FNAF2 Five Dead Children all possess Nightmare Fredbear??

[ErnieC3]

THIS IS A THEORY!!

Please play this video and read along. The narration reads off the exact text below:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tV4zRFmuvaM
Now, when I was looking back on the nightmare animatronics, I noticed something. Fredbear is the only animatronic that isn’t haunted…or is he? We know that the only other thing that got possessed in Fredbear’s Family Diner was the puppet, but who else was there to possess Fredbear? Well, no one…yet.

Do you remember the first five dead children? Once found by the puppet, they were stuffed into the animatronic suits. That explains the first original characters. But what about in FNAF2? Five MORE dead children were killed, but the puppet was worried about stopping the killer with Freddy at its guard, completely forgetting about those five more dead children. Or…maybe he didn’t forget. Here’s what I’m saying.

What if I told you that all five of those dead children may be possessing Fredbear. All five of them. Here’s there reasons why. Remember how spring trap was discovered. Maybe Fredbear was discovered too…in FNAF2. If so, then maybe the puppet didn’t forget about those five dead children and stuffed them all into Fredbear. Remember, Scott did say something big is coming…in a physical way too. People were also reporting that there were children in Fredbear’s stomach. They were also reporting on how fat he is. If these two are correct, they we can safely assume that all five of these dead children are possessing Fredbear. If he is going to be an important character, this might also be the reason. The grandfather of all Freddy Fazbears being possessed by the five dead children in FNAF2. But that's just a theory.

[Aetherius]

A GAAAAME THEORY. But for real, I like this theory.

[TheAuditor24]

Sounds like a good theory, but there's a problem. If 4 children are already the other 4 nightmare animatronics, how can all the children be Fredbear at the same time? And also, there were 6 children murdered. 5 at Freddy Fazbear's (Freddy, Chica, Bonnie, Foxy, Golden Freddy) and one at Fredbear's (the Puppet). Fredbear being fat has nothing to do with how many spirits are possessing him. We see Fredbear in FNAF 3, in the STAGE 01 minigame (you also see Springtrap in that minigame), and he's fat there too (the only other time we see Fredbear is in the Give Cake minigame in FNAF 2, because "Freddy" is the one who gives cakes even though at Freddy Fazbear's it's supposed to be Chica who does that). If we don't get a Nightmare Puppet or Nightmare Golden Freddy teaser, i'm guessing Fredbear is possessed by the Puppet and Golden Freddy at the same time (or just Golden Freddy if we get a Nightmare Puppet teaser, or vice-versa). It would make sense for Fredbear to be possessed by Golden Freddy, i mean Golden Freddy is pretty much Freddy with Fredbear colors, so he/she does have some sort of resemblance to Fredbear.

Also, those other 5 children you talk about don't exist. No one was killed at the FNAF 2 pizzeria (not even at The Bite of '87, since Phone Guy says in FNAF 1 that you can live without your frontal lobe, which definetly means that the victim is still alive), which is not the first Freddy Fazbear's. There was another pizzeria before it. That's when the murder happened (5 children died, there was another child, but he/she died at Fredbear's and became the Puppet)

[ErnieC3]

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

Sounds like a good theory, but there's a problem. If 4 children are already the other 4 nightmare animatronics, how can all the children be Fredbear at the same time? And also, there were 6 children murdered. 5 at Freddy Fazbear's (Freddy, Chica, Bonnie, Foxy, Golden Freddy) and one at Fredbear's (the Puppet). Fredbear being fat has nothing to do with how many spirits are possessing him. We see Fredbear in FNAF 3, in the STAGE 01 minigame (you also see Springtrap in that minigame), and he's fat there too (the only other time we see Fredbear is in the Give Cake minigame in FNAF 2, because "Freddy" is the one who gives cakes even though at Freddy Fazbear's it's supposed to be Chica who does that). If we don't get a Nightmare Puppet or Nightmare Golden Freddy teaser, i'm guessing Fredbear is possessed by the Puppet and Golden Freddy at the same time (or just Golden Freddy if we get a Nightmare Puppet teaser, or vice-versa). It would make sense for Fredbear to be possessed by Golden Freddy, i mean Golden Freddy is pretty much Freddy with Fredbear colors, so he/she does have some sort of resemblance to Fredbear.

Also, those other 5 children you talk about don't exist. No one was killed at the FNAF 2 pizzeria (not even at The Bite of '87, since Phone Guy says in FNAF 1 that you can live without your frontal lobe, which definetly means that the victim is still alive), which is not the first Freddy Fazbear's. There was another pizzeria before it. That's when the murder happened (5 children died, there was another child, but he/she died at Fredbear's and became the Puppet)

Correction:
1. There WERE 5 other children that got killed in FNAF2, but instead of the puppet stuffing them, the puppet led freddy to the killer in the Save Them mini-game.
2. Fredbear being fat determines how many bodies could have fit inside him (especially since his stomach has teeth).
3. The Fredbear in the Stage 01 minigame is not Fredbear, but golden freddy. If you listen to the phone guy on night two, he says, "Welcome to your new career as a performer/entertainer for FREDDY FAZBEAR's PIZZA". Not Fredbear's Family Diner. That golden bear was Golden Freddy.
4. Fredbear could possibly be possessed by the puppet, but Golden Freddy being possessed by Fredbear? It just doesn't make sense.

