"Secret" Offerings

[PrinceCharming]

The Devs said they want to change it because when a secret offering pops up every one knows it's mori. Because it's either that or the crappy "sperate 4 survivors on 4 different gens" offering.


Why not just make the secret offerings NOT show up when offerings are being shown? Literally defeats the purpose of "Secret" if we know exactly what offering the killer has. Same for survivors.

[Lanz ]

Already suggested but Devs care more about cosmetics it seems.

[PrinceCharming]

Originally posted by Lanz:

Already suggested but Devs care more about cosmetics it seems.

I love how this exact problem I stated is why they wanna implement Mori's as a base thing in the game. But if they literally just removed secret offerings from showing up this problem would be solved. Or just make more offerings secret??

[MrMadMask]

Technically the killer's secret offerings are the moris and making the survivors start the trial separated (not together), even if with this meta it's more an hinderance to the killer than the survivors. Still, I think that secret offerings not showing up at all would be a good idea. But if at rank 1 the killer has no offering, you better watch out...

[Querabias]

Eh, the main problem is that killers only have two types of secret offerings (of which one is less meta than Monstrous Shrine), and survivors have only one (technically two since Vigo's Shroud does not behave like the other two, but it's still a Shroud). As it is right now, you don't need too much brain power to figure out which secret offering is being burnt.

I sometimes load out something "toxic" like Insta-Down hatchets and burn Shroud of Separation just to see how many DC's I get.

Maybe the developers should begin by adding more secret offering variety. Even if it comes as invariably broken like a secret 100% map type chance, experimenting surely couldn't hurt too much, specially since we have PTBs?

[Welbert Asker]

burning an offering that spawns survivors separately, they think it's mori, they kill themselves on a hook

[Arcade]

Either hidden offerings should be completely hidden, and not just shown on the screen, or the killer's offering should be hidden no matter what they burn, just like how in the lobby, the killer can see the survivors, but they can't see the killer. The killer should always have that initial advantage, so hiding the offering should also hide intentions, should they use a hook, mori, map or the ward offerings.

[MrMadMask]

To be honest, killers technically have the Splinters used to play as a non-owned DLC character, and they're secret. But nobody really uses them.

[Sarief4eg]

Originally posted by MrMadMask:

To be honest, killers technically have the Splinters used to play as a non-owned DLC character, and they're secret. But nobody really uses them.

Don't believe they mention it
Are they?

I think I saw someone use it and saw it as surv

[MrMadMask]

Originally posted by Sarief4eg:

Originally posted by MrMadMask:

To be honest, killers technically have the Splinters used to play as a non-owned DLC character, and they're secret. But nobody really uses them.

Don't believe they mention it
Are they?

I think I saw someone use it and saw it as surv

Yes, they are. I have the Black Splinter and the Bone Splinter, and they're both secret.

[Kalec84]

Make all killer offering secret?