky, given the assumption that players will own animals which Linus does not. It's a problem I haven't come up with a good solution for. My best answer so far is to use remixed bundles and just hope the animal ones are not included, and restart a playthrough if they are.
Twelvefield 9 nov. 2021 às 14:49 
Thank you all for the thoughtful answers and the avoidance of spoilers! My wife and I have had some extensive discussions about the Juminos. She concluded that they aren't slaves, but I feel that they are being held in the region much like we are. Not hostages, but not free, either. Maybe Juminos are the spirits of the other players who could not leave (EDIT: I wonder how Grandpa* ever managed to leave?!) . People don't die in Stardew Valley, although creatures do. Maybe the townspeople envy the mine people of their mortality. That would explain why Harvey gets so little business, and why he is so dishevelled and unorganized. Maybe the machines Maru works on are intended to kill all the people and finally release them from an endless life in Pelican town.

It's a little clearer I think in Haunted Chocolatier, but also more sinister. You have ghosts who work for you, but there's only one way to make ghosts.

Linus' rejection of prosperity is exactly why I wanted to comment on this thread. My wife is doing an anti-prosperity run, but she's accumulated a quarter of a million in gold. I called her out on that as a Big Fail, which is why I am typing this from the couch downstairs rather than my own bed.

I don't know what the goal of Stardew Valley is either. I've been thinking a lot on this. Friendship is fine, I won't argue to say no. Wealth isn't the goal, as you don't get any farther than when you start, all you do is gain more stuff. Achievement, perhaps. There is a sort of endgame with Master Qi that has you running around a bit. But the quests aren't any different from the very first thing you do at the bulletin board, they just are larger in scale. They don't seem to drive much narrative.

Here's my guess: every citizen except you and possibly Maru represents a psychological facet of the creator, Concerned Ape. I believe he went out of his way to compartmentalize his own personality and then bring it forth as each of the citizens. In essence, farming Stardew Valley is the same as playing inside the very brain of Concerned Ape himself.

I consider Maru the single outlier as apart from your player character she is the only person I know in Pelican Town that changes their clothes. Unless, of course, Concerned Ape likes dressing up as a female nurse. I can see that, and it would make a lot of sense. No judgement: I love nurses myself.

*EDIT: I know next to nothing about Grandpa. My wife tells me that he gives a performance review later in the game, and that you get a rating. Crass as it may be, getting a good rating from Grandpa might be the only worthwhile goal of the game. If so, I fear Concerned Ape has father issues.

Thanks for reading through my rambling posts. I enjoy sharing my ideas as I want to believe my view is unique, but I get a lot out of reading about what other players are thinking. There is a wide range of interpretation regarding life in Stardew Valley. Nobody seems to play it the same way, which is very interesting considering how limited the game map is.
Última alteração por Twelvefield; 9 nov. 2021 às 15:02
< >
A mostrar 16-30 de 38 comentários
Por página: 1530 50

Postado a: 5 nov. 2021 às 23:57
Comentários: 38