What were your choices? (Spoilers)

[wtfcopter]

I saw a fairly similar thread awhile ago. What were your choices on your FIRST playthrough only. We will consider that as your canon choices here.

These were my choices on my first playthrough

Ep. 1
- Told on Nathan
- Made fun of Victoria
- Stepped in between David and Kate
- Came out of the closet and took the blame

Ep. 2
- Told Kate to wait for proof
- Took Kate’s call
- Tried to shoot Frank
- Saved Kate
- Blamed Nathan, and he got suspended

Ep. 3
- Lisa died
- Took the money
- Kissed Chloe
- Sided with Chloe
- Threw bone in parking lot for Pompidou (who would throw it in the street!!?)

Ep. 4
- Accepted Chloe´s wish
- Let Warren beat up Nathan
- Frank gave me his list and nobody got hurt…. after I did a rewind. Chloe killed Pompidou and Frank the first time.
- Warned Victoria, but she didn’t believe me.

Ep. 5
- Hid the truth from David
- Told the truth to Frank about Rachel’s death
- Convinced Joyce to take David back
- Hugged Warren
- Sacrificed Arcadia Bay – ♥♥♥♥ that town

[Luna Starshine]

My CANON-Playthrough

- Told on Nathan
- Comfort Victoria
- Stepped in between David and Kate
- Came out of the closet and took the blame

- Tell Kate to wait for proof
- BELGIAN WAFFELS!!
- Take the call of Kate
- Trying to shoot Frank
- SAVE KATE!!!!
- Blame Nathan

- Take the money from the office
- Kiss Chloe
- Side with Chloe
- Keep Pompidou alive

- Grand Chloe´s last wish
- Let Warren beat up Nathan
- Be on good terms with Frank
- Warn Victoria

- Don´t tell David the truth
- Hug Warren
- Sacrifice Arcadia Bay

[Sarcen]

This isn't my perfect playthough, but this was my first, and usually consider the first one canon because it's not influenced by things I know.

Ep. 1
- Didn't tell on Nathan
- Comfort Victoria
- Stepped in between David and Kate
- Failed at hiding, took the blame.

Ep. 2
- Told Kate to wait for proof
- Took Kate’s call
- Didn't try to shoot Frank
- Didn't tell jefferson anything (Didn't trust him from the start :P)
- Kate died.
- Blamed Nathan (believe Max and Nathan both got suspended)

Ep. 3
- Lisa lived
- Left the money
- Kissed Chloe
- Sided with Chloe
- Threw bone in parking lot for Pompidou

Ep. 4
- Accepted Chloe´s wish
- Stopped Warren from beating up Nathan
- Frank gave me his list and nobody got hurt
- Warned Victoria, and she believed me

Ep. 5
- Hid the truth from David
- Told the truth to Frank about Rachel’s death
- Convinced Joyce to take David back
- Hugged Warren
- Sacrificed Arcadia Bay

[Spiritus]

My first(and probably last) playthrough:

Ep. 1
- Told on Nathan
- Comfort Victoria
- Stepped in between David and Kate (after rewind, first i took photo, but that was not "right")
- Came out of the closet and took the blame

Ep. 2
- Told Kate to Go to the Police
- Took Kate’s call
- Tried to shoot Frank
- Saved Kate
- Blamed Nathan, and he got suspended

Ep. 3
- Lisa survived :-)
- Left the money
- Kissed Chloe
- Sided with Chloe
- Threw bone in parking lot for Pompidou

Ep. 4
- Accepted Chloe´s wish
- Let Warren beat up Nathan
- Frank gave me his list and nobody got hurt… (after rewind, of course)
- Warned Victoria and she believed me.

Ep. 5
- Hid the truth from David (after rewind, for first time i just wanted to see Jefferson dead)
- Told the truth to Frank about Rachel’s death
- Convinced Joyce to take David back (i am shocked that majority of people are against David and Joyce together)
- kissed Warren (it was end of the world for god sake, "kiss of friendship")
- Sacrificed Arcadia Bay – without hesitation - BAE over BAY: GUILT but NO REGRETS

[Kelli]

I watched someone play before playing myself, but forgot a lot before playing myself or just outright didn't know what effect the choices had. Made waaay different choices than the person I watched, anyway.

