a real gmod 2

[Spamton-G-Spamton]

If hlx/projectwhitesands is flatscreen and valve releases a source 2 sdk to the public maybe hopefully someone will make a sandbox mod for it and that game can be a real gmod 2 not a roblox clone

[Lady Alcina Dimitrescu]

??

Why you hate S&Box this much ?
Jesus christ, it's basically Garry's Mod 2, even if you want to admit or not.
It uses Source 2, it has more flexibility for mod development.

[Spamton-G-Spamton]

i guess you're right

[user]

it does look like a roblox clone though, and it doesn't have that gmod feel like the playermodels and everything

[user]

im gonna be real disappointed if people choose s&box over gmod

[EldritchGuardian]

Reply to: Lady Alcina
For s&box the hatred is the fact that it is not rooted to a specific game, Garry's mod itself is rooted to HL2 and is a really big part of it's identity, many of the props and such are from HL2 and based on its rooting it has a familiarish environment and a bunch of essential parts already included. Also the ability to play most of the older source engine games very well has its benefits where modding it is easy especially for HL2 yet S&Box seems more like a tech demo (to me at least) than an infinite sandbox game, also the switch from using the workshop for mods also make people annoyed to to the lack of support for that.
Reply to: Spamtron
I did see that Garry's mod's old competitor rose from the dead, so it may happen and make Garry rethink S&box if he makes a Garry's mod clone on source 2

[lamarr232]

Originally posted by Lady Alcina Dimitrescu:

??

Why you hate S&Box this much ?
Jesus christ, it's basically Garry's Mod 2, even if you want to admit or not.
It uses Source 2, it has more flexibility for mod development.

It's really more like it's Roblox and not Garry's Mod 2. That's the reason why some people don't like it, because they were expecting GMod 2 and not source 2 roblox

[user]

why doesn't garry just make a "Garrys mod: Source2" game

[user]

that would be the real gmod 2

[Siluva]

S&Box is Gmod 2 and use the Source 2 engine.

[user]

it is not, it is not garrys mod in any way

[user]

what it is is roblox in source2

[Lady Alcina Dimitrescu]

Originally posted by user:

im gonna be real disappointed if people choose s&box over gmod

Ngl I probably will. Gmod is getting boring

[Lady Alcina Dimitrescu]

Originally posted by lamarr232:

Originally posted by Lady Alcina Dimitrescu:

??

Why you hate S&Box this much ?
Jesus christ, it's basically Garry's Mod 2, even if you want to admit or not.
It uses Source 2, it has more flexibility for mod development.

It's really more like it's Roblox and not Garry's Mod 2. That's the reason why some people don't like it, because they were expecting GMod 2 and not source 2 roblox

It is completely your opinion. I respect that.
But it doesn't look like roblox AT ALL for me.
It is refreshing to have something new.

S&Box is Garry's Mod 2 but of course, since it's not ready right now, and all the youtubers leading you people like a shephard.
It's not for you guys to think S&Box is bad.

[Lady Alcina Dimitrescu]

Originally posted by EldritchGuardian:

Reply to: Lady Alcina
For s&box the hatred is the fact that it is not rooted to a specific game, Garry's mod itself is rooted to HL2 and is a really big part of it's identity, many of the props and such are from HL2 and based on its rooting it has a familiarish environment and a bunch of essential parts already included. Also the ability to play most of the older source engine games very well has its benefits where modding it is easy especially for HL2 yet S&Box seems more like a tech demo (to me at least) than an infinite sandbox game, also the switch from using the workshop for mods also make people annoyed to to the lack of support for that.
Reply to: Spamtron
I did see that Garry's mod's old competitor rose from the dead, so it may happen and make Garry rethink S&box if he makes a Garry's mod clone on source 2

1-You can reply to comments

2-No, you can't play any other source game on Garry's Mod. Only their maps and built-in game modes.
3-The only reason why this game has a character, is because it used Half-Life 2 assets for years and haven't seen any change. People are nostalgic and refuse new things.

Which is a 100% boomer move.

4-Workshop right now is a mess. All the mods are either made terribly or just a copy and paste. There are tons of conflicts and Engine is way too limited. Compare to S&Box (Gmod2)
Garry's Mod is far more limited.

5-Workshop Developers doesn't have to satisfy anyone, they make mods with their free-time. If Garry's Mod 2 gets more support for mods, and it becomes easier to make mods there, they will switch to that (obviously).

People need to stop attaching to old games. It's such a bad habit, prevents you from actually appreciate new things.

I love old games too, but I would not prefer them over new and actually improved games.

[Lady Alcina Dimitrescu]

Also, S&Box indeed a tech demo right now.
Garry Newman has limited access to Source 2 code, which causes S&Box development to stutter and slowdown a bit.

If you think Source 2 looks like Roblox, you either play another game or just make stuff out of your arse.

Show me 1 video proof of how S&Box looks like Roblox.