RANKING THE GAMES IN TERMS OF DIFFICULTY AND SCARINESS

[therawrmaster]

Of all the FNAF games, which one do you think was hardest? Put them in a list of hardest to easiest. Then a list of which one was the scariest to the one that was the least scary.

For me, this is what I think in terms of difficulty:

1. FNAF 2
2. FNAF 1
3. FNAF 3
4. FNAF 4

For me, FNAF 2 is the hardest because there are way too many animatronics and things to worry about. The flashlight can run out of battery and you always have to be paying attention to the music box, along with all the animatronics.

FNAF 1 comes really close to beating FNAF 2 just because I can never get past night 2 in FNAF 1. I always run out of power and it's really hard to not run out of it until 6 am.

Then FNAF 3 because of the whole ventilation and audio and visual stuff always needing a reboot. And FNAF 4 was pretty easy for me. I literally passed nights 1-4 in 20 minutes or less without dying once. And I always got the whole plushtrap minigame right. The only thing is I just can't get past night 5. That's all I'm stuck on.

In terms of scariest to least scary, this is what I think:

1. FNAF 4
2. FNAF 1
3. FNAF 2
4. FNAF 3

FNAF 4 is really scary. Especially since it's set in a home. A home is a very scary location in a game or a horror movie. It's also scary how the lights flicker and you can see the closet door move. And what makes it scariest of all is when you go to the door and listen for that breathing. Not knowing if you're about to die. That really makes this game the scariest.

FNAF 1 is second because it just a sort of scary atmosphere about it. I don't know how to explain it. It was the first game of the series, but almost the scariest. It was the scariest until FNAF 4 came out. It's a dark place and the animatronics are creepy. Maybe because it was the first game of the series that it just has this sort of scariness about it.

Then FNAF 2 is just creepy, especially with that balloon boy laughing and saying stuff. Nothing is scarier than hearing a little kid's voice saying creepy stuff, especially in a horror film or game. Then when those shadow animatronics come into the room and the lights flicker on and off, that's scary. Or when balloon boy or mangle enters the room and you know that all hope is lost, you already lost the game.

For me, FNAF 3 was not scary at all. I never really got scared by the hallucinations or springtrap. I don't know, but that's just me.

So after me saying all this, what about you guys? What do you guys think?

[💜Jentrap💚]

Difficulty:

FNAF 2
FNAF 4
FNAF 3
FNAF 1

Spooky Scary Scale:

same as difficulty.

FNAF 2 is the perfect FNAF in my opinion. Nobody will agree with me on this but, I find the designs of Withered Chica and Withered Bonnie the scariest designs in the series, and dare I say, scarier than the Nightmare designs from FNAF 4. Something about Chica's eyes popping out, having no hands and arms stretched out straight across (or as I like to nickname them, Jesus arms), and her mouth broken scares the crap out of me. Similar things go for Withered Bonnie. He has no face (just those glowing eyes) and one arm. That's just creepy. Moving on to gameplay, having to multitask is difficult, but that is what makes the game scary for me. Plus, when/if I mess up, I literally don't see the jumpscares coming (only exception being if I see an animatronic right in front of me, but that in itself is scary as hell), and that's a really good factor in horror games like this. Overall, FNAF 2 is (and always will be, presuming FNAF 4 really is the last game) the perfect FNAF game and it's everything I could ever ask for in a sequel.

FNAF 4, though not as scary or difficult as FNAF 2, still does a really good job at being scary while being difficult. The game taking place in a house is already a very spooky factor. It does not help that I'm a house with very limited technology and I can't have a tablet or a security system because this game is set in the 80's (thank god I wasn't alive back then). Without technology, I have to depend on my hearing skills (and they aren't very good). Having to run to the door just to wait until I hear breathing is suspenseful, and if I mess up, jumpscares are there to ruin my night. The only thing keeping it from being the scariest is fearing Withered Chica and Bonnie in FNAF 2 (I still have nightmares about them >_<) and PLUSHTRAP IS A CUTIE!!!!

FNAF 3 is not that scary or that hard. In case you forgot or don't know, I am the person who wrote the Springtrap is my Senpai review for FNAF 3. The review is on my profile if you want to check it out. The only thing keeping this game from being at the rock bottom of my list is the fact the suspense comes after the Phantom jumpscares and while I'm fixing errors.

FNAF 1, when I first saw it, was scary. However, now I can breeze through the game with absolutely no suspense or screams. It's because once you learn a certain technique, the game becomes way too easy and not scary at all.




Edit, adding in TL;DR:

FNAF 2 is perfect due to having to multitask (very hard), mostly unpredictable jumpscares (predictable ones are scary too) and Withered Chica and Bonnie have the scariest designs of the series.

FNAF 4 has an spooky atmosphere and relying on hearing skills can be difficult at times. Only things keeping it from topping FNAF 2 are Withered Chica/Bonnie are scary and Plushtrap is cute.

FNAF 3, read above

FNAF 1, read above

[💜Jentrap💚]

Originally posted by Roy:

Originally posted by Plushia LaTrap:

Difficulty:

FNAF 2
FNAF 4
FNAF 3
FNAF 1

Spooky Scary Scale:

same as difficulty.