Ep. 1
- Told on Nathan
- Comforted Victoria
- Stepped in between David and Kate
- Couldn't figure out how to move the lamp and stayed unhidden, took the blame for Chloe

Ep. 2
- Told Kate to go to police
- Took Kate’s call
- Tried to shoot Frank
- Saved Kate
- Blamed Nathan and he got suspended

Ep. 3
- Lisa lived!
- Took the money
- Kissed Chloe
- Sided with Chloe
- Threw bone in parking lot for Pompidou

Ep. 4
- Accepted Chloe's wish
- Let Warren beat up Nathan
- Frank gave me his list and nobody got hurt, but not before Chloe killed his dog and him a couple times
- Warned Victoria and she believed me

Ep. 5
- Told David the truth (my fiance wanted to see David shoot Jefferson)
- Told the truth to Frank about Rachel’s death
- Didn't even talk to Joyce, oops
- Hugged Warren
- Sacrificed Arcadia Bay, saved Chloe

[76561198268928911]

Here we go:

Ep. 1
- Told on Nathan
- Made fun of Victoria ( then rewind and made fun again lol )
- Intervened to help out Kate
- Came out of the closet and took the blame

Ep. 2
- Told Kate to wait for proof
- Didn't answer Kate's call (Wrong, I know, but Chloe comes first. I saved Kate anyway)
- Tried to shoot Frank
- Saved Kate
- Blamed Nathan

Ep. 3
- Lisa lived
- Took the money
- Kissed Chloe (then rewind and kissed her again, and again, and again...)
- Sided with Chloe
- Kept Frank's dog from harm (really?)

Ep. 4
- Accepted Chloe´s wish (hardest choice in the game) and then sat on a corner and started crying
- Let Warren beat up Nathan (kinda regretted it later)
- No one got hurt
- Warned Victoria, but she didn’t believe me.

Ep. 5
- Told the truth to David (he deserved it)
- Told the truth about Rachel to Frank
- Helped Joyce believe in David again.
- Hugged Warren
- SACRIFICED ARCADIA BAY!! -- Easiest choice in the game, I didn't hesitate even for a second, no regrets.

[Eanne]

Ep. 1
- Told on Nathan
- Comfort Victoria
- Intervened to help out Kate
- Came out of the closet and took the blame

Ep. 2
- Told Kate to wait for proof
- Answer Kate's call.
- Tried to shoot Frank
- Saved Kate
- Blamed Nathan

Ep. 3
- Lisa lived
- Took the money
- Kissed Chloe (then rewind and kissed her again, and again, and again...)
- Sided with Chloe
- Threw bone in parking lot for Pompidou of course.

Ep. 4
- Refused Chloe´s wish (hardest choice in the game).
- Let Warren beat up Nathan (never regretted it)
- No one got hurt
- Warned Victoria, she believe me ( regreted it later...)

Ep. 5
- Told the truth to David.
- Told the truth about Rachel to Frank
- Helped Joyce believe in David again.
- Warren who?
- SACRIFICED ARCADIA BAY!! -- Easiest choice in the game, I didn't hesitate even for a second, no regrets.

[wtfcopter]

Originally posted by Spiritus:

- Convinced Joyce to take David back (i am shocked that majority of people are against David and Joyce together)

I think most of those people likely just missed talking to Joyce. If you don't talk to her, then it counts against it.

[76561198268928911]

Originally posted by wtfcopter:

Originally posted by Spiritus:

- Convinced Joyce to take David back (i am shocked that majority of people are against David and Joyce together)

I think most of those people likely just missed talking to Joyce. If you don't talk to her, then it counts against it.

And, correct me if I'm wrong, but if you side David instead of Chloe in the ep3 confrontation (I did it in my second or third playthrough) you can't convince Joyce because they are already together, but I may be wrong.

