How do i prove Brogar's guilty?

[ManBoyBoyManBoy]

I have gone around and collected the money as he asked. I also talked with Rachel, because i am going to expose him. i have collected the money from everyone, except danny, I can't find him. who is going to object paying the protection fee? how do expose Brogar?

[Finarfin]

Did you talk to the guy at the farm in the swamp? I think you might need to get him to admit that Brogar is taking protection money from him, as well.

[ManBoyBoyManBoy]

you mean Rhobart? i took his money because it had no effect on rachel that he objected

[Finarfin]

Yeah, that's who I mean. I thought when you first talked to him, though, he asked you if you were there to collect protection money. I think you need to learn this to have evidence against Brogar.

[Disappear]

Just kick his ass in the arena.. gotta play around rge rules with outlaws_ otherwise you might consider moving in with the monastery loonies.)
On the subject: you could grass him out when you speak to the Don, but I don't know what happens if you do.

[ManBoyBoyManBoy]

Disappear: :) What do you mean "grass him"?
Jeff: I talked to Rhobart and he replied with the question if i was there to collect money. then i got a choice between taking the money and letting him wait. First, I let him wait to tell Rachel about Rhobart protesting to pay. It had no reacti9on to Rachel, she wouldn't talk to me. Then I went back to Rhobart to take his money. I also have collected the money from everyone else, except Danny. Do you know how to solve it? :)

[Finarfin]

Actually, you know what? I'm on Chapter 4 and I still have the open quest Power Struggle in the bandit camp. So I guess I never actually resolved it, either. You could always check a guide on the Web.

[ManBoyBoyManBoy]

well, thanks anyway, i'll try that :)

[lionhart]

That quest is a bit of a red herring because you can't actually prove that Brogar is guilty. Well you can, but no one will do anything about it. You have to defeat him in the arena no matter what. If you defeat him, and if you have collected enough evidence against him, you can tell him to back down otherwise you will expose him to the Don, and he'll agree. That officially ends the Power Struggle quest.

[D'amarr from Darshiva]

Came here via Google after running into something similar.

The quest journal entry gives the names of the people to visit for the protection money. There is no Danny on that list, and that wasn't my issue anyway.

My roleplaying choice has been to keep the money and then go to Rachel in hope that it would lead to an option, but it doesn't. The quest really is only about collecting the money, helping Rhobart, negotiating with Oscar about "staying friends" and then deciding on whether to give Brogar the money or keep it. I've not encountered any resistance collecting the money, except Rhobart requesting protection and pointing at the Bog Bodies near the waterfall.

Anyway, afterwards I've walked around in the camp with three pieces of that broken sword and no options, asking myself whether the arena fighting and gambling stuff is the only way forward. And that's when I've done some searching at Google.


This is another attempt at trying to get in into Risen, and I've not quit early at the bandits camp this time - but I'm not excited yet either. Sam is the only exception so far, because when talking to him repeatedly he contributed a lot more than the others.

I'll probably reload the savegame to return to arrival at the camp, then use LP and gold differently.

[ManBoyBoyManBoy]

Thank you, this was really helpful!

[Adacanavar]

You can also turn him into the don during your first meeting with him.