Skin Concept Sable Feedback Please

[Mal114]

Please give me feedback (Constructive criticism only pls) on these sketched out concepts so I can try decide what I wanna go with for the final design (split pieces into head, top, legs) Left to Right (1 - 5)
Thank you for your help!

Link to the image bc idk how to upload

[Shakes]

I think 4 and 5 are the best, IMHO. Hairstyles I could see going either way between the two. Not sure what's going on with the legs on 5, but I would try it with and without fishnets just to see. If I had to pick one as-is, I'd go with 4.

1 looks too "business"-ey for Sable, but maybe that would be a good contrast with her current outfits.
2 isn't bad, it looks like it's straight out of an early 2000s/late 90s movie, which fits based on Sable having a flip phone. Not my personal cup of tea I will admit, though. I never really cared for the spiky anime hairstyle.
3 looks like a younger Morticia Addams, which is kinda goth but moreso a 50s/60s view of it which doesn't really fit Sable
4 and 5 both look time-period appropriate, I would go with 4 over 5 partially because of Sable's current wardrobe being primarily skirts and me not understanding what's going on with her legs in 5. I also think the skull necklace on the choker is a little too on-the-nose. The high-waisted shorts and cropped high-neck sweater do fit her character well though.

[♥Raquelita♥®Esp™©]

I like both 4 and 5 entire outfits. Will combine perfect with actual Sable´s parts. From one i like the hair and from 2 the top. Great job!

[peep]

I love all of them, especially number 2.

3 Is dope but I'd rather Mikaela have that skin with a REAL witch hat and not the ugly hat she currently has.

[Betelgeuse]

2 and 4 are my favis

The hairstyles are different from the existing ones and add some nice variety. Hedehog style would be a first amongst all characters as far as I am aware - points for creativity.

Long sleeves - absolute must have for an early 2000s goth sth. sth.

The ripped pants from 2 are nice and go well together with the boots.

1 I don't dig the attire style on her. Kind of looks like a Hot Topic clerk aiming to be employee of the month
3 & 5 too much overlap with existing skins imho

[DeadboyEzra]

They all too fine to decide. Well done.

[Pierce Dalton]

I like them all except 1, it just doesn't fit Sable imo.

[Chaac]

I really like the 2nd from the left, really unique hairstyle and love the outfit, not too much or too little.

4 is also great

[hex me now]

i like 3 in the middle <3

[Mal114]

Omg thank you all so much for the feedback! I wasn't expecting so many responses :O I'll take my time going through it all so I can make the best skin possible, you're all the best ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥! <3

[♥Raquelita♥®Esp™©]

Mal114 a écrit :

Omg thank you all so much for the feedback! I wasn't expecting so many responses :O I'll take my time going through it all so I can make the best skin possible, you're all the best ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥! <3

Sure you will make an awesome skin!