Haley use to love diamonds but no longer does?

[Wolfei]

Haley used to love diamonds but upon playing stardew again for like the first time in a 1 year, I gave her a diamond for her birthday but got no love response so checked the wiki and it's no longer listed as a loved item for Haley...

am I hallucinating this? Did Haley ever love diamonds? I'm so confused.... someone please clarify this for me cause I can't find any patch notes that tell me it was changed.

[The Mighty Mulletman]

Weren't diamonds a universal love? I think they changed that.

[darkdisciple1313]

I think if you keep giving certain characters the same things without variation, they do get a little meh about it. I usually placate Haley with a few different things (including beer...nothing like a drunk wife, I guess...), and I've yet to not get a positive response. I might try the diamonds multiple times on the PS4 version, just to see if it's a glitch or if it's now implemented as not being one of her things.

And here I thought it was a lot of work keeping the damn chickens happy...

[Wolfei]

Originally posted by darkdisciple1313:

I think if you keep giving certain characters the same things without variation, they do get a little meh about it. I usually placate Haley with a few different things (including beer...nothing like a drunk wife, I guess...), and I've yet to not get a positive response. I might try the diamonds multiple times on the PS4 version, just to see if it's a glitch or if it's now implemented as not being one of her things.

And here I thought it was a lot of work keeping the damn chickens happy...

I've never had that issue where giving characters a lot of the one thing they love will cause them to no longer love it. All I know is Haley use to love diamonds and now no longer does :( When did they change that? I thought it fit Haley really well that she had a love for diamonds.

If you're having trouble finding things Haley likes, she also likes pink cake :)

[darkdisciple1313]

Originally posted by Wolfei:

Originally posted by darkdisciple1313:

I think if you keep giving certain characters the same things without variation, they do get a little meh about it. I usually placate Haley with a few different things (including beer...nothing like a drunk wife, I guess...), and I've yet to not get a positive response. I might try the diamonds multiple times on the PS4 version, just to see if it's a glitch or if it's now implemented as not being one of her things.

And here I thought it was a lot of work keeping the damn chickens happy...

I've never had that issue where giving characters a lot of the one thing they love will cause them to no longer love it. All I know is Haley use to love diamonds and now no longer does :( When did they change that? I thought it fit Haley really well that she had a love for diamonds.

If you're having trouble finding things Haley likes, she also likes pink cake :)

I honestly haven't experienced that yet, since I do vary what I give each person (except a few who I ply with beer, just because), but it would make sense if that became a thing.

"Here, honey, I bought you another Porsche!"

"Great dear, I'll just put it with the other 138 in the backyard. Luv ya, kiss-kiss!"