5. Listen to these parts in the video below
-6:23
-13:55 (IMPORTANT) "Five MORE Children"
-The whole video (Yes)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GPugMe4ePEw

[Sarcasm]

Am I wrong to think that Pink Guy (if separate from Purple Guy) is Fredbear? And that Purple Fam and Pink Fam both died on dates that were close? Maybe, if they were in a league together, Purple Fam dismantled the animatronics for revenge...




What a ♥♥♥♥♥♥ theory. Move along.

[TheAuditor24]

Originally posted by ErnieCIII:

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

Sounds like a good theory, but there's a problem. If 4 children are already the other 4 nightmare animatronics, how can all the children be Fredbear at the same time? And also, there were 6 children murdered. 5 at Freddy Fazbear's (Freddy, Chica, Bonnie, Foxy, Golden Freddy) and one at Fredbear's (the Puppet). Fredbear being fat has nothing to do with how many spirits are possessing him. We see Fredbear in FNAF 3, in the STAGE 01 minigame (you also see Springtrap in that minigame), and he's fat there too (the only other time we see Fredbear is in the Give Cake minigame in FNAF 2, because "Freddy" is the one who gives cakes even though at Freddy Fazbear's it's supposed to be Chica who does that). If we don't get a Nightmare Puppet or Nightmare Golden Freddy teaser, i'm guessing Fredbear is possessed by the Puppet and Golden Freddy at the same time (or just Golden Freddy if we get a Nightmare Puppet teaser, or vice-versa). It would make sense for Fredbear to be possessed by Golden Freddy, i mean Golden Freddy is pretty much Freddy with Fredbear colors, so he/she does have some sort of resemblance to Fredbear.

Also, those other 5 children you talk about don't exist. No one was killed at the FNAF 2 pizzeria (not even at The Bite of '87, since Phone Guy says in FNAF 1 that you can live without your frontal lobe, which definetly means that the victim is still alive), which is not the first Freddy Fazbear's. There was another pizzeria before it. That's when the murder happened (5 children died, there was another child, but he/she died at Fredbear's and became the Puppet)

Correction:
1. There WERE 5 other children that got killed in FNAF2, but instead of the puppet stuffing them, the puppet led freddy to the killer in the Save Them mini-game.
2. Fredbear being fat determines how many bodies could have fit inside him (especially since his stomach has teeth).
3. The Fredbear in the Stage 01 minigame is not Fredbear, but golden freddy. If you listen to the phone guy on night two, he says, "Welcome to your new career as a performer/entertainer for FREDDY FAZBEAR's PIZZA". Not Fredbear's Family Diner. That golden bear was Golden Freddy.
4. Fredbear could possibly be possessed by the puppet, but Golden Freddy being possessed by Fredbear? It just doesn't make sense.

5. Listen to these parts in the video below
-6:23
-13:55 (IMPORTANT) "Five MORE Children"
-The whole video (Yes)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GPugMe4ePEw

1. There was only 1 victim of The Bite of '87 as far as i recall, and that victim is still alive even though it's frontal lobe got bitten off (Phone Guy says in FNAF 1 that a person can live without his/her frontal lobe, which implies that the victim is still alive)

2. The stomach having teeth and having stuff like the Puppet and other animatronics inside it probably is supposed to represent Fredbear is the one that started the business.

3. The STAGE 01 yellow Freddy can't be Golden Freddy. Golden Freddy is not fat, but Nightmare Fredbear is (and don't talk about the color, since it's definetly edited by Scott so we won't see Fredbear's real colors in the teaser), not to mention, the minigame didn't happen at Freddy Fazbear's. Only Springtrap and Fredbear are in that minigame, Springtrap doesn't have a corpse inside it, Springtrap and Fredbear are in business, proved by the kids there, even though at Freddy Fazbear's, Springtrap and Fredbear were probably only used temporarily, and the room looks small enough to be a diner. Springtrap is not a ghost, but Golden Freddy is, so this is more proof against the "yellow Freddy = Golden Freddy" theory.

So in short: STAGE 01 happens at Fredbear's and yellow Freddy and yellow Bonnie are Fredbear and Springtrap.

