Nathan should take a beating or not?

[ShadowBeak]

I wonder if Warren should or should not give a beating in Nathan. What kind of result it might cause in the future?

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Kayla TheWeirdo:

Escrito originalmente por PrideSP:

Which isn't what Warren did. Warren beat Nathan for a good reason.

to protect Chloe and Max? Nathan didnt really seem to kill them lol

Yes. To protect Chloe and Max and Nathan deserve it. Nathan did harm. I'm not laughing.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Trindave:

Escrito originalmente por Kayla TheWeirdo:

to protect Chloe and Max? Nathan didnt really seem to kill them lol

yo I need to hit that guy's face sixteen times in order to protect dem girls

Nathan deserved it and he did protect the girls.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por UCSC KaraThrace:

Escrito originalmente por PrideSP:

Which isn't what Warren did. Warren beat Nathan for a good reason.

I find it interesting that you defend Warren beating up Nathan (and Warren in general) to the bitter end, since Warren doesn't seem particularly glad to have beaten up Nathan. If you let him beat Nathan to a pulp, he will constantly exprewss regret afterwards, and seems to wish you had stopped him. If you do stop him, he constantly thanks you for keeping him from going further. It just seems odd to me that you defend Warren to the death, except in this case where he explicitly regrets what you want him to do.

Warren is like that because of his character. He barely showed that he regret it and he didn't wish you had stopped him. He did do it, and he did the right thing. And he talked about it too. About being a hero. He even said that Nathan had it coming. Nathan deserves it. It's what heroes do, it's what Warren does.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Kayla TheWeirdo:

Escrito originalmente por Michael:

Warren didn't kill Nathan either. In a guy's eyes there is not a winner until the other surrenders by submission. Warren stops on his own once Nathan submits.

if Max wasnt there to stop Warren, Nathan could have been in a hospital/dead :D

If Max wasn't there to stop Warren, Nathan wouldn't have been in a hospital or dead. If this, if that. If is nothing. If Max wasn't there, this wouldn't have happened. If it was anyone else but Nathan, Warren wouldn't have done what he done. Warren is a good guy. Nathan is a bad guy. Warren did good.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Kayla TheWeirdo:

Escrito originalmente por Michael:

My Max didn't stop Warren, and he stops on his own.
The first would be deserved. Remember Nathan did have a gun and attempted to pull it out, so I'd have no tears over the second. Nathan could have shot Warren like he did Chloe. Nathan is doing things of his own free will and nobody forced him to carry that gun.

Nathan always has a gun and if Warren wasnt there Nathan wouldnt pull it out. But no, Warren wants to "protect" Max by beating the living ♥♥♥♥ out of ppl. And yes, he stopped after Nathan started crying. (no need to mention his face)

also im not specifically saying that someone is forcing Nathan to have a gun. (we actually dont know that so far tho)

If Warren wasn't there. Nathan would pull it out. Warren did protect Max. Nathan did deserve it. What about his face? he deserved it. No one forced Nathan to do most of the things to Max and Chloe and Warren.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Veril:

What's ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up tho is that no one tried to grab the gun when you stop Warren. Chloe could have grabbed it while Max was pulling Warren away.

Chloe was stun in shock and if Chloe picked up the gun immediately, Nathan would still able to fight her back for it. I mean they can hold Nathan but he'll still go crazy for that gun.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Kayla TheWeirdo:

Escrito originalmente por Michael:

I'm not sure Warren knew Max was there. Warren came out of his room only after he heard Nathan screaming.Nathan drugging Chloe on his own points to him enjoying himself when it comes to taking the girls, why else keep the picture?

