Last Harvest Achievement missing (spoiler)

[( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)]

I didn't obtain some achievements i should, notably the Last Harvest one.

I did the side mission near perfectly, but when i talked to the killer at the end, she stooded up and fought me. I didn't kill her, get the chip and convince the cop to believe me. So, just because i don't do the right dialogue against her one time, i don't have the achievement? This is really REALLY stupid. And i guess the other achievement i don't get are for similar reasons.

Since when you have to do it perfectly to get achievement for finishing one side quest?

[Awaken]

With C.A.S.I.E it's impossible to make a mistake unless you're not paying attention.

However, if you're going on the normal dialogue selections it really is hit or miss (just like HR). There's a chance you say the right thing, and a chance that you say the wrong thing even if you're answering identically.

For it to succeed, you have to have talked to the Dr. If you didn't do that, you missed out on half of the criteria to get this achievement.

You have to coerce Dr. Capri to give you the safe word, and you have to use that whilst convincing her that she's not Sovbotka. If she doesn't believe it, it's failed as the achievement is solely about saving her. Not turning her into the police, but making her herself again.

[( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)]

Thanks for the answer.

I talked to the doctor and he ask me to bring him the chip once i "killed her". When i talked to her, I mentioned the doctor but she burst of anger and attacked me.

But, i understand than i don't have the achievement because i fought her. I just think it's stupid than i didn't get ANY achievement even if i do everything in the sidequest except answer the right thing one time. That's really arbitrary.

[dzxbeast]

Originally posted by Pompidou:

With C.A.S.I.E it's impossible to make a mistake unless you're not paying attention.

the cop knows when you try to use casie, and gets very angry. you have to talk to him yourself

[Awaken]

True, certain achievements are more forgiving than others. That is one thing I noticed now that you've mentioned it, the achievements in MD are geared towards you being the good guy.

In HR, there were achievements where you were supposed to behave badly to get them.

[( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)]

Originally posted by Pompidou:

True, certain achievements are more forgiving than others. That is one thing I noticed now that you've mentioned it, the achievements in MD are geared towards you being the good guy.

In HR, there were achievements where you were supposed to behave badly to get them.

Maybe not two achievements, but something like "you stopped the harvester" regardless of the way to do it.

[Awaken]

Originally posted by Kaposi:

Maybe not two achievements, but something like "you stopped the harvester" regardless of the way to do it.

You're preaching to the choir mate. I'm an achievement addict as well

[Timi]

Originally posted by Kaposi:

Since when you have to do it perfectly to get achievement for finishing one side quest?

Isn't exactly what achievements are supposed to do? /Achievements/, not participation badges.

[Selfish Lee Everett]

Look , if you actually read up on the achievement, it literally tells you what you need to do. That's one of the easiest ones to get.

[( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)]

Originally posted by Timi:

Originally posted by Kaposi:

Since when you have to do it perfectly to get achievement for finishing one side quest?

Isn't exactly what achievements are supposed to do? /Achievements/, not participation badges.

Originally posted by Selfish Lee Everett:

Look , if you actually read up on the achievement, it literally tells you what you need to do. That's one of the easiest ones to get.

I didn't look the achievement list before playing to the game but, i suppose, it have to reward the player to do a multiple hours side quest if you achieve the right way even if you don't get the perfect ending possible. I don't want to redo the game just for answer another thing on a dialogue.

And actually, without being hard, it is the hardest one, look at the completion pourcentage. I guess i'm not the only one.

[( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)]

Originally posted by Pompidou:

Originally posted by Kaposi:

Maybe not two achievements, but something like "you stopped the harvester" regardless of the way to do it.

You're preaching to the choir mate. I'm an achievement addict as well :highlvl:

It's not really than i am a achievement hunter or whatsoever, but i like to do everything in a game on first try and have the maximum story related achievement possible. For this game i tried to not use a guide for the choices and i succeed everything except THIS. Now i have to redo the game entirely AND the first Harvester quest only to re-answer something different at the end and that pisses me off.

[B4d*Hom8r3]

I finished the mission without kill in her, using C.A.S.I.E., and still I didn't get the achievement. :(