Basing this on the ''imagine if rachel didn't die'' discussion

[Rachel D.]

Okay so, I'm basing this on the discussion ''imagine if Rachel didn't die'' and about what happened and this. was. confirmed. in the comics and what a lot of people don't know is they didn't know anything about the comics and are waiting for a confirmation or starting a theory.

I can't confirm either since I haven't read it but ill give you a good gist on what basically happens - max goes to different realities and chole and Rachel are either a couple and living in arcadia bay where no storm happened OR their somewhere else together.

And yes, this technically does confirm that if Rachel was still alive and max didn't come along, Rachel and chole would be together 100% (sorry max x chole shippers)

Alot of people will ask ''but what if max did come along the same time as Rachel or came back the same time like in the life is strange game?'' it will be the same outcome since Rachel is alive in this reality.

(Heres the link for the discussion - https://steamcommunity.com/app/319630/discussions/0/4206993868016923026/)

[Rachel D.]

Originally posted by homeroom backrow:

if Rachael was a real person. Chloe never would have met her and yes she would completely have remained breathing.

Well this is bascially based on the theory of "what happens if rachel didnt die?" And therefore there was a reality proving of this theory.

[Qiana]

Originally posted by Rachel D.:

Originally posted by homeroom backrow:

if Rachael was a real person. Chloe never would have met her and yes she would completely have remained breathing.

Well this is bascially based on the theory of "what happens if rachel didnt die?" And therefore there was a reality proving of this theory.

...your misunderstanding of what homeroom backrow/Crystalize/junglepissplate response means (actually tells and presents.).

Check out another post for easier understanding:

Originally posted by homeroom backrow:

the brother of the girl that is the controller of the screen
def deserved to die. if fact i replayed it "the scene" a lot of times and confirmed that his surrogate son hated him and did not trust him.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/936790/discussions/0/4289187621817646409/

[Rachel D.]

Originally posted by Qiana:

Originally posted by Rachel D.:

Well this is bascially based on the theory of "what happens if rachel didnt die?" And therefore there was a reality proving of this theory.

...your misunderstanding of what homeroom backrow/Crystalize/junglepissplate response means (actually tells and presents.).

Check out another post for easier understanding:

Originally posted by homeroom backrow:

the brother of the girl that is the controller of the screen
def deserved to die. if fact i replayed it "the scene" a lot of times and confirmed that his surrogate son hated him and did not trust him.

https://steamcommunity.com/app/936790/discussions/0/4289187621817646409/

What is homeroom backrow? I'm so confused.

[Rachel D.]

Originally posted by homeroom backrow:

helllo. yes. thats me.

Ohh okay got it

[Rachel D.]

But yeah I'm just saying it's been confirmed in the comics of what will happen if rachel didnt die, so if people were waiting for a proof of that part that would be the only proof so far.

[skeeter]

If Rachel didn't die who was the smelly body they dug up?

[Rachel D.]

Originally posted by crop-duster:

If Rachel didn't die who was the smelly body they dug up?

That body wouldn't be there if rachel didnt die.

[Astra]

Originally posted by crop-duster:

If Rachel didn't die who was the smelly body they dug up?

Her secret twin sister. While Rachel was in a coma, her twin sister pretended to be her and ended up dead. That's why the Rachel Chloe knew and the one who spent her time with Jefferson and Frank were so different

[Noir Angel]

I think you should actually read the comics first. In the alternate timeline, Max never came back, until 2016, when she changed timelines. Rachel never left. (Also, Rachel is a completely different person, she’s likeable and most likely didn’t do anything with Frank or Jefferson, so that’s probably how she was able to escape to LA with Chloe. She’s not the same Rachel from BTS). But main timeline Chloe? She loves Max.

Also, the comics can’t really confirm anything, because they’re not considered canon to the games, they’re their own thing. It’s basically glorified fanfiction.

[Rachel D.]

Originally posted by Spider-Max:

I think you should actually read the comics first. In the alternate timeline, Max never came back, until 2016, when she changed timelines. Rachel never left. (Also, Rachel is a completely different person, she’s likeable and most likely didn’t do anything with Frank or Jefferson, so that’s probably how she was able to escape to LA with Chloe. She’s not the same Rachel from BTS). But main timeline Chloe? She loves Max.

Also, the comics can’t really confirm anything, because they’re not considered canon to the games, they’re their own thing. It’s basically glorified fanfiction.

Yeah I do need to read the comics but I would need some clarification of source if the developers or anyone from the game confirm the comics is cannon or not but let's be honest it's not. It is just a "what if?" Kind of comic and this just confirms alot of my thoughts.

[Marshall of the Templars]

Originally posted by Rachel D.:

I would need some clarification of source if the developers or anyone from the game confirm the comics is cannon or not

The actual writer of the comics herself stated that:

LiS is such an inspiring game. It's why I was so keen from the get-go to explain that this comic is A story. not THE story.

Source - https://twitter.com/Emmavieceli/status/1060208929622446080

[Rachel D.]

Originally posted by Marshall of the Templars:

Originally posted by Rachel D.:

I would need some clarification of source if the developers or anyone from the game confirm the comics is cannon or not

The actual writer of the comics herself stated that:

LiS is such an inspiring game. It's why I was so keen from the get-go to explain that this comic is A story. not THE story.

Source - https://twitter.com/Emmavieceli/status/1060208929622446080

Thank you for giving the source it helps alot : ))

[MorningLightMountain]

Originally posted by Rachel D.:

Originally posted by Spider-Max:

I think you should actually read the comics first. In the alternate timeline, Max never came back, until 2016, when she changed timelines. Rachel never left. (Also, Rachel is a completely different person, she’s likeable and most likely didn’t do anything with Frank or Jefferson, so that’s probably how she was able to escape to LA with Chloe. She’s not the same Rachel from BTS). But main timeline Chloe? She loves Max.

Also, the comics can’t really confirm anything, because they’re not considered canon to the games, they’re their own thing. It’s basically glorified fanfiction.

Yeah I do need to read the comics but I would need some clarification of source if the developers or anyone from the game confirm the comics is cannon or not but let's be honest it's not. It is just a "what if?" Kind of comic and this just confirms alot of my thoughts.

Going to have to say you don't you need to read them. They are glorified fanfiction with okay art.

[Rachel D.]

Originally posted by MorningLightMountain:

Originally posted by Rachel D.:

Yeah I do need to read the comics but I would need some clarification of source if the developers or anyone from the game confirm the comics is cannon or not but let's be honest it's not. It is just a "what if?" Kind of comic and this just confirms alot of my thoughts.

Going to have to say you don't you need to read them. They are glorified fanfiction with okay art.

I didn't know that but then again the only other comics I see relating to were games are either chole + Max, chole + amber, steph + Alex but never ryan with alex so that makes sense.

[Cat]

Originally posted by jimbo:

If Rachel didn't die who was the smelly body they dug up?

Taylor Swift