Kill Chloe or let her live?

[ShadowBeak]

In the scene where she's in bed and asks to die from euthanasia. It would be the right choice to kill her or ignore her desire?

There is a small possibility of medical diagnosis is wrong and she survives. Then Max would be committing a crime by murdering her own friend.

Remember that the choices based on Chloe's suggestion tend to be bad.

[Trindave]

I had to do it.

I wanted to kill her for like three ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ episodes so

[Skywise]

i did kill her, but not just based on her suggestion. if you go around the house, and look at everything, you get a bigger picture. i may have made the wrong choice though. it was tough.

[ShadowBeak]

I believe that Chloe did not die when she was shot by Nathan in the bathroom.

The same thing happens in the alternate universe.

Probably the doctors were wrong about the diagnosis of Chloe and she shall live.

Max can not kill her so suddenly.

[THEREALTHERION]

You'd be an idiot to do that in a real situation. It's not fair to the parents and it WOULD get you in some serious ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ trouble with the law.

There are other things you can do to Chloe that get you in serious legal trouble, too, but she told me she loved it ;)

[Dragoon]

It's just wrong, their is no way that Max, as her friend, could ever agree to that.

[Trindave]

euthanasia is wrong, but putting Chloe is a wheelchair for the rest of her life is ok

and don't even say "Max didn't saw that coming", like a movie geek like her hasn't watched Butterfly Effect? yeh sure kk i blame Warren anyway, he should include that movie in his party buster flashdrive folder

[฿ắ฿λ▬Beast]

(

[Doughryen]

I've read that euthanasia is not illegal in Oregon, but even then it's still kinda bad because of the moral choice. Just wanted to make a point about that

[swaders]

Obviously, in real life if you don't want to end up in jail you shouldn't euthanize someone on request. In real life what to do is easy but this is not real life we are dealing with. We are dealing with a game in which someone caused a friend to end up in a wheel chair because of tampering with time. If it weren't for Max Chloe wouldn't have been in a wheelchair and she would have likely died at the hands of Nathan.

I am not buying into the notion that Chloe wouldn't have died at the bathroom. There are no real hints to that effect and it is merely based on that someone could possibly live from such a gunshot and not much else. I believe that the developers fully intended for her to die.

I also don't believe the doctors misdiagnosed Chloe with Chloe clearly noticing her health is getting worse without her even knowing about the exact diagnose in the first place.

[Palatine Katinka]

I was planning to kill her in my second play but went for "I don't know" with the intention of rewinding after seeing that conversation and choosing to accept her wishes. The game didn't seem to like that though and after rewinding through that conversation Max jumped straight to using the photo, avoiding the topic completely. Officially she refused even though she technically was never asked. Although, I guess technically she was never asked in any play of the game since she rewrote that reality in an attempt to get back to normal (I still wonder if everything did go back to normal, Max wouldn't know a subtle change).

[Myth Alric]

Originally posted by DarkRisado:

I believe that Chloe did not die when she was shot by Nathan in the bathroom.

The same thing happens in the alternate universe.

Probably the doctors were wrong about the diagnosis of Chloe and she shall live.

Max can not kill her so suddenly.

It would be crazy if Max tries everything to save Chloe and she keeps ending up dead, but then has to go back to the first episode and let her get shot to save her. Which if she got shot would get Nathan arrested for sure, he confesses to everything that is going on, and the story is resolved!

[Белый Кот]

Originally posted by James:

Originally posted by DarkRisado:

I believe that Chloe did not die when she was shot by Nathan in the bathroom.

The same thing happens in the alternate universe.

Probably the doctors were wrong about the diagnosis of Chloe and she shall live.

Max can not kill her so suddenly.

It would be crazy if Max tries everything to save Chloe and she keeps ending up dead, but then has to go back to the first episode and let her get shot to save her. Which if she got shot would get Nathan arrested for sure, he confesses to everything that is going on, and the story is resolved!

1) Rewind to bathroom scene of Ep1
2) Take the hammer
3) Hit Nathan with hammer to get him unconscious (if you kill him it's not a big deal)
4) Take all his clothes off and put them into Max bag (don't forget, you keep all items you pick while people lose them)
5) Rewind a few minutes back, while Nathan was still in corridor

And if you are really cruel:
Rip his eyes off and put them into bag before rewinding

Anyway if you want to stop Nathan you don't need him to kill anyone.

[Valdyr]

Originally posted by James:

Which if she got shot would get Nathan arrested for sure, he confesses to everything that is going on, and the story is resolved!

More like Sean Prescott holds a press conference and expresses deep sorrow over the breakdown of his mentally unstable son, who has killed some poor girl and concocted a schizophrenic fantasy built on delusions and hallucinations in order to deny responsibility. No confession or testimony from someone like Nathan is going to stick against someone with the wealth and power of Sean. Nathan is even already known in the community as crazy and unstable.

[Porky Pig]

I don't like Chloe, I find her manipulative. She feels sorry for herself all the time "woe is me" all shes goes on about is rachel, if I was Max I'd tell her to take a run and jump.

[Jeckenn]

The way I looked at it was, here was my BFF asking/begging me to help her make her final choice to end her life so her parents could have a better life. After I thought about it like that, saw all the bills that were piling up on the Price family, saw how my BFF was likely going to die anyway in a few more months from her resperatory problems, with tears streaming I helped my BFF make her choice to end her life.

Also realize that Max created that ♥♥♥♥♥♥ up timeline by altering the real timeline and saving Chloe's father William from his fatal car accident. So if Max had never done that then that timeline would not even exist. Max PUT her BFF in that wheelchair and she begged me to end it for her, I complied but still had tears doing it...:(