The Wizard's daughter? (OMG SPOILERS LUL)

[Greywolf]

So yeah it has long been assumed that Abigail is the Wizard's daughter yes? Well truth be told that is actually false, the Wizard's daughter is actually Emily, Caroline just gets a little action on the side, pretty sure all the women of Stardew Valley have slept with the Wizard at one point or another, he is quite the playa!

[Vroomi]

Where'd you get that from?

[I Kinda Fail]

I mean... blue hair isn't too much of a stretch from purple hair, but Haley's also her sister... Emily does have more spiritual juju than others, but I think the game implies it's Abigail through dialogue with Pierre and Abby? I never talked to Caroline much...

[Greywolf]

Originally posted by I Kinda Fail:

I mean... blue hair isn't too much of a stretch from purple hair, but Haley's also her sister... Emily does have more spiritual juju than others, but I think the game implies it's Abigail through dialogue with Pierre and Abby? I never talked to Caroline much...

Well Haley does wonder if Emily is her sister you know, since they are so different like woah!

Besides the only evidence that suggests that Abigail is his daughter is Caroline saying she likes to go for walks around the wizard tower and unless the wizard is so virile that any woman walking within a certain radius of his tower gets pregers I think it is safe to say just walking is not enough to get you pregers.

[I Kinda Fail]

Well it's more because Abby says she hasn't died her hair in a long time, and it stays purple, and that Pierre wonders if Abby is his real daughter...

[Greywolf]

Never seen those convos

[Nakos]

Yeah.. the game strongly implies that it's Abby.

Abby likes adventuring and is facinated by the occult.
The Wizard had a catastrophic breakup with his own wife due to an indiscression on his part.
Caroline mentions how she used to go wander out in the woods near the tower
Pierre wonders if Abby is really his daughter.

The dialogues in question don't come up all that often, but if you talk to them, they do eventually mention it.

http://stardewvalleywiki.com/Wizard

[rad rat ray]

caroline already says that abigail's natural hair color isn't purple, and abigail says she dyes it quite a lot. I don't think caroline seems to be the type to have an affair either

maybe his daughter's penny, since her dad is never mentioned, or maybe it's jas?

[EnigmaticBeast]

Originally posted by rad rat ray:

caroline already says that abigail's natural hair color isn't purple, and abigail says she dyes it quite a lot. I don't think caroline seems to be the type to have an affair either

maybe his daughter's penny, since her dad is never mentioned, or maybe it's jas?

Abigail says she dyed it ONCE and it never faded from purple, she also has an interest in the occult and if you read what Caroline says properly she said she used to VISIT the tower as in go INSIDE BEFORE she met pierre, not after, but BEFORE she met her husband

[rad rat ray]

Originally posted by SHLobo:

Originally posted by rad rat ray:

caroline already says that abigail's natural hair color isn't purple, and abigail says she dyes it quite a lot. I don't think caroline seems to be the type to have an affair either

maybe his daughter's penny, since her dad is never mentioned, or maybe it's jas?

Abigail says she dyed it ONCE and it never faded from purple, she also has an interest in the occult and if you read what Caroline says properly she said she used to VISIT the tower as in go INSIDE BEFORE she met pierre, not after, but BEFORE she met her husband

when I said dyes it quite a lot I mean when she asks you "what should I dye my hair tonight" etc. though for the sake of keeping the same character sprite concernedape doesn't actually visually change it when that happens

either way, she was born with the same hair color as pierre, not the wizard

she would've had to have met and married pierre extremely quickly after banging the wizard which seems unrealistic, not to mention the wizard seemed to imply the whole incident with the witch happened pretty recently rather than 20+ years ago

imo abigail is just a rebellious type of character that differs greatly from her parents, it's pretty common