[Spoiler] Who is it ?

[[CP]Benjymen [fr]]

Hello ! I'm near the end of the game, and someone knifed Trish ... I was wondering who it was, because I don't fancy exiling the wrong one and having to do another playtrough to find out ! So anyone know who the traitor is ?
Thanks for the help !

[Holy Avatar]

Liz

[[CP]Benjymen [fr]]

Thanks !

[Ogami]

I really hated that quest.

It made no sense in my opinion. Liz was one of my best team members. I got her the gun of her dead boyfriend, let her keep it and leveld her up to 10 in Assault Rifles. She was the most useful team member i had. Included in any mission. There was not a single clue about her being crazy.
Then this quest came up and you cant even talk to the people in the camp before making a decision, its just " yeah no, throw someone out, now!". That was really poorly made. I exiled Mary the nurse because she was the only one with mental issues and i guessed her medication ran out by now. When Liz was revealed later i was like " wait, WHAT?". Not a fan of this whole quest. Either let us talk to the other survivors before making that decision or you need to include a lot more clues that something is wrong with Liz.
Alo this quest triggerd really late for me, around day 39 or so and the resolution who the traitor was came on the final day, day 44. So i gone from the reveal to the ending sequence. Which felt weird.

[Holy Avatar]

I understand your reasons. there are some weird comments, but I will put it on our improvement list to make more.

[sharzul]

the person did not have initially which tells of nightmares or delusions?

I just backed up the savegame and some days cued :)

[MonoTheKing⭐]

I would like to have an investigation here too, no way to find out who is it by logic for now. And the game doesn't explain anything after all, which make me curious a little bit. Liz seem pretty normal.

[Ogami]

Origineel geplaatst door MonoTheKing⭐:

I would like to have an investigation here too, no way to find out who is it by logic for now. And the game doesn't explain anything after all, which make me curious a little bit. Liz seem pretty normal. :misterghost:

Especially since the game has another character with Mary who clearly IS mentally disturbed. Getting her psych meds is a whole questline. So she seemed the much more logical choice. Apparently Liz becomes more obvious when you take her dead boyfriends gun from her but i never did that and trained her in it. So i really dont remember any kind of strange behaviour from her. She was pretty much at the bottom of my list of suspects when the quest came up.
They really should add a possibilty to question the other survivors for some alibi or similar.
Liz could say something like " oh i was taking a walk with my boyfriend at the time" and then the player would think " hmm thats weird i thought her boyfriend was dead?" if they rememberd it.
That would be a clue but not a 100% confirmation since she could have gotten a new boyfriend from the group of survivors. But it still could make you doubt her. Something like that.

[MonoTheKing⭐]

^ You got the point, and good theory. Clearly she was at the bottom of the list if I didn't take that powerful gun from her. And even if I took it, I still can't find it weird react, thats her thing and she made the deal at first. There are many other girls, with jealous love stuff can be added to top of the list, since I find the main character was so close with Trish all the time. And the only text clue: mentally stuff so easily leads to the wrong person. Maybe its the tricky part from dev but there is no other clearly clue to find out the truth.

[Razter]

At some point you basically make a team of people that are your A Team. <The Person> was part of that team. Matter of fact, this person was my best gear and most leveled next to my main character. I was pretty pissed when the exent happened.

Not only that, I lost a 2nd person because of this event as well.

That's really ♥♥♥♥♥♥ to have an event almost at the end of the game that just up and kills off 2 of your people. (Not to mention actually losing a 3rd person since I exiled the wrong character)

If you're trying to piss people off by really stupid scripted events, you've succeeded.

Hey hope you didn't need them for that end game run in the desert! :/

[Vertex]

I don't think Liz was obvious. I'm glad it wasn't Mary.

I am sick of seeing those that suffer from mental illnesses also being stereo-typed as 'psychos' and violent people.

[bamachine]

Worst part, the one listed above, she is dead in my playthrough, on day 39. So she is not even available as a choice. I messed up on first day and thought I was supposed to meet her on the road in the city, not in the camp area, so she died the very next day. I learned from that and now have 10 members in my camp(myself included).

[bamachine]

Well, update, meant to say 12 members, counting Bill and Trish. Also, in my playthrough, since I could not choose the one listed above, in fact there is no Liz in my game, there was a Jessica that died after I messed up and chose the wrong place to go. So I chose Mary, as she was clearly the most crazy of those left and Voila, I guess it was her, as I got the good result of the quest. They must have changed it, since so many complained that she seemed the obvious choice.

[The Terror]

The worest part is Liz leavs with all her gear. She was a main in my party. This being a issue with anyone dying/leaving the group with no notice.

[Aesmatv]

yea lol was little irked on the liz option for me too i had her decked out so much she had some of my best gear. would have been nice to be able to take that gear off first.

[Mormegil]

Did they really change it now?
And i had a event in the bar where XXX had a arguing with trish about stealing rations. Is this new?