Community center reasonable or old fashioned (spoiler)

[***]

I just finished community center, and have doubt choosing,
which is more benefit for player, choosing reasonable or ol fashioned?

[Pixel Peeper]

Edit: totally misunderstood the question.

One results in a fight, the other in a speech.

Mechanically, nothing changes.

[Cohnway]

Either way's good. Pierre's got a good right arm. He'll tell you that himself.

[***]

Thanks for the information, I read Pierre's shop will open all day if choose old fashioned, what about if we choose be reasonable? is it the same?

[Pixel Peeper]

Pierre does open 7 days a week if you run Joja out of town.

I don't know what happens to him if you side with Joja. Possibly nothing. The advantage there is that the JojaMart has much better opening hours (9:00 to 23:00).

Essentially, the Community Center path is more complex but more rewarding, while the Joja path is much simpler (you just throw gold directly at it) and more convenient, but not as rewarding.

[Rjazz]

Originally posted by ***:

Thanks for the information, I read Pierre's shop will open all day if choose old fashioned, what about if we choose be reasonable? is it the same?

Same thing happens if you choose reasonable over old-fashioned.

Honestly, just depends on which cutscene you want to trigger. Both lead to Joja being run out of town and Pierre opening 7 days a week.

[***]

Okay thanks all now I feel assured and ready to make choice,
game save system made me having doubts.