Did Batman kill Scarecrow

[PowerKristals]

I mean he refuses to kill and all but he feed Scarecrow to Killer Croc so didn't he technically kill Scarecrow?

[Shufflecat]

Originalmente postado por thedarkmessenger:

Originalmente postado por Pepe_DeJefe:

Bear in mind that Batman had no reason to think he didn't kill him either, so far as we see. I mean, he did what he did, regardless of wheather scarecrow managed to survive. So it's not so much that he upheld his "no kill" code, as that he apparently tried to break it (or at the very least willfully ignored it) and failed.

This is true. Batman had just as much reason as Joker to believe Scarecrow died.

Although would it technically be Batman who killed him? Technically, Croc did the deed....but Batman did put Scarecrow in that situation knowing the dangers of doing so....

I think if he expected Croc to kill Scarecrow (in either the "I want him to" or just the "I think it's very likely" sense), then yeah it would count as killing him. Sort of like how hiring a hit man or deliberately pushing someone in front of a moving car would be considered murder/attempted murder, even though you'd be one person removed from the actual wet bits.

[HimeAria]

Originalmente postado por Pepe_DeJefe:

Originalmente postado por thedarkmessenger:

This is true. Batman had just as much reason as Joker to believe Scarecrow died.

Although would it technically be Batman who killed him? Technically, Croc did the deed....but Batman did put Scarecrow in that situation knowing the dangers of doing so....

I think if he expected Croc to kill Scarecrow (in either the "I want him to" or just the "I think it's very likely" sense), then yeah it would count as killing him. Sort of like how hiring a hit man or deliberately pushing someone in front of a moving car would be considered murder/attempted murder, even though you'd be one person removed from the actual wet bits.

Right. For some reason I forgot about that. Whoops :B

I doubt Batman was thinking "Scarecrow can totally handle this" when he threw the guy in...

[Tycoooooooooooooooooooooooooon!]

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ why is this still going on just search up the trailer for arkahm night its not that hard?

[HimeAria]

Originalmente postado por PWGforever:

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ why is this still going on just search up the trailer for arkahm night its not that hard?

uhh....because we're not aware that Arkham Knight answers our question on Batman killing Scarecrow?

And actually, does it even answer that question, or are you thinking this discussion is about something we're not even talking about at all?

And why is it such a huge issue to you in the first place? If you don't like the thread, then ignore it. Report it if you feel like you have to, even. (good luck with that)

[Troop]

Originalmente postado por thedarkmessenger:

Originalmente postado por PWGforever:

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ why is this still going on just search up the trailer for arkahm night its not that hard?

uhh....because we're not aware that Arkham Knight answers our question on Batman killing Scarecrow?

And actually, does it even answer that question, or are you thinking this discussion is about something we're not even talking about at all?

And why is it such a huge issue to you in the first place? If you don't like the thread, then ignore it. Report it if you feel like you have to, even. (good luck with that)

Scarecrow is one of the MAIN villains in Arkham Knight.

[Shufflecat]

That question got settled early, and then the thread moved on to whether or not Batman actually tried to kill Scarecrow.

Acting exasperated and telling people to look up the Arkham Knight trailer was just hilariously clueless at that point. Dude was obviously posting without reading... at best.

[Tycoooooooooooooooooooooooooon!]

Originalmente postado por Trooper:

Originalmente postado por thedarkmessenger:

uhh....because we're not aware that Arkham Knight answers our question on Batman killing Scarecrow?

And actually, does it even answer that question, or are you thinking this discussion is about something we're not even talking about at all?

And why is it such a huge issue to you in the first place? If you don't like the thread, then ignore it. Report it if you feel like you have to, even. (good luck with that)

Scarecrow is one of the MAIN villains in Arkham Knight.

THANK YOU

[HimeAria]

Originalmente postado por PWGforever:

Originalmente postado por Trooper:

Scarecrow is one of the MAIN villains in Arkham Knight.

THANK YOU

I once again have to ask why this is such a personal matter to you. We already moved past that point of discussion when you first joined in, and you've added nothing but entertainment at your own clueless expense.

[Kawalorn]

OK if you guys didn't notice, Croc jumped on Scarecrow and Batman threw a batarang at Croc's collar to incanpacitate him probably hoping he will drop Scarecrow. Which he did not. As far as I saw Bats tried to save him and there wasn't much more he could do.

