Middle-earth™: Shadow of War™

Middle-earth™: Shadow of War™

View Stats:
Ranni Oct 14, 2017 @ 7:21pm
How does betrayal work?
There are many things to consider, but it's different than a blood brother revenge type of thing. For me I can assume 3 things that might cause it, and one i'll make it clear on the type i hate the most.

-RNG
-They dislike you and now want to kill you
-Demotion causing them to betray you because they aren't warchief/overlord (BS)

The last one if he;d true is the worst, The orcs don't level up casually you may have to force it and if you demote someone and try to level them up through missions they may just come after you. It's a poor system to be honest.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 50 comments
Obeliske Oct 14, 2017 @ 7:28pm 
I'd like to know this as well. I had plans for this one guy it was a really rought fight and after I took him he turned against me and whupped my arse. The only reason I lived is I had some orc slayer dude show up and straight out murder him as he was going to kill me. choked me up because I'd rather have died and tried to make him mine again.
Korvyr Oct 14, 2017 @ 7:28pm 
"If you demote someone, they may not like it. BOGUS MAN!"

I think that's actually a rather realistic reaction to being demoted. Dislike. Betrayal.

There's also tons of fun ways to level up your orcs. Best of which is to pit them against tons of enemies until someone kills them, and then you put someone better in their place.
SupaStompa Oct 14, 2017 @ 7:30pm 
I dont believe that much into "RNG" explanation its much more logical just like blood brothers betrayal, for example when i first went on downed state my assigned bodyguard olog that was fighting for me all good decided that i was "weak" and decided to end me right after i killed the captain. Like i said show of weakness is one that can trigger betrayal and most likely fleeing from
enemy captain as well.
Ranni Oct 14, 2017 @ 7:47pm 
Originally posted by Korvyr:
"If you demote someone, they may not like it. BOGUS MAN!"

I think that's actually a rather realistic reaction to being demoted. Dislike. Betrayal.

There's also tons of fun ways to level up your orcs. Best of which is to pit them against tons of enemies until someone kills them, and then you put someone better in their place.

Could be true, I demoted two guys to do two quest so they are close to my level and then promote them, within the first mission both betray me. I am guessing it could play a factor or complete luck, but I wasn't happy.
Ranni Oct 14, 2017 @ 7:49pm 
Originally posted by FuriousPancake:
I dont believe that much into "RNG" explanation its much more logical just like blood brothers betrayal, for example when i first went on downed state my assigned bodyguard olog that was fighting for me all good decided that i was "weak" and decided to end me right after i killed the captain. Like i said show of weakness is one that can trigger betrayal and most likely fleeing from
enemy captain as well.

Maybe running away doesn't play a factor, there are times where the captain is a savage or shield guy which are the worst and I have to circle around and throw knives so i can replenish my arrows and shoot him. I mean I can't attack the savage guy cause A: he is immune to vault and immense HP and B: trying to hit him at the front he just head-butts you.

Frost does the trick but till they adapt to it.

However, my orcs didn't betray me cause of that, simply all 3 ganged up on me after I demoted 2 and the other no idea why.
Last edited by Ranni; Oct 14, 2017 @ 7:50pm
Terrible Oct 14, 2017 @ 8:09pm 
Being level 43 I had a level 17 Olog betray me. If I had to assume why its because he was the lowest level and I never tried to level him to have him do busy work.

Also he kidnapped one of my higher Orcs and took him with him as he did it.
Smashed the dudes head on the ground when he confronted me.

As I killed him he told me "Out of all my bosses you were the worst.. and the rest were orcs"

So I think he was bored of sitting around all day.
Ranni Oct 14, 2017 @ 8:14pm 
Originally posted by Terrible:
Being level 43 I had a level 17 Olog betray me. If I had to assume why its because he was the lowest level and I never tried to level him to have him do busy work.

Also he kidnapped one of my higher Orcs and took him with him as he did it.
Smashed the dudes head on the ground when he confronted me.

As I killed him he told me "Out of all my bosses you were the worst.. and the rest were orcs"

So I think he was bored of sitting around all day.

it's confusing indeed, I am on stage 8 on act 4 defending my bases and I am a bit tired of always changing my orcs so I don't lose the good ones in battle. Personally it depends if I die or not honestly haha, but I guess stronger orcs is a better choice so they survive the fights and don't die even the average ones.
TimThomasCrown Oct 14, 2017 @ 8:27pm 
I move orca around all the time and have never had anyone betray me for that (well at least never said it)

I only get blood brother revenge, which seems if a new warchief comes in they could get that trait with one of the warlords. Then if you kill him the warlord betrays you.

