Easiest and hardest in-game choice.

[deadektmiu]

I was wondering, which choices did you find easiest and hardest in LiS?

[sputnik]

Easiest: kissing Chloe xD
Hardest: last one *cries in a corner*

[DELTA]

Easiest: be nice to david, i felt like he needed kindness because i reckon he has PTSD or depression
Hardest: not sure yet.

[Makesin]

Easiest was definitely the choice regarding Pompidou. I mean, even without knowing the result beforehand, throwing a bone to the road is too close to deliberately killing the poor dog. And that's just not nice.

Hardest for me was actually the choice in Episode 4 regarding killing Chloe in the alternative timeline. Even if I was pretty sure that Max would return back and delete this whole timeline, I just sat there fpr several minutes, unsure what to do.

[Jdwarfer]

Same here, Pompidou for the easiest, and last one for the hardest.
Edit, on second thought, I think the easiest was kiising Chloe because I hesitated a couple of seconds before throwing the bone on the parking lot... because at this time I hated Frank.

[vchen91745]

Originally posted by reckless:

Easiest: kissing Chloe xD
Hardest: last one *cries in a corner*

Me too.
Easiest: Kissing Chloe may have been the easiest choice of all time

Hardest: Sacrifice the Bay or sacrifice the Bae? Actually it was hard not for the same reason as most other people. I was ready to kill the Bay but I was afraid my Bae would be mad that I didn't honour her wishes (Chloe keeps pushing you to sacrifice her), and thus killed Joyce, etc. That was the only thing holding me back. I didn't want Chloe to resent Max. But in the end, I saved Bae, and I was grateful she wasn't even mad.

[Capybara #PS5 Expedition 33]

Easiest: Kiss or Take the blame. I didn't realize how to enter the closet on my 1st time lol when had to hurry and step-douche charged in. Ofc I couldn't blame Chloe <3.

Hardest: Paralyzed Chloe ask me to end her life. I know she's suffering, but can I do it? Am I allowed to do it? I did put her there...I feel so sorry for her. If I don't she might hate me and have severe pains. I love her and I don't want to see her die... But as being Chloe's best friend who hasn't visited her in long time, I don't want her to hate me. A while later, I slowly watch my best friend to close her eyes and enter the afterlife, after telling me how proud she is about me of following my dreams, and ask me not to forget her... <(T__T)>..........

I didn't always rewind choices on first playthrough. Anyway, this choice is still hard for me when replayed.

The last choice of the game didn't feel as hard, because I just couldn't lose her again. So I did my choice easier, although still mourning over the dead town residents. It skyrocket in emotional side when save Chloe and Obstacles is just perfect.

[TamoDogo]

Easiest for me was probably anything to do concerning Kate. Like in the diner when Kate calls you, and you can either answer it or ignore it: i answered, i always chose to help her without thought, depression is an absolute ♥♥♥♥♥ of a thing in real life. i was absolutely devastated when i couldnt stop her from jumping off the roof

hardest: im not too sure, there was a few times when i was like "i seriously cannot answer this question" and i would sit there thinking about it.

[Blackwell_ninja]

Hardest: revealing/not revealing the truth about Chloe´s death to David after he saved Max in dark room. On one side, I wanted to see Jefferson dead, but i couldn´t stand seeing David so hopeless and destroyed by her death
Easiest: the last choice and kissing Chloe choice

[Capybara #PS5 Expedition 33]

Originally posted by Tomazzah:

Easiest for me was probably anything to do concerning Kate. Like in the diner when Kate calls you, and you can either answer it or ignore it: i answered, i always chose to help her without thought, depression is an absolute ♥♥♥♥♥ of a thing in real life. i was absolutely devastated when i couldnt stop her from jumping off the roof

hardest: im not too sure, there was a few times when i was like "i seriously cannot answer this question" and i would sit there thinking about it.

Yea I was considering Kate too as easiest, I never liked bullies in my school days either and wanted to help her. I felt really good when was able to save her. It's hard to pick the number one choices though, when there's quite many :).

[TamoDogo]

Originally posted by Gatsu:

Originally posted by Tomazzah:

Easiest for me was probably anything to do concerning Kate. Like in the diner when Kate calls you, and you can either answer it or ignore it: i answered, i always chose to help her without thought, depression is an absolute ♥♥♥♥♥ of a thing in real life. i was absolutely devastated when i couldnt stop her from jumping off the roof

hardest: im not too sure, there was a few times when i was like "i seriously cannot answer this question" and i would sit there thinking about it.

Yea I was considering Kate too as easiest, I never liked bullies in my school days either and wanted to help her. I felt really good when was able to save her. It's hard to pick the number one choices though, when there's quite many :).

Yea, i messed up on the one where you have to chose the quote from the bible. when Max started saying it, i realised it was the one Kate had scribbled out in her book, so at that moment my heart just sank

Originally posted by BaeOverBay:

Easiest: the last choice and kissing Chloe choice

Your name explains the answers you chose :P

[Capybara #PS5 Expedition 33]

I don't remember saying anything of bible when I saved her, but I guess it depends how you answer. In the last choice I had to say there are still some who care for her and I remember his father always supporting him, so I picked that :), glad I did.

[TamoDogo]

Originally posted by Gatsu:

I don't remember saying anything of bible when I saved her, but I guess it depends how you answer. In the last choice I had to say there are still some who care for her and I remember his father always supporting him, so I picked that :), glad I did.

I remember that, but it was the one after. there was 2 quotes to chose from or you didnt say anything, and im pretty sure i meantioned her father caring about her before the quote..... ive screwed up somewhere :'(

[Marmorkuchen]

Bacon omelette or Belgian waffles was definetly the hardest one :D

[Jeckenn]

I know it was not a choice but when Max was 18 again in the alternate reality where that has Wheelchair Chloe in it the entire trip to go see what happened to Chloe in that reality was like torture to me. I knew it was going to be ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ horrible and when I was finally shown Chloe in a wheelchair I was crying like a baby right along with Max..thinking..."what did I do???"

That whole thing was so well done, so epic in how it makes the player feel, and I can't remember any game ever giving me the feels I got from that scene. It absolutely took my breath away and then some and I will NEVER forget it.

Easiest...Kissing Chloe when dared to.. :D

[Tirigon]

Easiset was to kiss Chloe, as many pointed out already.... but I feel that is kind of a joke answer
On a more serious note, the easiest for me were killing Chloe when she wants to die in the alternative timeline, and saving her in the end - because neither was a choice at all for me. Actually going through with it was hard, of course, but I have always believed that one should be able to choose one's own fate, so when she explains that she is going to die soon anyways and wants to choose for herself one last time, I dont see how anyone could refuse her.


The hardest choice is harder to say... I think it might actually be whether or not you shoot Frank, because it's a lose-lose situation: Shoot him, and you have to live with the fact that you would have willingly killed someone (even though it was kinda in self-defense), and you have made everything more dangerous for you as he's going to be pissed... or dont, and you have acted like a f*cking ♥♥♥♥♥ and made everything more dangerous as well because Chloe loses her gun and a crazy criminal ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ gets it.