Vote Physics... Sebastien Loeb Rally EVO vs Dirt Rally

[janirobe]

Give a 1 for SLRE or a 2 for Dirt Rally. Feel free to give your reasoning.

PS: I have not played SLRE so I cannot vote but feel that dirt rally is the perfect game for me. Someone prove me wrong. Amount of content aside, I mostly care about the physics and authenticity to real rally racing. This includes graphics and sound but I am hearing Dirt Rally wins those hands down. I am a wheel user.

[janirobe]

Publicado originalmente por JukkaGee:

1. Sebastien Loeb Rally Evo is simply amazing with physics. Its so shame that in many aspects its very unfinished game, and maybe thats why it doesn´t have living modding community. Its super fun for rallycross races as it is , but with mods it could be the new RBR for rally games.

yeah I think you miss spelt Dirt Rally.

[-RG]

In DR is ♥♥♥♥ and SLRE great but in all other is DR much better.

[Smithers-1968]

SLRE. No contest for physics or content.

[janirobe]

Publicado originalmente por Smithers-1968:

SLRE. No contest for physics or content.

you're wrong. but it's okay we all make mistakes at some point in our lives

[Plaskus]

Publicado originalmente por janirobe:

Publicado originalmente por Smithers-1968:

SLRE. No contest for physics or content.

you're wrong. but it's okay we all make mistakes at some point in our lives

My mum told me i was a mistake :'(

[janirobe]

Publicado originalmente por Rock Manlyfist:

Publicado originalmente por janirobe:

you're wrong. but it's okay we all make mistakes at some point in our lives

My mum told me i was a mistake :'(

https://imgflip.com/i/2marm4

[Surveyor]

Publicado originalmente por janirobe:

https://imgflip.com/i/2marm4

Sure, that definitely proves DR being superior in all aspects hands down.
Let me guess. You came up with this thread with trolling in mind?

While I'm looking at DR much more favorably now and can enjoy an occasional session in it, the thing still has glaring issues. And I'm not even talking about the nonexistent tarmac tire model here. Doesn't look like DR 2.0 will be a step forward rather than backward either.

Edit: In fact, scratch that. Try loose surfaces in BeamNG (or Automobilista) and you'll quickly discover that DR is just a hugely immersive rally*driver* "simulator" (AKA a proper arcade), while SLRE is a not too shabby semi-arcade. Both these titles have their strengths, but don't let it fool you even for a second that either of them can portray loose surfaces handling realistically, even though in SLRE you can kind of swap ends if you try hard enough. AWD is a tricky beast to tame. It can lull you into a false sense of security. Give it such an opportunity, however, let go of the gas at just the "right" moment and you are screwed in many senses due to a snap oversteer. Alternatively, exceed a certain yaw rate thinking that "it's an AWD, this should be safe", and you're a goner once again.

[Hanachan]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iZEu8VN6AkE

Yeah .. Nice physics DR!
Ultra realistic physics that can't even simulate tarmac behaviors unlike other sim racing games!

[LokiD1978]

Reinstalled this after buying dr2. And yes the physics and car movement is still more realistic than dr2. The ffb although not amazing on SLRE is still streets ahead of the numb ffb that is dirt rally. Look at replays in SLRE the cars behave like they do in reality weight transfer suspension movement, Dr has a physics issue due to it centre pivot steering which makes replays look ridiculously floaty. I find it immensely frustrating to drive due to the ffb which is up there with the most awful ffb in sim racing. But as a game its all there but the most important part the driving is meh..

Nice gfx and audio vo.

[andis.balins]

:D SLRE physics are so real :D drive rallycross at 70 kp/h small contact and barellroll can begin.
so real!!!

[Snake]

I find it amazing that people fed a Codemasters troll for 24 pages, while he obviously has no interest in the game.

[Plaskus]

Publicado originalmente por Snake:

I find it amazing that people fed a Codemasters troll for 24 pages, while he obviously has no interest in the game.

I find it more amazing this thread is still alive and relevant 3.5 years later

[Raffi]

Publicado originalmente por Schmidtarn:

Publicado originalmente por Snake:

I find it amazing that people fed a Codemasters troll for 24 pages, while he obviously has no interest in the game.

I find it more amazing this thread is still alive and relevant 3.5 years later

You hit the spot, so long time SLRE is pursued, also by me because I'm a fan of Sebastian Loeb. Unfortunately I could not drive the game with my different steering wheels since release and accelerating or braking over a button is not my thing.
It's a pity Milestone does not even think about Sebastian Loeb and his honor to fix the input problems of the steering wheels and pedals.
What I have seen so far shows that it would not be in the Rally League before Dirt Rally, but before Dirt Rally 2.0.
On Milestone, what are you afraid of, bring a patch with which all steering wheels are supported and you can resell it!
If you're brave, bring VR into the game! ;-)

[janirobe]

Publicado originalmente por Schmidtarn:

Publicado originalmente por Snake:

I find it amazing that people fed a Codemasters troll for 24 pages, while he obviously has no interest in the game.

I find it more amazing this thread is still alive and relevant 3.5 years later

I am probably the most surprised

[Cellulo]

I prefer SLRE than Dirt rally, because SLRE physics are really close to real cars behavior, when i plug my G25 wheel in SLRE it was automatically detected and i see the difference immediately with Dirt rally 1 about the physics.

SLRE are awesome, my G25 wheels and pedals are well detected and when playing it, i believe i'm in real car, the wheel and pedals responds like real car, the only set i do it's the dead zone setting for the brake because too much brake by default that lock the wheels too early when pushing the brake pedal, i have not this feeling in Dirt rally even after a lots of settings for my wheel in this one, i'm near to set it like SRLE but not the same behavior happen with my wheel.

For me the downside of SLRE is really the sound of the cars and sometimes the environment sounds ( flat tyre, no tyre on surface), the immersive take punch in the face and also some bad collisions on some tracks, but the tracks and cars available are cool.

And the big downside of the game no modding support, the community can't make new tracks, new cars or new sounds, if modding was supported this game was the son of the richard burns rally game and more.

The other car game that give me the feeling of the real car behavior with my G25 wheel is the Assetto Corso game.