Fnaf Game Battle Royale

[Find Me in the Alps]

Now the fnaf series has come to a close, I feel it only fair to let the four games fight it out, to find out (in my opinion) which was the best.
Round 1-Atmosphere
Fnaf1- 9/10. Brilliant pacing, a sense of crippling helplessness and a focus on less is more really works out.
Fnaf2- 7/10- Similar to fnaf1, manages to instill a sense of urgency. However, this is stifled by its brighter colours, and far more intense gameplay.
Fnaf3- 8/10- A sense of mystery surrounds this atmosphere, rather than terror, but Springtraps clever AI allows for the feeling of being hunted. The phantoms beatifully animated moving sequences and unpredictability also aid it.
Fnaf4-8/10- Taking a step back into fnaf1 horror, the game successfully manages to make you feel helpless, but without the same kind of variety it doesn't match fnaf1.
Round 2- Graphics
Fnaf1- 7/10. The games graphics weren't its selling point, but were good enough to enhance its atmosphere.
Fnaf2- 7/10. DOES improve on fnaf1. however, it misses out the extra mark due to the largely 2D atmosphere and lack of movement, which killed immersion in the graphics a bit.
Fnaf3- 8/10 Doing everything right fnaf1 got wrong, the 3D models here look great. The extra movement sequences also take the game that step higher.
Fnaf4-8/10. Stunningly rendered, fnaf4 would merit a 9 or 10 if it had included cameras, to show us even more spooky environments.
Round 3- Gameplay
Fnaf1-6/10. The gameplay is harsh, and allows for no mistakes on later nights. However, it very quickly becomes repitive and boring, with nothing to boost it up. Only the intensity carries this game gameplay wise
Fnaf2-7/10. more to do, more to see and more to interact with, fnaf2 improves on fnaf1. However, it does eventually fall into repititiveness, but this time has several variables (who appears in the vents, who appears in the office, the hallway etc) that prevents this game from becoming as boring in its gameplay as it's predecessor.
Fnaf3-8/10. Springtraps AI and the reboot system make this game a little more of a strategy rather than a "repeat certain actions over and over." The phantoms are unpredictable, Springtrap is unpredicatble, gameplay is brilliant
Fnaf4- 7/10. Falls away from the complex and unpredictable AI, the breathing mechanic does serve to keep you invested. however, I enjoyed the gameplay of fnaf3 more.
Round 4- Storytelling
Fnaf1- 7/10Short, sweet and subtle, a great start to the tale. Makes a difference from the other games in that the main story actually has to be looked for
Fnaf2-8/10. Expanded on the plot HUGELY. Storytelling is great, and I feel it sparked the great story i obssess over today.
Fnaf3-6/10- reveals a lot more about the plot, but I feel the vagueness of the good and bad ending minigames kind of mystified me. VERY satisfying end of the purple guy however.
Fnaf4-5/10. Sorry scott. The missing of story of fnaf4 really bugs me. I am STILL trying to solve it. Game Theory gave up at this point. I won't, but I feel really frustrated the missing pieces of the story are remaining elusive. game Theory was our main source of info. Who knows, he might say something cool in the livestream, but for now the story remains hidden, and for that it gets a low mark, despite it's undoubtable cleverness and complexity.
Round 5- Overall summary
Fnaf1- 18/20- A great game, witha great story, but became a little too repetitive and stale after a while.
Fnaf2- 17/20. Everything you could ask for in a sequel, fnaf2 nevertheless manages to stifle the firsts atmosphere to helplessness and terror.
Fnaf3-16/20-Having the least scary jumpscares of the franchise comes at a cost, and that cost is a few marks short of the perfect sequel to fnaf2. the AI and great gameplay are its saving grace however.
Fnaf4-18/20. Digging back more to the terrors of fnaf1, fnaf4 delivers better gameplay, better storytelling and more scares at a cost of variety and simplicity.
So, who won?
Fnaf1-47/60
Fnaf2 46/60
Fnaf3-46/60
Fnaf4 46/60
Well, that was a coinciendece. tell me if I added it up wrong, but fnaf1 just comes out on top with great gameplay, great atmosphere, and chilling but simple story.

[Find Me in the Alps]

shanergamer eredeti hozzászólása:

Kewl.



Here's some help solving the story for you:
https://www.reddit.com/r/fivenightsatfreddys/comments/3h8hq5/my_ultimate_five_nights_at_freddys_4_theory/?sort=confidence

More facts and possibiities to consider :)

This is an awesome theory, however, if I could have the impertinence to criticize, I would say at times you used too little evidence to support things, and there was a little too much speculation (especially in the Fredbear does not equal Golden Freddy).