FNAF 2 is the perfect FNAF in my opinion. Nobody will agree with me on this but, I find the designs of Withered Chica and Withered Bonnie the scariest designs in the series, and dare I say, scarier than the Nightmare designs from FNAF 4. Something about Chica's eyes popping out, having no hands and arms stretched out straight across (or as I like to nickname them, Jesus arms), and her mouth broken scares the crap out of me. Similar things go for Withered Bonnie. He has no face (just those glowing eyes) and one arm. That's just creepy. Moving on to gameplay, having to multitask is difficult, but that is what makes the game scary for me. Plus, when/if I mess up, I literally don't see the jumpscares coming (only exception being if I see an animatronic right in front of me, but that in itself is scary as hell), and that's a really good factor in horror games like this. Overall, FNAF 2 is (and always will be, presuming FNAF 4 really is the last game) the perfect FNAF game and it's everything I could ever ask for in a sequel.

FNAF 4, though not as scary or difficult as FNAF 2, still does a really good job at being scary while being difficult. The game taking place in a house is already a very spooky factor. It does not help that I'm a house with very limited technology and I can't have a tablet or a security system because this game is set in the 80's (thank god I wasn't alive back then). Without technology, I have to depend on my hearing skills (and they aren't very good). Having to run to the door just to wait until I hear breathing is suspenseful, and if I mess up, jumpscares are there to ruin my night. The only thing keeping it from being the scariest is fearing Withered Chica and Bonnie in FNAF 2 (I still have nightmares about them >_<) and PLUSHTRAP IS A CUTIE!!!!

FNAF 3 is not that scary or that hard. In case you forgot or don't know, I am the person who wrote the Springtrap is my Senpai review for FNAF 3. The review is on my profile if you want to check it out. The only thing keeping this game from being at the rock bottom of my list is the fact the suspense comes after the Phantom jumpscares and while I'm fixing errors.

FNAF 1, when I first saw it, was scary. However, now I can breeze through the game with absolutely no suspense or screams. It's because once you learn a certain technique, the game becomes way too easy and not scary at all.

I cant read all that. ;_;

I guess people don't have time for reading long things nowadays. I guess I'll edit my post to include a TL;DR. *sigh*

[💜Jentrap💚]

Just letting everyone know I now added in a TL;DR for those who can't read long things for whatever reason.

[💜Jentrap💚]

Originally posted by The Marionette:

DON'T LET DANK MEMES BE DREAMS!!!!

Yesterday, you said tomorrow, SO JUST DO IT, MAKE YOUR DREAMS COME TRUE!

[💜Jentrap💚]

Originally posted by The Marionette:

JUST... *does the shia labeouf hand in hand thing* DO IT!!!!

Some people dream of success while you're gonna wake up and work hard at it! Nothing is impossible!

[💜Jentrap💚]

Originally posted by The Marionette:

Uhh ma'am i'm actually gonna wake up and eat cereal...

You should get to the point where anyone else would quit, and you're not gonna stop there! No, what are you waiting for? DO IT! JUST........DO IT! Yes you can! Just do it!

[💜Jentrap💚]

Originally posted by The Marionette:

But i'm hungry

If you're tired of starting over, stop giving up!

[💜Jentrap💚]

Originally posted by The Marionette:

(D
   (
(D

DO IT! JUST DO IT!

[💜Jentrap💚]

Originally posted by The Marionette:

FINE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *JUST ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ DOES IT!* YEEEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH11!!!!!!!!!!1

I'm glad I could help make your dreams come true.

[ExplosiveSloth]

In terms of difficulty I'd say:

FNAF 2 (I have 36 hours on that game I still haven't beat ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ 10/20 mode)
FNAF 4 (Still on 4/20 mode.)
FNAF 1 (4/20 mode took me while)
FNAF 3 (Aggressive Nightmare was fairly easy compared to the others.)

Even without the 20 modes, I'd still probably have it in that order.
As for scarieness, I'd say the obvious one terrified me the most, and even now unlike the rest of the games in which's atmoshpere stops being creepy and the jumpscares become completely bareable. So, FNAF 4 would be first, but after that, I have no idea. I could re-arrange all the first games into a certain order for creepiness.

FNAF 1 was scary due to the darkness, not quite being able to see Freddy sometimes, running out of power and watching him jingle at the door, knowing you only have seconds left before that light goes out and your dead.

FNAF 2 was the most stressful. You went from 4 animatronics to deal with in the first game, up to 11 in the second. I found it very stressful and that ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ Puppet will haunt you in your sleep.

FNAF 3 was terrifying due to it's overall atmosphere, and the knowledge that there was a crazy amount of jumpscares, and one could happen at any moment.

So, I'm not sure really for this list, but FNAF 4 was definitely the creepiest personally.

[FenrirSlip]

FNAF 2: Hardest
FNAF 1: Second Hardest
FNAF 4: Somewhat Hard
FNAF 3: Not Hard

[FenrirSlip]

FNAF 4: Scariest
FNAF 1: Second Scariest
FNAF2 & 3: Not Scary

[Jinx ★★★]

Heres my list on difficulty.

Fnaf 4
Fnaf 2
Fnaf 1
Fnaf 3

[Graydemon]

Fnaf 4: Scariest and Hardest
Fnaf 2: 2nd Hardest
Fnaf 3 and Fnaf 1:Easy and not scary

[Graydemon]

I just beat night 1 in fnaf 4!
I was just feeling confident when all the sudden I died by Bonnie.