Store Page
Higurashi When They Cry Hou - Ch.2 Watanagashi
All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews

Higurashi When They Cry Hou - Ch.2 Watanagashi

Store Page
View Stats:
Global Achievements
Raoul[GER] Jan 1, 2016 @ 2:00pm
(Spoiler) Question
As we know, it is Shion who pretends to be Mion all the time.
Now at the end of this chapter, we get to the prison where Mion is held (Keiichi thinks it is Shion).
I am now at the part where the imprisoned Mion is talking to Shion and saying "..........Mion, my big sister. I beg you [...]"
Why would the real Mion call her sister Mion as well?! It is her sister and she should know it is Shion, or did she lose her mind?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 22 comments
Wasa Jan 1, 2016 @ 2:01pm 
She lost her mind.
#1
Ohagi-Chan Jan 1, 2016 @ 2:24pm 
Maybe your murderer was actually Mion all along? :beatmeat:
#2
Raoul[GER] Jan 1, 2016 @ 2:47pm 
Originally posted by Ohagi-Chan:
Maybe your murderer was actually Mion all along? :beatmeat:
No, Mion is my best friend :steamsad:

:steammocking:
#3
Lucius Jan 1, 2016 @ 6:11pm 
Originally posted by Ohagi-Chan:
Maybe your murderer was actually Mion all along? :beatmeat:
Haha, never. A little spoiler here but...
Mion is the only main character who never kills or turn psychotic in the entire series, possibly including Rika to some extent.
Last edited by Lucius; Jan 1, 2016 @ 6:11pm
#4
Ohagi-Chan Jan 1, 2016 @ 6:55pm 
Originally posted by Ominous Flare:
Originally posted by Ohagi-Chan:
Maybe your murderer was actually Mion all along? :beatmeat:
Haha, never. A little spoiler here but...
Mion is the only main character who never kills or turn psychotic in the entire series, possibly including Rika to some extent.

Lol, you think so?
#5
Lucius Jan 1, 2016 @ 8:56pm 
Originally posted by Ohagi-Chan:
Originally posted by Ominous Flare:
Haha, never. A little spoiler here but...
Mion is the only main character who never kills or turn psychotic in the entire series, possibly including Rika to some extent.

Lol, you think so?
It's revealed in the answer arcs that every single time "Mion" killed someone, it was Shion in her guise.
#6
TheGoldenSmurf Jan 2, 2016 @ 5:02pm 
Originally posted by RaoulGER:
As we know, it is Shion who pretends to be Mion all the time.
Now at the end of this chapter, we get to the prison where Mion is held (Keiichi thinks it is Shion).
I am now at the part where the imprisoned Mion is talking to Shion and saying "..........Mion, my big sister. I beg you [...]"
Why would the real Mion call her sister Mion as well?! It is her sister and she should know it is Shion, or did she lose her mind?

If you actually read Meakashi you would know the reason;
#7
Ohagi-Chan Jan 2, 2016 @ 5:12pm 
That, or Matsuribayashi, which repeats the answer several times, to make sure you know why.
#8
Chaos_Alfa Jan 3, 2016 @ 6:11am 
This thread should be moved to the Spoiler Discussion sub-forum, because it has spoilers from a future chapter.

On the general forum only spoilers from the current chapter are allowed when spoiler tagged. Spoilers of future chapter go into the Spoiler Discussion sub-forum.
Last edited by Chaos_Alfa; Jan 3, 2016 @ 6:18am
#9
CelesteValentine Jan 6, 2016 @ 2:23pm 
Yeah thanks for ruining a future chapter for me.
I came on here after completing Chapter 2 hoping to avoid spoilers. Great.
#10
Raoul[GER] Jan 6, 2016 @ 2:48pm 
Originally posted by Cel:
Yeah thanks for ruining a future chapter for me.
I came on here after completing Chapter 2 hoping to avoid spoilers. Great.
you try to avoid spoilers but you read a thread which clearly says SPOILER
#11
Ohagi-Chan Jan 6, 2016 @ 5:02pm 
This is a thread that was destined to turn spoiler, since it was askimg a question that CAN'T be answered by ehat you know in Chapter 2. As Chaos_Alfa said, it should be moved to the spoiler foeum, but really, it should have begun there.
#12
CelesteValentine Jan 7, 2016 @ 1:58am 
Originally posted by RaoulGER:
Originally posted by Cel:
Yeah thanks for ruining a future chapter for me.
I came on here after completing Chapter 2 hoping to avoid spoilers. Great.
you try to avoid spoilers but you read a thread which clearly says SPOILER