4. Why wouldn't it make sense? Golden Freddy, while he/she is a ghost, is still a spirit like the other 5 children. Golden Freddy probably didn't want to possess anything, or couldn't find anything to possess and instead became a ghost. And for the last time, Golden Freddy is a ghost, or spectre, or whatever, but not a suit or animatronic. He/She takes the form of Freddy with Fredbear colors and that's it, but it's not Fredbear. Since Golden Freddy is sort of based off Fredbear, it would make sense for him/her to possess Fredbear. Remember those empty heads in FNAF 1? Well, they sometimes stare at the camera, even though there's nothing remaining to possess them. Maybe Golden Freddy is possessing those heads, and with Golden Freddy possessing Fredbear, i think those things inside Fredbear that represent animatronics actually represent the empty heads from FNAF 1.

5. 5 more children? Apart from the 6 kids who became the Puppet, Freddy, Bonnie, Foxy, Chica, Golden Freddy and Purple Guy who became Springtrap, who else was seen dying in the FNAF games? And it is mentioned that there were FIVE children murdered at the 1st Freddy Fazbear's (it's on a poster in FNAF 1 or 2, can't recall which game, but the poster is in the games). Sure, the toy animatronics seem shady, but they were probably introduced just to fool us (probably except Mangle since it most likely caused The Bite of '87, but let's not get off track). The only one who was killed at Fredbear's was the Puppet (Give Cake minigame) and the only ones who were killed at Freddy Fazbear's were Freddy, Bonnie, Foxy, Chica and Golden Freddy (Foxy minigame). As for the minigame map representing the FNAF 2 pizzeria, that's probably just coincidence. The 1st Freddy Fazbear's most likely looked just like the FNAF 2 pizzeria, since Phone Guy doesn't mention that the pizzeria had a lower budget in FNAF 2, unlike in FNAF 1, where he mentions the pizzeria has a lower budget (the FNAF 1 pizzeria is after the FNAF 2 pizzeria). The only one who was harmed at the FNAF 2 pizzeria was the victim of The Bite of '87, but he/she survived so he/she doesn't count (again, Phone Guy talks about it in FNAF 1)

[ErnieC3]

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

Originally posted by ErnieCIII:

Correction:
1. There WERE 5 other children that got killed in FNAF2, but instead of the puppet stuffing them, the puppet led freddy to the killer in the Save Them mini-game.
2. Fredbear being fat determines how many bodies could have fit inside him (especially since his stomach has teeth).
3. The Fredbear in the Stage 01 minigame is not Fredbear, but golden freddy. If you listen to the phone guy on night two, he says, "Welcome to your new career as a performer/entertainer for FREDDY FAZBEAR's PIZZA". Not Fredbear's Family Diner. That golden bear was Golden Freddy.
4. Fredbear could possibly be possessed by the puppet, but Golden Freddy being possessed by Fredbear? It just doesn't make sense.

5. Listen to these parts in the video below
-6:23
-13:55 (IMPORTANT) "Five MORE Children"
-The whole video (Yes)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GPugMe4ePEw

1. There was only 1 victim of The Bite of '87 as far as i recall, and that victim is still alive even though it's frontal lobe got bitten off (Phone Guy says in FNAF 1 that a person can live without his/her frontal lobe, which implies that the victim is still alive)

2. The stomach having teeth and having stuff like the Puppet and other animatronics inside it probably is supposed to represent Fredbear is the one that started the business.

3. The STAGE 01 yellow Freddy can't be Golden Freddy. Golden Freddy is not fat, but Nightmare Fredbear is (and don't talk about the color, since it's definetly edited by Scott so we won't see Fredbear's real colors in the teaser), not to mention, the minigame didn't happen at Freddy Fazbear's. Only Springtrap and Fredbear are in that minigame, Springtrap doesn't have a corpse inside it, Springtrap and Fredbear are in business, proved by the kids there, even though at Freddy Fazbear's, Springtrap and Fredbear were probably only used temporarily, and the room looks small enough to be a diner. Springtrap is not a ghost, but Golden Freddy is, so this is more proof against the "yellow Freddy = Golden Freddy" theory.

So in short: STAGE 01 happens at Fredbear's and yellow Freddy and yellow Bonnie are Fredbear and Springtrap.

4. Why wouldn't it make sense? Golden Freddy, while he/she is a ghost, is still a spirit like the other 5 children. Golden Freddy probably didn't want to possess anything, or couldn't find anything to possess and instead became a ghost. And for the last time, Golden Freddy is a ghost, or spectre, or whatever, but not a suit or animatronic. He/She takes the form of Freddy with Fredbear colors and that's it, but it's not Fredbear. Since Golden Freddy is sort of based off Fredbear, it would make sense for him/her to possess Fredbear. Remember those empty heads in FNAF 1? Well, they sometimes stare at the camera, even though there's nothing remaining to possess them. Maybe Golden Freddy is possessing those heads, and with Golden Freddy possessing Fredbear, i think those things inside Fredbear that represent animatronics actually represent the empty heads from FNAF 1.