Nathan said "you're such a nosey ♥♥♥♥♥ Max" so...
im sure Warren's reaction would be.. weird

we dont really know why Nathan drugged Chloe. maybe it was to impress his father or something? :p

Escrito originalmente por Kayla TheWeirdo:

Escrito originalmente por Trindave:

- dad why u no notice me
- cuz u a lil ♥♥♥♥
- but i am screaming 4 ur attention
- ok, drug som girls and stuff
- lel k

lol thats not it works tho

Yes, it's exactly how it works. There is no reason for him to do what he does.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Kayla TheWeirdo:

Escrito originalmente por Michael:

That's the thing you or I are not Nathan. Nathan has been given free rein to do whatever he wants. He's been helping Jefferson kidnap girls, and so somewhere in his twist little brain he thinks he can do that for himself.

he is being controlled to these stuff ~.~

No, he's not.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Kayla TheWeirdo:

Escrito originalmente por Ratsneve:

Well, I've hardly started the game having just arrived at Cloe's house for the first time and I've avoided the comments above to prevent potentially getting spoiled, but my first impressions of Nathan Prescott are that he is the one who should end up missing or dead.

he shouldnt

Yes, he should.

[Michael]

Escrito originalmente por Kayla TheWeirdo:

Escrito originalmente por Michael:

Well first he yelled "You're in my dorm!" I think Warren was already out the door at that point, trying to see what was going on. Maybe Nathan drugged Chloe because he was in some twisted way trying to hit on her? He really only knows Victoria and her minons, so that's not much interaction to go on for him.

that doesnt make much sense, no offense xD

Warren was out the door before Nathan said Max's name. The second part implies Nathan is bad with women and maybe he just wanted to get to know Chloe a little better :D

[Fracture]

Max's MIlkshake brings Warren to the yard, he's like 'damn right, let's go ape!'

[Axion]

No because that willl make Warren as bad as Nathan and it was in front of Max. That's why I didn't give him a beating. What does violence really solve? It will just made the situation worse.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Morosi:

No because that willl make Warren as bad as Nathan and it was in front of Max. That's why I didn't give him a beating. What does violence really solve? It will just made the situation worse.

No, it doesn't make Warren as bad as Nathan and it being in front of Max doesn't matter. Then Warren might as well start drugging girls and kidnapping and shipping them to the photography teacher to take pictures of them. Warren is better than Nathan. Yeah, because allowing evil to continue really solves anything. Stopping and doing good doesn't make the situation worse.

[Crynosaur]

Escrito originalmente por PrideSP:

Escrito originalmente por Veril:

What's ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up tho is that no one tried to grab the gun when you stop Warren. Chloe could have grabbed it while Max was pulling Warren away.

Chloe was stun in shock and if Chloe picked up the gun immediately, Nathan would still able to fight her back for it. I mean they can hold Nathan but he'll still go crazy for that gun.

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥. She didn't hesitate to push him back when he tried to go after Max. And Nathan was already incapacitated when Warren went at him. If Chloe had the gun, there's a big possibility Nathan will back down and leave them alone for now. If Nathan went after them, Warren is still there to play the Ape.

Also as Trindave said, Max could take the gun if she rewinded but she didn't and let him have it if you chose the 'Intervene' option.

[PrideTheBest]

Escrito originalmente por Veril:

Escrito originalmente por PrideSP:

Chloe was stun in shock and if Chloe picked up the gun immediately, Nathan would still able to fight her back for it. I mean they can hold Nathan but he'll still go crazy for that gun.

♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥. She didn't hesitate to push him back when he tried to go after Max. And Nathan was already incapacitated when Warren went at him. If Chloe had the gun, there's a big possibility Nathan will back down and leave them alone for now. If Nathan went after them, Warren is still there to play the Ape.

Also as Trindave said, Max could take the gun if she rewinded but she didn't and let him have it if you chose the 'Intervene' option.

She was shock what Warren did to Nathan, you can see the expression on her face. And if Max stops Warren, Nathan would fought back for the gun. Well Max stop him, and he left the building afterwards. Not sure about that, there's a big possibility that Nathan would fought back for his gun, many people would. Max isn't a person to take guns or abuse her powers like that.