So it seems you gonna need to check every new orc
Alopekis Oct 14, 2017 @ 8:36pm 
I think there's a chance they'll betray you if they end up above your level, if that's possible. I think I had one orc betray me like this. I had just completed a mission with him and he leveled up, then when I was fighting some rando Captain that showed up out of no where he came up and said something then started attacking me.

I hadn't attacked a blood brother of his, didn't demote him, and I don't see any reason why he would've disliked me. I think he just got too powerful and decided that he would try to overthrow me.

I don't actually remember if he was above my level or not, but I think he was. And that's the only reason I can think of that he decided to betray me. It sucks too cause I was gonna make him a warchief because I liked him.
Last edited by Alopekis; Oct 14, 2017 @ 8:37pm
Ranni Oct 14, 2017 @ 8:46pm 
Originally posted by Alopekis:
I think there's a chance they'll betray you if they end up above your level, if that's possible. I think I had one orc betray me like this. I had just completed a mission with him and he leveled up, then when I was fighting some rando Captain that showed up out of no where he came up and said something then started attacking me.

I hadn't attacked a blood brother of his, didn't demote him, and I don't see any reason why he would've disliked me. I think he just got too powerful and decided that he would try to overthrow me.

I don't actually remember if he was above my level or not, but I think he was. And that's the only reason I can think of that he decided to betray me. It sucks too cause I was gonna make him a warchief because I liked him.

I wonder if ambush plays a role, feel like it wouldn't you have an orc thats really low level and want to power him up, so you bring in some buddies to make him stronger and so that he doesn't die. I have 3 legend orcs level 15 that need work cause i opened the box early on lol so they need advising.
MafiaPenguin Oct 14, 2017 @ 8:52pm 
Originally posted by Alopekis:
I think there's a chance they'll betray you if they end up above your level, if that's possible. I think I had one orc betray me like this. I had just completed a mission with him and he leveled up, then when I was fighting some rando Captain that showed up out of no where he came up and said something then started attacking me.

I hadn't attacked a blood brother of his, didn't demote him, and I don't see any reason why he would've disliked me. I think he just got too powerful and decided that he would try to overthrow me.

I don't actually remember if he was above my level or not, but I think he was. And that's the only reason I can think of that he decided to betray me. It sucks too cause I was gonna make him a warchief because I liked him.

they can never go above your level, but it may be that if they did enough missions and didnt level up because you arent leveling up, they betray you because you are holding them back
Ranni Oct 14, 2017 @ 8:57pm 
Originally posted by MafiaPenguin:
Originally posted by Alopekis:
I think there's a chance they'll betray you if they end up above your level, if that's possible. I think I had one orc betray me like this. I had just completed a mission with him and he leveled up, then when I was fighting some rando Captain that showed up out of no where he came up and said something then started attacking me.

I hadn't attacked a blood brother of his, didn't demote him, and I don't see any reason why he would've disliked me. I think he just got too powerful and decided that he would try to overthrow me.

I don't actually remember if he was above my level or not, but I think he was. And that's the only reason I can think of that he decided to betray me. It sucks too cause I was gonna make him a warchief because I liked him.

they can never go above your level, but it may be that if they did enough missions and didnt level up because you arent leveling up, they betray you because you are holding them back

Could be, had a few guys maxed level and one legend level 53 (hasn't betrayed me yet) but its weird. We won't fully know what triggers it, we can second guess and predict but we will never really know why.
AgentKid Oct 15, 2017 @ 11:57am 
Originally posted by Meruem:
There are many things to consider, but it's different than a blood brother revenge type of thing. For me I can assume 3 things that might cause it, and one i'll make it clear on the type i hate the most.

-RNG
-They dislike you and now want to kill you
-Demotion causing them to betray you because they aren't warchief/overlord (BS)

The last one if he;d true is the worst, The orcs don't level up casually you may have to force it and if you demote someone and try to level them up through missions they may just come after you. It's a poor system to be honest.


I was trying to free one of my captains from being executed and while I was doing that a series of unfortunate events took place:

-Another captain of mine ambushed/betrayed me.

-My olog bodyguard betrayed me

-Another olog captain betrayed me and stopped in. He had another one of my still friendly captains in his hand and smashed him into the ground causing him to start bleeding, it was cool.
Crackjack Oct 15, 2017 @ 12:01pm 
Dominating a Nemisis also has a chance to betray you
A man Oct 15, 2017 @ 12:06pm 
I was betrayed my fy favorite Captain for no reason...I did nothing to him and he just betrayed me when I called for his help
< >
Showing 1-15 of 50 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Oct 14, 2017 @ 7:21pm
Posts: 50