5. 5 more children? Apart from the 6 kids who became the Puppet, Freddy, Bonnie, Foxy, Chica, Golden Freddy and Purple Guy who became Springtrap, who else was seen dying in the FNAF games? And it is mentioned that there were FIVE children murdered at the 1st Freddy Fazbear's (it's on a poster in FNAF 1 or 2, can't recall which game, but the poster is in the games). Sure, the toy animatronics seem shady, but they were probably introduced just to fool us (probably except Mangle since it most likely caused The Bite of '87, but let's not get off track). The only one who was killed at Fredbear's was the Puppet (Give Cake minigame) and the only ones who were killed at Freddy Fazbear's were Freddy, Bonnie, Foxy, Chica and Golden Freddy (Foxy minigame). As for the minigame map representing the FNAF 2 pizzeria, that's probably just coincidence. The 1st Freddy Fazbear's most likely looked just like the FNAF 2 pizzeria, since Phone Guy doesn't mention that the pizzeria had a lower budget in FNAF 2, unlike in FNAF 1, where he mentions the pizzeria has a lower budget (the FNAF 1 pizzeria is after the FNAF 2 pizzeria). The only one who was harmed at the FNAF 2 pizzeria was the victim of The Bite of '87, but he/she survived so he/she doesn't count (again, Phone Guy talks about it in FNAF 1)

1. I haven't mentioned the bite of 87 at all. This theory doesn't mention or will mention it.
2. Stage 01 is Freddy Fazbear's Pizza, becuase after the springlock suits (including Golden Freddy) were removed and were replaced with the original Bonnie, Chica, Freddy, and Foxy. Afterwards, the Five Children Incident occurs.
3. Scott wouldn't just have the ghost children play musical chairs with the animatronics. Each spirit is trapped in one body, otherwise they could've just left.
4. The FNAF2 location was in business twice. Yes, the same location. The first time period they were open (also when the phone guy makes the phone messages), the purple man is snooping around and then kills the five more children. Those dead child bodies aren't there for no reason or are just a "coincidence". The place gets closed down due to the murders. After everything is cleared up, they re-open for "only a few short weeks" before the bite of 87 happens, closing down FNAF2 for good.

Go to parts:
-1:12 (watch from there)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SgACktyVXbk&index=7&list=PL35FE5C4B157509C9&spfreload=10

[Aetherius]

Originally posted by Sarcasm:

Am I wrong to think that Pink Guy (if separate from Purple Guy) is Fredbear? And that Purple Fam and Pink Fam both died on dates that were close? Maybe, if they were in a league together, Purple Fam dismantled the animatronics for revenge...




What a ♥♥♥♥♥♥ theory. Move along.

I was thinking the same thing. I have a hunch Purple Guy isn't Pink Guy.

[TheAuditor24]

Originally posted by ErnieCIII:

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

1. There was only 1 victim of The Bite of '87 as far as i recall, and that victim is still alive even though it's frontal lobe got bitten off (Phone Guy says in FNAF 1 that a person can live without his/her frontal lobe, which implies that the victim is still alive)

2. The stomach having teeth and having stuff like the Puppet and other animatronics inside it probably is supposed to represent Fredbear is the one that started the business.

3. The STAGE 01 yellow Freddy can't be Golden Freddy. Golden Freddy is not fat, but Nightmare Fredbear is (and don't talk about the color, since it's definetly edited by Scott so we won't see Fredbear's real colors in the teaser), not to mention, the minigame didn't happen at Freddy Fazbear's. Only Springtrap and Fredbear are in that minigame, Springtrap doesn't have a corpse inside it, Springtrap and Fredbear are in business, proved by the kids there, even though at Freddy Fazbear's, Springtrap and Fredbear were probably only used temporarily, and the room looks small enough to be a diner. Springtrap is not a ghost, but Golden Freddy is, so this is more proof against the "yellow Freddy = Golden Freddy" theory.

So in short: STAGE 01 happens at Fredbear's and yellow Freddy and yellow Bonnie are Fredbear and Springtrap.

4. Why wouldn't it make sense? Golden Freddy, while he/she is a ghost, is still a spirit like the other 5 children. Golden Freddy probably didn't want to possess anything, or couldn't find anything to possess and instead became a ghost. And for the last time, Golden Freddy is a ghost, or spectre, or whatever, but not a suit or animatronic. He/She takes the form of Freddy with Fredbear colors and that's it, but it's not Fredbear. Since Golden Freddy is sort of based off Fredbear, it would make sense for him/her to possess Fredbear. Remember those empty heads in FNAF 1? Well, they sometimes stare at the camera, even though there's nothing remaining to possess them. Maybe Golden Freddy is possessing those heads, and with Golden Freddy possessing Fredbear, i think those things inside Fredbear that represent animatronics actually represent the empty heads from FNAF 1.