[wtfcopter]

Originally posted by Bae over Bay:

Originally posted by wtfcopter:

I think most of those people likely just missed talking to Joyce. If you don't talk to her, then it counts against it.

And, correct me if I'm wrong, but if you side David instead of Chloe in the ep3 confrontation (I did it in my second or third playthrough) you can't convince Joyce because they are already together, but I may be wrong.

This I don't know, because I have always sided with Chloe :)

[OrangeCrush]

Episode 1
- Told on Nathan
- Made fun of Victoria
- Defended Kate
- Stayed in hiding

Episode 2
- Told Kate to go to the police
- Answered Kate's call
- Tried to shoot Frank
- Saved Kate
- Blamed Nathan

Episode 3
- Stopped Chloe from stealing the money
- Kissed Chloe
- Sided with Chloe
- Threw the bone in the parking lot

Episode 4
- Refused Chloe's request
- Let Warren beat up Nathan
- Chloe stabbed Frank
- Didn't warn Victoria

Episode 5
- Told David the truth
- Kissed Warren
- Sacrificed Arcadia Bay

[darquan0]

From my first playthough. I would change some of them, but they are most "blind" I made.

Ep.1
Reported Nathan
Comforted Vic
Supported Kate
Came out of hiding

daniel drew portrait
signed petition (did not in "true" playthrough)
erased insults
watered plant
took Dana's test but rewound
rearranged Vic's photos
let the bird die (didn't know about the bird!)
broke snowglobe but rewound
hid evidence of shuffling David's files
read David's files

Ep.2
Told Kate to go to police (told her to wait for proof in "true" playthrough)
Answered call
Pulled the trigger on Frank
Saved Kate (seriously, people, just a little curiosity and comfort her, and she can't die!)
Blamed Nathan

watered Lisa (paid more attention in "true")
warned Alyssa
erased link to video
been "friendly" to Tailor
accepted Warren's invitation (I regretted that later)
wrote message in junkyard
saved Chloe without tampering the rail switch (would change that and save Chloe with NO REWIND)
gained entry to Vortex Club from Courtney
helped Warren
told Jefferson about David (now how can I undo that, actually?)


Ep.3
Didn't take money (took them in "true" playthrough"
Kissed Chloe (!YAY!)
Sided with David (I knew he wasn't a truly bad man from middle of ep.1)
Didn't hurt Pompidou (rewound!)
Chloe has a gun (she never lost it)

Lisa is drowned :( (saved her in "true")
altered Warren's exam
already was on the list
removed some other names from list
had eggs'n'bakey
didn't erase message
warned Alyssa
told homeless about storm
took photo of Chloe&William
did not left butterfly memento (didn't see that point)

Ep.4
Overdosed alt!Chloe
Let Warren beat up Nathan
Saved Frank from being shot, stabbed, etc (took some rewinds)
Warned Victoria and she beilieved

let the brid die (didn't see that bird)
did not disturb nest
found the code
Kate helped with Nathan's room
motivated Daniel to go to the End of the World party
left a message on Warren's board
found Nathans PIN (NOW THAT WAS HARD!!!)
warned Alyssa

Ep.5
Bae > Bay

David got scar (will change that)
David killed Jefferson
saved the Trucker
saved Evan
didn't save Alyssa (didn't know she was there!)
didn't save the fisherman (got too far to rewind, and the timeline will be changed anyway)
didn't change Joyce's mind about David (no need)
didn't tell Frank about Rachel (didn't talk to him at all!)
hugged Warren

so, that's it.

[OrangeCrush]

Originally posted by Spiritus:

- Convinced Joyce to take David back (i am shocked that majority of people are against David and Joyce together)

If you sided with David, you're stuck with "didn't change Joyce's opinion about David" since she wasn't pissed with him.

