Old BBQ & chilli

[ShadowDragon]

I don't get the reason at all why they changed it, removed the extra bp on it. That's literally the main reason why I used it. It was so good, and would be so helpful today getting to p100

[Tommy]

It was the healthiest perk and they got rid of the incentive to play nice. Also helped out killers that don't generate bp very well.

[Tokogawa [GER]]

They also removed it from Prove Thyself

And lets be honest many used the Perk just for the Bonus BP. It felt both weird to "waste" a Perk Slot for more Points, aswell as being sort of Pay2Win since the Perk is from Leatherface, a licenced DLC. I fully understand why it was removed since it made no real sense.
I can throw a Cake or Pudding almost every second match and that already doubles the Points and im sure Others should be able to do so aswell considering those two are Yellow

And lets not pretend that the Devs arent showering us in Bloodpoints. A few Years ago you were lucky if you got 15K Points in a Match and Bonus BP Events were only once a Year

[GunSalute!]

They did implement role specific incentive on the other hand. Now u dont even need to use a perk slot for the ekstra 100%. They also lowered the price on all items in the bloodweb.

[State Line Crosser]

The problem was being forced to run bbq to get decent bp gains. The second problem was not including that system into the base game and instead just deleting it.

They are terrified of players not having to grind constantly for bp. Only relatively recently have they started to ease off that a bit.

[Nubbles]

Old bbq was the best perk in the game. The 2 main ways to play sweaty af at the time were camping and tunneling. Bbq would give you targets far away from the hook and gave you a big reward for going after different survivors, incentivising the killer to leave the hook and go for someone else.

This however also incentivised killers to play for hooks instead of kills, which bhvr decided is not how this game should be played. Shots on goals don't count in icehockey and therefor, hookstates don't count in dbd, only kills.