5. 5 more children? Apart from the 6 kids who became the Puppet, Freddy, Bonnie, Foxy, Chica, Golden Freddy and Purple Guy who became Springtrap, who else was seen dying in the FNAF games? And it is mentioned that there were FIVE children murdered at the 1st Freddy Fazbear's (it's on a poster in FNAF 1 or 2, can't recall which game, but the poster is in the games). Sure, the toy animatronics seem shady, but they were probably introduced just to fool us (probably except Mangle since it most likely caused The Bite of '87, but let's not get off track). The only one who was killed at Fredbear's was the Puppet (Give Cake minigame) and the only ones who were killed at Freddy Fazbear's were Freddy, Bonnie, Foxy, Chica and Golden Freddy (Foxy minigame). As for the minigame map representing the FNAF 2 pizzeria, that's probably just coincidence. The 1st Freddy Fazbear's most likely looked just like the FNAF 2 pizzeria, since Phone Guy doesn't mention that the pizzeria had a lower budget in FNAF 2, unlike in FNAF 1, where he mentions the pizzeria has a lower budget (the FNAF 1 pizzeria is after the FNAF 2 pizzeria). The only one who was harmed at the FNAF 2 pizzeria was the victim of The Bite of '87, but he/she survived so he/she doesn't count (again, Phone Guy talks about it in FNAF 1)

1. I haven't mentioned the bite of 87 at all. This theory doesn't mention or will mention it.
2. Stage 01 is Freddy Fazbear's Pizza, becuase after the springlock suits (including Golden Freddy) were removed and were replaced with the original Bonnie, Chica, Freddy, and Foxy. Afterwards, the Five Children Incident occurs.
3. Scott wouldn't just have the ghost children play musical chairs with the animatronics. Each spirit is trapped in one body, otherwise they could've just left.
4. The FNAF2 location was in business twice. Yes, the same location. The first time period they were open (also when the phone guy makes the phone messages), the purple man is snooping around and then kills the five more children. Those dead child bodies aren't there for no reason or are just a "coincidence". The place gets closed down due to the murders. After everything is cleared up, they re-open for "only a few short weeks" before the bite of 87 happens, closing down FNAF2 for good.

Go to parts:
-1:12 (watch from there)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SgACktyVXbk&index=7&list=PL35FE5C4B157509C9&spfreload=10

For the last time, GOLDEN FREDDY IS NOT A SUIT OR ANIMATRONIC. Think of it: if Golden Freddy was an animatronic or a suit, HOW WOULD HE/SHE BE ABLE TO PASS THROUGH WALLS AND DOORS, AND HOW WOULD HE/SHE BE ABLE TO TURN HIMSELF/HERSELF INTO A FLOATING HEAD?! And if the yellow Freddy in the STAGE 01 minigame is Golden Freddy, then WHY IS HE FAT? Golden Freddy IS NOT FAT. Nightmare Fredbear IS FAT.

You could be right with STAGE 01 happening at Freddy Fazbear's, i mean the diner is called Fredbear's Family Diner, so i doubt Springtrap would have been in business there (or it probably was used, along with yellow versions of Chica and Foxy maybe), maybe they just re-used Fredbear and Springtrap to cut costs, or used modernized versions of them.

You didn't mention The Bite of '87, but i talked about it just to add more proof and make it clear what the deaths of the franchise were and when they happened (1 child at Fredbear's who becomes the Puppet; 5 children at Freddy Fazbear's who become Freddy, Bonnie, Chica, Foxy, Golden Freddy who, for the last time, IS NOT A SUIT OR ANIMATRONIC; Purple Guy who becomes Springtrap), not counting guards who died thanks to the animatronics, and no one died thanks to The Bite of '87, since Phone Guy mentions in FNAF 1 that you can live without a frontal lobe.

The FNAF 2 location being the same as the previous one is a good theory.

And also, Golden Freddy is only trapped as a spirit in the pizzeria. He/She could probably possess or things, since he/she seems powerful enough to do it. I mean, if the Puppet was able to mind-control Purple Guy (not the one with badge and phone) to act like a possessed animatronic during the night (that's pretty much how Springtrap acts in FNAF 3, normal during the day, agressive during the night), then who knows what Golden Freddy is capable of?

Originally posted by Player 1:

Originally posted by Sarcasm:

Am I wrong to think that Pink Guy (if separate from Purple Guy) is Fredbear? And that Purple Fam and Pink Fam both died on dates that were close? Maybe, if they were in a league together, Purple Fam dismantled the animatronics for revenge...




What a ♥♥♥♥♥♥ theory. Move along.

I was thinking the same thing. I have a hunch Purple Guy isn't Pink Guy.