[DarkRavenQueen]

It's hard to recall it all because I deleted it (damn those only three saves!), but that's what I remember:

Ep. 1

- Didn't tell on Nathan
- Made fun of Victoria
- Stepped in between David and Kate
- Came out of closet and took the blame

Ep. 2

- Told Kate to wait for proof
- Took Kate’s call
- Tried to shoot Frank
- Didn't tell Jefferson on David (I think I didn't trust him there, but in the pause to Episode 3 I forgot it again ._.)
- Saved Kate
- Blamed Nathan, Max got suspended (I'm such a brainiac :D)

Ep. 3

- Lisa died
- Left the money
- Kissed Chloe
- Sided with Chloe
- Threw bone in parking lot for Pompidou

Ep. 4

- Accepted Chloe´s wish
- Stopped Warren from beating up Nathan
- Frank gave me his list and nobody got hurt
- Warned Victoria, and she didn't believe me (Oh well, was not that bad after all :3)

Ep. 5

- Told David the truth
- Told the truth to Frank about Rachel’s death
- Convinced Joyce to take David back
- Kissed Warren
- Sacrificed Chloe

[Tredegar]

Ep. 1
- Didn't Tell on Nathan
- Comforted Victoria
- Stepped in between David and Kate
- Hid in the Closest

Ep. 2
- Told Kate to wait for proof
- Took Kate’s call
- Tried to shoot Frank
- Failed to Save Kate
- Blamed David

Ep. 3
- Lisa Lived
- Took the money
- Kissed Chloe
- Sided with Chloe
- Threw bone in parking lot for Pompidou

Ep. 4
- Accepted Chloe´s wish
- Let Warren beat up Nathan
- Frank gave me his list and nobody got hurt
- Warned Victoria and she believed me.

Ep. 5
- Told David the truth about Chloe
- Told the truth to Frank about Rachel’s death
- Convinced Joyce to take David back
- KIssed Warren
- Sacrificed Arcadia Bay – Chloe Forever!

[Entity Wears Jorts]

This was my first playthrough, which I did entirely blind.

Major Choices

Ep. 1
- Reported Nathan
- Comforted Victoria
- Intervened to help Kate
- Came out of hiding to intervene

Ep. 2
- Told Kate to wait for more proof
- Answered Kate's call
- Didn't try to shoot Frank
- Saved Kate
- Blamed Nathan

Ep. 3
- Left the money
- Kissed Chloe
- Sided with Chloe
- Kept Frank's dog from harm
- Gave Chole David's gun

Ep. 4
- Refused Chloe's request
- Stopped Warren from beating up Nathan
- No one got hurt
- Victoria believed the warning

Ep. 5
- Sacrificed Chloe

Minor Choices (I didn't even see most of minor choices the first time through.)

Ep. 1
- Didn't let Daniel draw
- Didn't sign
- Didn't help Alyssa
- Erased the insults
- Watered the plant
- Didn't touch pregnancy test
- Didn't touch Victoria's photos
- Didn't write on the RV
- Let the bird die
- Didn't break Chloe's snow globe
- Didn't leave evidence
- Didn't read David's files

Ep. 2
- Watered the plant
- Didn't help Alyssa
- Erased the link
- Wasn't friendly with Taylor
- Rejected Warren's invitation
- Didn't write a message
- Tampered with the tracks
- Didn't gain Vortex Club entry
- Didn't help Warren
- Told on David to Jefferson

Ep. 3
- Lisa is dead
- Didn't "help" Warren
- Not on the Vortex Club entry list
- Erased named from the entry list
- Didn't erase the cop's message
- Didn't help Alyssa
- Didn't warn the homeless woman
- Didn't take a photo in the past
- Didn't leave a mark on the fireplace

Ep. 4
- Let the Blue Jay die
- Didn't disturb the bird's nest
- Found David's code
- Kate helped find Nathan's room
- Got Daniel to go to the Vortex Club party
- Didn't write a message for Warren
- Figured out Nathan's pin code
- Helped Alyssa

Ep. 5
- David got a scar
- David didn't kill Jefferson
- Didn't save the trucker
- Didn't save Ethan
- Didn't save Alyssa
- Didn't save the fisherman
- Didn't change Joyce's mind about David
- Didn't tell the truth about Rachel to frank
- Hugged Warren