You posted it under the discussion for Chapter Two so I expected it to be ABOUT Chapter Two. You should have clearly labelled it as a spoiler for future chapters or not posted it in the general thread at all.
#13
Chaos_Alfa Jan 7, 2016 @ 3:18am 
Originally posted by Ohagi-Chan:
This is a thread that was destined to turn spoiler, since it was askimg a question that CAN'T be answered by ehat you know in Chapter 2. As Chaos_Alfa said, it should be moved to the spoiler foeum, but really, it should have begun there.
The problem of knowing that this thread would turn into a future chapters spoiler thread is that it started as such as of the opening post. The fist sentence of the opening post is a spoiler already. There are not enough sentence for someone to deduce if this thread is about current chapter spoilers or future chapters spoilers without getting spoiled about future chapter revelation.

The solution would have been if the Opening Poster had read the Spoiler Guidelines and created his/her thread in the correct sub-forum.

Also MangaGamer could have moved this thread to the correct sub-forum, I have already reported this thread ages ago.

Originally posted by RaoulGER:
Originally posted by Cel:
Yeah thanks for ruining a future chapter for me.
I came on here after completing Chapter 2 hoping to avoid spoilers. Great.
you try to avoid spoilers but you read a thread which clearly says SPOILER

Originally posted by http://steamcommunity.com/app/410890/discussions/0/490125737471001420/:
The forums are split into a General board and a Spoiler board. Please avoid any spoilers (even in spoiler tags) for story details beyond Watanagashi on the General board. There are still people new to the series who would like to experience it and discuss it without having things ruined for them, so please respect that.

Spoilers for material contained in Watanagashi and posted on the General board should be placed in spoiler tags. Discussion of previous chapters is allowed to go unmarked in the body of a post, but please refrain from putting spoilers in post titles.

If you wish to discuss content beyond Watanagashi, that should take place on the Spoiler board. The spoiler tag requirement is more lenient on that board, but do try to be reasonable about what you post out in the open.

If you see spoiler discussion happening in the wrong place, feel free to report it. Spoiler threads will just be moved to the other board. But because moderators can't edit posts, individual posts with spoilers in otherwise compliant threads will be deleted--along with any subsequent posts that quote/refer to the spoiler content.


EDIT: The thread has finally been moved.
Last edited by Chaos_Alfa; Jan 7, 2016 @ 4:33pm
#14
megabyte Jan 10, 2016 @ 12:37pm 
I have to admit, that line bugged me because otherwise I think they did a great job of hiding the truth throughout the whole episode while still dropping hints.

Did you guys notice that the day after the switch was made, Shion's theme song from the cafe plays when we see 'Mion' coming to school?

We also have subtle hints about who is who based on the Satoshi. In episode 1, Mion was sad to see him 'transfer', but in episode 2, Shion is angry that he 'transfered'. When 'Mion' was shaking the ladder and talking about Satoshi, it should have given away who she really was if anyone was thinking rationally at the time.

To be fair, I completely missed these clues on my first go, as I was primed to think of supernatural causes instead of natural ones.

Getting back to the discussion at hand, I think the most rational explanation is that Mion was broken at that point, and ready to do whatever Shion wanted her to do, letting her be 'Mion' as much as she wanted to be.

It's very tragic.
#15
< >
Showing 1-15 of 22 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Higurashi When They Cry Hou - Ch.2 Watanagashi > Spoiler Discussions > Topic Details
Date Posted: Jan 1, 2016 @ 2:00pm
Posts: 22

Discussions Rules and Guidelines