I think it's pretty obvious Purple Guy can't be Pink Guy. The murderer was caught from what i recall, so probably while the children were being ressurected, Pink Guy was in jail. He probably escaped one night and went to the FNAF 2 pizzeria to steal Fredbear (Springtrap is still in the pizzeria, proved by the FNAF 3 minigames, so obviously Fredbear was stolen, not to mention we see a strange Purple Freddy in those minigames, which could be Pink Guy using Fredbear). But if Pink Guy was in jail while the children were being ressurected, then how can he still be at the pizzeria to disable animatronics? This proves that Purple Guy is just a regular guard (probably one of those techinicans Phone Guy mentions in FNAF 3) and not Pink Guy.

And before anyone asks, Pink Guy is NOT Phone Guy. Phone Guy was killed by Golden Freddy, where as Pink Guy was killed by stuffing himself the wrong way inside Springtrap, not to mention Phone Guy talked about the spring suits (Fredbear and Springtrap) being dangerous, so i doubt he would risk trying out Springtrap or Fredbear. Phone Guy also can't be Purple Guy. Purple Guy can disable animatronics, so he's obviously a technician (Phone Guy mentions technicians in FNAF 3). Phone Guy, however, is part of Freddy Fazbear's management (it's implied at some point in the games). He teaches guards how to do their jobs and stuff, so he can't be a technician. Maybe the "phone" Purple Guy holds is a tool, and the fact that it's shaped like a phone is probably just coincidence used to fool us into thinking that Purple Guy is Phone Guy. Not to mention, those were the old times, so cordless phones didn't exist back then, which is more proof against the Purple Guy = Phone Guy theory. I do think there's something shady about Phone Guy though, especially thanks to how he acted on Night 6 in FNAF 2. He was about to mention that the yellow suit (Fredbear) that was took (by Pink Guy probably, or by Phone Guy to make the other animatronics go berserk so they could kill Jeremy, since he probably went to work to investigate, or he probably missed the message, or something) was used in something, but before Phone Guy says that "something", he stops and sighs and just says "Now none of them are acting right.". He also implies to Jeremy to take the day shift, wear his uniform (something that Jeremy would obviously NOT forget since he is a GUARD) and stay close to the animatronics (that's more of a safety thing, but it could also be thanks to the fact that Phone Guy probably wanted Jeremy to provoke the animatronics into killing him), which makes Jeremy the one most likely to be the victim of The Bite of '87, but let's not dig into The Bite, since this discussion isn't about it.

EDIT: Nevermind what i said about Phone Guy not being Purple Guy. There is a possibility that they are the same person, i mean, Phone Guy obviously knows a bit too much about animatronics for a regular guard (he's even part of management), so he probably would have some experience in tech and stuff. Not to mention, in FNAF 2, he says himself that he will take the next night shift in Night 6 (this doesn't necessarily mean he's Fritz Smith, because Night 7 can't happen after Night 6, since during the day, The Bite of '87 happened and the pizzeria was closed, so Night 7 definetly happened inbetween some nights), so this definetly means Phone Guy is allowed to take night shifts. Which could mean he could be Purple Guy, but again, who knows.

[Sarcasm]

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

I think it's pretty obvious Purple Guy can't be Pink Guy. The murderer was caught from what i recall, so probably while the children were being ressurected, Pink Guy was in jail. He probably escaped one night and went to the FNAF 2 pizzeria to steal Fredbear (Springtrap is still in the pizzeria, proved by the FNAF 3 minigames, so obviously Fredbear was stolen, not to mention we see a strange Purple Freddy in those minigames, which could be Pink Guy using Fredbear). But if Pink Guy was in jail while the children were being ressurected, then how can he still be at the pizzeria to disable animatronics? This proves that Purple Guy is just a regular guard (probably one of those techinicans Phone Guy mentions in FNAF 3) and not Pink Guy.

And before anyone asks, Pink Guy is NOT Phone Guy. Phone Guy was killed by Golden Freddy, where as Pink Guy was killed by stuffing himself the wrong way inside Springtrap, not to mention Phone Guy talked about the spring suits (Fredbear and Springtrap) being dangerous, so i doubt he would risk trying out Springtrap or Fredbear. Phone Guy also can't be Purple Guy. Purple Guy can disable animatronics, so he's obviously a technician (Phone Guy mentions technicians in FNAF 3). Phone Guy, however, is part of Freddy Fazbear's management (it's implied at some point in the games). He teaches guards how to do their jobs and stuff, so he can't be a technician. Maybe the "phone" Purple Guy holds is a tool, and the fact that it's shaped like a phone is probably just coincidence used to fool us into thinking that Purple Guy is Phone Guy. Not to mention, those were the old times, so cordless phones didn't exist back then, which is more proof against the Purple Guy = Phone Guy theory. I do think there's something shady about Phone Guy though, especially thanks to how he acted on Night 6 in FNAF 2. He was about to mention that the yellow suit (Fredbear) that was took (by Pink Guy probably, or by Phone Guy to make the other animatronics go berserk so they could kill Jeremy, since he probably went to work to investigate, or he probably missed the message, or something) was used in something, but before Phone Guy says that "something", he stops and sighs and just says "Now none of them are acting right.". He also implies to Jeremy to take the day shift, wear his uniform (something that Jeremy would obviously NOT forget since he is a GUARD) and stay close to the animatronics (that's more of a safety thing, but it could also be thanks to the fact that Phone Guy probably wanted Jeremy to provoke the animatronics into killing him), which makes Jeremy the one most likely to be the victim of The Bite of '87, but let's not dig into The Bite, since this discussion isn't about it.