[Stabbey]

Originalmente postado por Kawalorn:

OK if you guys didn't notice, Croc jumped on Scarecrow and Batman threw a batarang at Croc's collar to incanpacitate him probably hoping he will drop Scarecrow. Which he did not. As far as I saw Bats tried to save him and there wasn't much more he could do.

Yeah, this.

Also if you want to talk about Batman breaking his no-kill rule, in the Medical Area, to rescue one of the doctors, you need to batarang a rope holding a criminal, who crashes through the ceiling into Joker toxin, dying.

[Troop]

Originalmente postado por Stabbey:

Originalmente postado por Kawalorn:

OK if you guys didn't notice, Croc jumped on Scarecrow and Batman threw a batarang at Croc's collar to incanpacitate him probably hoping he will drop Scarecrow. Which he did not. As far as I saw Bats tried to save him and there wasn't much more he could do.

Yeah, this.

Also if you want to talk about Batman breaking his no-kill rule, in the Medical Area, to rescue one of the doctors, you need to batarang a rope holding a criminal, who crashes through the ceiling into Joker toxin, dying.

You rescue him immediately after. batman even says this.

[HimeAria]

Originalmente postado por Trooper:

Originalmente postado por Stabbey:

Yeah, this.

Also if you want to talk about Batman breaking his no-kill rule, in the Medical Area, to rescue one of the doctors, you need to batarang a rope holding a criminal, who crashes through the ceiling into Joker toxin, dying.

You rescue him immediately after. batman even says this.

He says that....but let's be honest: it's not true. I don't care what the game thinks, the guy fell through a ROOF. A roof that COMPLETELY SHATTERED FROM THE IMPACT. Oh, and did I mention that the roof is NOT made of glass?

I don't believe for a second he survived that kind of an impact. Never mind the Joker toxin (which you do get rid of), the roof killed him before the toxin ever had a chance. He's not Croc. He's not Batman. He's "generic bad guy henchman criminal #263".

[Troop]

Originalmente postado por thedarkmessenger:

Originalmente postado por Trooper:

You rescue him immediately after. batman even says this.

He says that....but let's be honest: it's not true. I don't care what the game thinks, the guy fell through a ROOF. A roof that COMPLETELY SHATTERED FROM THE IMPACT. Oh, and did I mention that the roof is NOT made of glass?

I don't believe for a second he survived that kind of an impact. Never mind the Joker toxin (which you do get rid of), the roof killed him before the toxin ever had a chance. He's not Croc. He's not Batman. He's "generic bad guy henchman criminal #263".

It didn't seem like that bad of a fall. The roof was pretty instable so that's why it collapsed. But let's just agree to disagree.

[HimeAria]

Originalmente postado por Trooper:

Originalmente postado por thedarkmessenger:

He says that....but let's be honest: it's not true. I don't care what the game thinks, the guy fell through a ROOF. A roof that COMPLETELY SHATTERED FROM THE IMPACT. Oh, and did I mention that the roof is NOT made of glass?

I don't believe for a second he survived that kind of an impact. Never mind the Joker toxin (which you do get rid of), the roof killed him before the toxin ever had a chance. He's not Croc. He's not Batman. He's "generic bad guy henchman criminal #263".

It didn't seem like that bad of a fall. The roof was pretty instable so that's why it collapsed. But let's just agree to disagree.

Or we could just agree it's a fantasy video game based off a fantasy comic book :p

In that sense then yeah, he probably did actually survive. I still doubt the survivability of such a fall IRL, but I guess I can't really say I'm an expert in this field. That, and miracles DO occur on occasion. Either way it's not a huge deal, so time to move on to the next subject!

.....what's our next subject? :D

[Troop]

Originalmente postado por thedarkmessenger:

Originalmente postado por Trooper:

It didn't seem like that bad of a fall. The roof was pretty instable so that's why it collapsed. But let's just agree to disagree.

Or we could just agree it's a fantasy video game based off a fantasy comic book :p

In that sense then yeah, he probably did actually survive. I still doubt the survivability of such a fall IRL, but I guess I can't really say I'm an expert in this field. That, and miracles DO occur on occasion. Either way it's not a huge deal, so time to move on to the next subject!

.....what's our next subject? :D

And now, onto sports.