Did Eve kill Hannah?

[timeforplanZ]

If they aren't the same person, is this what happened to Hannah? The song she plays on the guitar is all about a woman who drowns her sister.

[pgann]

The last appearance of "Hannah-Hannah" is Jun30. From Jul1 onward it's all Eve-Hannah, and by Jul3 she's open about being Eve.

I think the song is meant more for us (the players) than for the detectives. The problem with the song is that Eve is the younger sister (check the Florence birth account) who wore the blonde wig. Perhaps Eve feels like her life is being snuffed out. After Hannah gets pregnant w/ Simon, Eve goes off to live her own life, with no real identity. And all she could do after being torn apart was sing that one sad song about the wind and the rain.

Just some thoughts.

But... yeah. I think either
a) Eve killed Hannah
*or*
b) using multiple-personality theory, Eve dominates/overcomes Hannah in the end.

[RubberPunch]

Depends on what pattern you're trying to fit. IMO pgann makes a lot of assumptions.

[Dibs]

Remember her story about when they were on the beach and Hannah tried to drown Eve? There are some similarities between the song and Hannah/Eve's relationship with each other and Simon. This scenario fits with both the twin and the multiple personality theory.

Hannah could have tried to drown Eve, but it could also be the reflection of Eve in the water. Eve talks a lot about mirrors and reflection, and water works the same way.

What doesn't make sense to me is why they'd risk being seen together? That would've destroyed everything they've worked for. If one person they know sees them together, the truth will be out. Like in the story when they tried to run away for a concert. They ended up in a police station, but apparently only Hannah was picked up by their parents. Then how the hell did Eve get out of that situation?

[Brune]

Originally posted by Dibs:

Remember her story about when they were on the beach and Hannah tried to drown Eve?

When I heard it this is what came to mind. Hannah (I think) was recalling about how she almost killed Eve one time. Eve mirrored her explaining the story but sang it. Although I don't believe the boy in the song was simon but it was carl. Eve was still mad at Hannah that Hannah broke the rules.

[RubberPunch]

Originally posted by Mr.Fishy:

Originally posted by Dibs:

Remember her story about when they were on the beach and Hannah tried to drown Eve?

When I heard it this is what came to mind. Hannah (I think) was recalling about how she almost killed Eve one time. Eve mirrored her explaining the story but sang it. Although I don't believe the boy in the song was simon but it was carl. Eve was still mad at Hannah that Hannah broke the rules.

The Wind and the Rain is a version of an old Murder Ballad "first known to have appeared on a broadside in 1656 as "The Miller and the King's Daughter."". (see The Twa Sisters[en.wikipedia.org])

Hannah could be spinning the story from her knowledge of the song, or the song could be an Eve favorite because of what happened between her and her sister. Or there's no sisters at all.

[Shadowed]

Originally posted by pgann:

The last appearance of "Hannah-Hannah" is Jun30. From Jul1 onward it's all Eve-Hannah, and by Jul3 she's open about being Eve.

Actually, I believe it's Hannah on July 2nd (wearing the black blouse) as she takes milk and sugar with her coffee, something she also did with tea (one sugar). Eve always had coffee black.

[Jack Sawyer]

Originally posted by Shadowed:

Actually, I believe it's Hannah on July 2nd (wearing the black blouse) as she takes milk and sugar with her coffee, something she also did with tea (one sugar). Eve always had coffee black.

But Hannah always drank tea. It's inconclusive at best. One or the other has changed what they are drinking. The question is which one.

I think it's Eve because Hannah would have no reason to react negatively to being aske for her fingerprints. They already had hers. Giving them again would simply shore up her alibi and "prove" to the police that they are not twins. But if it's Eve, a negative reaction to being asked for fingerprints makes sense.

[Shadowed]

Originally posted by Psi Pilgrim:

Originally posted by Shadowed:

Actually, I believe it's Hannah on July 2nd (wearing the black blouse) as she takes milk and sugar with her coffee, something she also did with tea (one sugar). Eve always had coffee black.

.
I think it's Eve because Hannah would have no reason to react negatively to being aske for her fingerprints. They already had hers. Giving them again would simply shore up her alibi and "prove" to the police that they are not twins. But if it's Eve, a negative reaction to being asked for fingerprints makes sense.

That's fair, but she does seem confident that they will match. She is agitated in general in that interview since the detective has caught on about them being twins. I don't think she is hostile solely because of the fingerprints.

I could see it being either, like you said, but I still feel it's Hannah going off the subtle differences in their personalities.

[Brune]

Originally posted by RubberPunch:

Originally posted by Mr.Fishy:

When I heard it this is what came to mind. Hannah (I think) was recalling about how she almost killed Eve one time. Eve mirrored her explaining the story but sang it. Although I don't believe the boy in the song was simon but it was carl. Eve was still mad at Hannah that Hannah broke the rules.

The Wind and the Rain is a version of an old Murder Ballad "first known to have appeared on a broadside in 1656 as "The Miller and the King's Daughter."". (see The Twa Sisters[en.wikipedia.org])

Hannah could be spinning the story from her knowledge of the song, or the song could be an Eve favorite because of what happened between her and her sister. Or there's no sisters at all.

No sisters at all is where this really falls apart. Ignoring everything about what she is saying. One day she has a tattoo and the other day she doesn't. One day she has a bruise the other day she doesn't. There are physicalities here that don't just appear and disappear overnight. You can argue that it's one person with split personality but then if that was the case she would switch between them sooner. Hours between not full days as seen. There was never a switch on tape or even in the same day.