I thought Purple Guy became the "stuffing" in Springtrap? Purple hues belong to Purple Guys. Now, I agree fully that Pink Guy is not Purple Guy and Purple Guy or Pink Guy are not Phone Guy (yeesh!), but I just wanted to add some contradictory statements so you could argue against them for the fun of it.
But Phone Guy knows how to work the springlock suits? Technician!
Phone Guy works the phone? Technician!
Phone Guy works with animatronics? TECHNICIAN!!!!!
Also, Phone Guy mentions management. He does, however, state that he is a guard...
a GUARD/TECHNICIAN!!!!!!!!

[TheAuditor24]

Originally posted by Sarcasm:

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

I think it's pretty obvious Purple Guy can't be Pink Guy. The murderer was caught from what i recall, so probably while the children were being ressurected, Pink Guy was in jail. He probably escaped one night and went to the FNAF 2 pizzeria to steal Fredbear (Springtrap is still in the pizzeria, proved by the FNAF 3 minigames, so obviously Fredbear was stolen, not to mention we see a strange Purple Freddy in those minigames, which could be Pink Guy using Fredbear). But if Pink Guy was in jail while the children were being ressurected, then how can he still be at the pizzeria to disable animatronics? This proves that Purple Guy is just a regular guard (probably one of those techinicans Phone Guy mentions in FNAF 3) and not Pink Guy.

And before anyone asks, Pink Guy is NOT Phone Guy. Phone Guy was killed by Golden Freddy, where as Pink Guy was killed by stuffing himself the wrong way inside Springtrap, not to mention Phone Guy talked about the spring suits (Fredbear and Springtrap) being dangerous, so i doubt he would risk trying out Springtrap or Fredbear. Phone Guy also can't be Purple Guy. Purple Guy can disable animatronics, so he's obviously a technician (Phone Guy mentions technicians in FNAF 3). Phone Guy, however, is part of Freddy Fazbear's management (it's implied at some point in the games). He teaches guards how to do their jobs and stuff, so he can't be a technician. Maybe the "phone" Purple Guy holds is a tool, and the fact that it's shaped like a phone is probably just coincidence used to fool us into thinking that Purple Guy is Phone Guy. Not to mention, those were the old times, so cordless phones didn't exist back then, which is more proof against the Purple Guy = Phone Guy theory. I do think there's something shady about Phone Guy though, especially thanks to how he acted on Night 6 in FNAF 2. He was about to mention that the yellow suit (Fredbear) that was took (by Pink Guy probably, or by Phone Guy to make the other animatronics go berserk so they could kill Jeremy, since he probably went to work to investigate, or he probably missed the message, or something) was used in something, but before Phone Guy says that "something", he stops and sighs and just says "Now none of them are acting right.". He also implies to Jeremy to take the day shift, wear his uniform (something that Jeremy would obviously NOT forget since he is a GUARD) and stay close to the animatronics (that's more of a safety thing, but it could also be thanks to the fact that Phone Guy probably wanted Jeremy to provoke the animatronics into killing him), which makes Jeremy the one most likely to be the victim of The Bite of '87, but let's not dig into The Bite, since this discussion isn't about it.

I thought Purple Guy became the "stuffing" in Springtrap? Purple hues belong to Purple Guys. Now, I agree fully that Pink Guy is not Purple Guy and Purple Guy or Pink Guy are not Phone Guy (yeesh!), but I just wanted to add some contradictory statements so you could argue against them for the fun of it.
But Phone Guy knows how to work the springlock suits? Technician!
Phone Guy works the phone? Technician!
Phone Guy works with animatronics? TECHNICIAN!!!!!
Also, Phone Guy mentions management. He does, however, state that he is a guard...
a GUARD/TECHNICIAN!!!!!!!!

Let me make it easier for you.

Murderer = Pink Guy = FNAF 3 Purple Guy = FNAF 3 minigame Purple Freddy = Springtrap
Phone Guy = FNAF 2 Purple Guy (possibly, or maybe it's a random technician)

[Sarcasm]

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

Pink Guy = FNAF 3 Purple Guy = FNAF 3 minigame Purple Freddy = Springtrap

Why does a pink guy become a purple guy? HOW does a pink guy become a purple guy?
Do purple guys become pink guys?

