Episode 5: Silence is "Not" an valid option

[Death Korps of Krieg]

I play this game and all other telltale games in 3 ways,

First is my original playthrough,

2nd is my playthrough with heinsight of whats to come

and my 3rd playthrough is one where i am completely passive and take silence on all options.


This has worked in all games from the walking dead to the wolf among us, and now also here in Game of Thrones,

However now here in Episode 5, i get to see Queen-Mother ceircy lannister, with handmaiden Mira forrester,

I choose silence on ever option here aswell, but the Queen is not to pleased with my silence while she is interrogating me,

on the 2nd question that i choose to ignore to answer, Her Guard smacks me in the face.

on the 3rd question that i choose to ignore to answer, the guard pulls out his sword and looks me very threatning.

on the 4th question that i choose to ignore to answer, Queen ceircy says: "i guess she was useless after all....... KILL HER"


And so here ends my playthrough as the Mute who lost his tongue at the beginning of each game.......

[Douglas Quaid]

This was the worst episode by far. When Ramsey asks you to leave the sword, you can either say yes or no, but either choice he grabs your sword anyway. So what's the damn point?

[myrvogna]

Silence stays a valid option.

You just have to deal with the consequences.

[yusupov]

still a ♥♥♥♥ episode

[Silent J]

Αναρτήθηκε αρχικά από Mom's Spaghetti:

Silence stays a valid option.

You just have to deal with the consequences.

I feel like I am dealing with consequences of ♥♥♥♥♥♥ writing not the consequences of my own actions which is I feel, a fairly significant distinction.

[LtlMacMcG]

Αναρτήθηκε αρχικά από Mom's Spaghetti:

Silence stays a valid option.

You just have to deal with the consequences.

Haha, this. ^

[LtlMacMcG]

Αναρτήθηκε αρχικά από 116th | Heisenberg:

Αναρτήθηκε αρχικά από Mom's Spaghetti:

Silence stays a valid option.

You just have to deal with the consequences.

I feel like I am dealing with consequences of ♥♥♥♥♥♥ writing not the consequences of my own actions which is I feel, a fairly significant distinction.

I dunno...I have a lot of issues with this episode.....but the reality is that silence simply is not going to be a viable option when dealing with someone who is demanding a response, views it as a challenge to not respond, and as the ability to kill and torture at her whim. It would have been less convincing if she DIDN"T kill to be honest.

[Nukehouse247]

If I recall, there were plenty of moments in the other game where if you didn't speak, nothing happened so you just had to speak at least something. This is one of those moments, except the consequence is real, as it should be.

[GregStrider]

Αναρτήθηκε αρχικά από Douglas Quaid:

This was the worst episode by far. When Ramsey asks you to leave the sword, you can either say yes or no, but either choice he grabs your sword anyway. So what's the damn point?

Is that the very first TTG's game you're playing?

[Spekpater]

Finally people are seeing the "tailoring to how you play" ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ TTG uses. There are no valid choices..

These games should be called.. Speech simulator 2015. Choose what you want to say but not every time because then your character dies and that ends the playthrough,

[Death Korps of Krieg]

I find it a pity it isnt a Real concequence i cant change, as soon as Mira Forrester dies after that conversation, u get the message of Valar Morghulis game over.

So i cant kill off Mira Forrester, even if wanted to, because she is not staying dead, and letting the story continue.... i wish i could kill her off,

[tonym3701]

Game of Thrones by Telltale Games is a marriage made in heaven. George RR Martin doesn't give a ♥♥♥♥ about the fans. David Benioff and D. B. Weiss (and the rest of HBO) treat the fans even worse. And now we have TTG, the company that cause fans more rage than any other popular independent videogame developer.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FT4_Fefew78

[Death Korps of Krieg]

@tonym3701, Why are u using my thread about Silence is not an valid option, to complain about the game?

Im not dissapointed with this episode nor with the game developers, nor does it causes any rage.

Please keep your complaints to your own made threads, and please stay on topic in this thread

[Can'tTouchThis]

Αναρτήθηκε αρχικά από skapunker:

@tonym3701, Why are u using my thread about Silence is not an valid option, to complain about the game?

Im not dissapointed with this episode nor with the game developers, nor does it causes any rage.

Please keep your complaints to your own made threads, and please stay on topic in this thread

Because, not being able to choose silence every time would be a possible reason to complain about the game? So why are you complaining about people complaining?

[tonym3701]

Αναρτήθηκε αρχικά από skapunker:

@tonym3701, Why are u using my thread about Silence is not an valid option, to complain about the game?

Im not dissapointed with this episode nor with the game developers, nor does it causes any rage.

Please keep your complaints to your own made threads, and please stay on topic in this thread

Excuse me?

Because it IS a problem with the game that silence is not a valid option.

And just because you started the thread doen't mean that it must follw the EXACT direction that you want it to go. Deal with it.

[LtlMacMcG]

Αναρτήθηκε αρχικά από tonym3701:

Αναρτήθηκε αρχικά από skapunker:

@tonym3701, Why are u using my thread about Silence is not an valid option, to complain about the game?

Im not dissapointed with this episode nor with the game developers, nor does it causes any rage.

Please keep your complaints to your own made threads, and please stay on topic in this thread

Excuse me?

Because it IS a problem with the game that silence is not a valid option.

And just because you started the thread doen't mean that it must follw the EXACT direction that you want it to go. Deal with it.

I disagree that silence not being a valid a valid option is a problem. I actually like that trying to remain silent results in death....as in this situation it makes perfect sense.

I do agree with the second half of your statement, though