[TheAuditor24]

Originally posted by Sarcasm:

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

Pink Guy = FNAF 3 Purple Guy = FNAF 3 minigame Purple Freddy = Springtrap

Why does a pink guy become a purple guy? HOW does a pink guy become a purple guy?
Do purple guys become pink guys?

It's probably supposed to show Pink Guy getting older, or approaching his punishment inside Springtrap. Or maybe it's just to fool us into thinking him and Purple Guy (with badge) is the same person.

[Sarcasm]

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

Originally posted by Sarcasm:

Why does a pink guy become a purple guy? HOW does a pink guy become a purple guy?
Do purple guys become pink guys?

It's probably supposed to show Pink Guy getting older, or approaching his punishment inside Springtrap. Or maybe it's just to fool us into thinking him and Purple Guy (with badge) is the same person.

Eh...

[ErnieC3]

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

Originally posted by Sarcasm:

I thought Purple Guy became the "stuffing" in Springtrap? Purple hues belong to Purple Guys. Now, I agree fully that Pink Guy is not Purple Guy and Purple Guy or Pink Guy are not Phone Guy (yeesh!), but I just wanted to add some contradictory statements so you could argue against them for the fun of it.
But Phone Guy knows how to work the springlock suits? Technician!
Phone Guy works the phone? Technician!
Phone Guy works with animatronics? TECHNICIAN!!!!!
Also, Phone Guy mentions management. He does, however, state that he is a guard...
a GUARD/TECHNICIAN!!!!!!!!

Let me make it easier for you.

Murderer = Pink Guy = FNAF 3 Purple Guy = FNAF 3 minigame Purple Freddy = Springtrap
Phone Guy = Phone Guy pretty much, he has no other variant
FNAF 2 Purple Guy (with badge) = random technician

The Purple Man with a badge is a random technician....are you kidding me?? I know that there are people who over think the game, but that is just completely UNDER thinking it. And he even says "You can't", so that doesn't mean anything?? I mean the whole thing with the Stage 01 mistake and the other five children not being recognized I can understand, but this (and the golden freddy ghost just suddenly deciding to jump into the Fredbear costume)....just...come on. I love theorists, but not ones who don't make sense.

[TheAuditor24]

Originally posted by ErnieCIII:

Originally posted by Titanium_Duke40:

Let me make it easier for you.

Murderer = Pink Guy = FNAF 3 Purple Guy = FNAF 3 minigame Purple Freddy = Springtrap
Phone Guy = Phone Guy pretty much, he has no other variant
FNAF 2 Purple Guy (with badge) = random technician

The Purple Man with a badge is a random technician....are you kidding me?? I know that there are people who over think the game, but that is just completely UNDER thinking it. And he even says "You can't", so that doesn't mean anything?? I mean the whole thing with the Stage 01 mistake and the other five children not being recognized I can understand, but this (and the golden freddy ghost just suddenly deciding to jump into the Fredbear costume)....just...come on. I love theorists, but not ones who don't make sense.

"You can't" could probably be just part of the words Purple Guy says when he disables the animatronic. FNAF 3 Purple Guy (a.k.a. Pink Guy) doesn't say "You can't", but this guy does. Also, how would the murderer know about the animatronics being possessed at first? Maybe Purple Guy doesn't just say "You can't". Maybe he says "You can't do that" or something, because the animatronics aren't allowed to wander around in the pizzeria. Also, no night guard (the ones that stay in the office like the player) is able to disable animatronics (Mike, Jeremy and the FNAF 3 guard would have disabled the animatronics if they were actually able to), and like i said, Phone Guy does mention techinicians in FNAF 3. "You can't" could be there just to fool us, or maybe Purple Guy isn't even the one who says it. Maybe it's the Puppet scolding the player? Who knows. Either way, i like to think that "You can't" is just there to make us think Purple Guy = Pink Guy, but really, they can't be the same imo. Why would Fazbear Entertainment allow Pink Guy out of all the people to be a guard? Not to mention, he probably was in jail at the time (it is mentioned the murderer got caught, as far as i recall). I also doubt it's an intended continuation of "Save them". How would Purple Guy, a regular night guard, know about what the Puppet says to the animatronics? It's not like he/she says it out loud to them. Not even Phone Guy would know.

And how is Purple Guy not able to be a technician? He can disable animatronics without damaging them. How is that not a technician trait? Like i said, he could be Phone Guy too, who has some knowledge in tech even though he helps new guards know what they do.

Also, when i overthink stuff, sometimes i do miss some points, so expect some edits for some of my theories.

And Phone Guy, like i said, is not necessarily Purple Guy. I just like to think he is. I mean, the children spirits probably see all Fazbear workers as Purple Guys.