*SPOILERS!!!!!!!* last choice too easy?

[DireSpade111]

I honestly don't see why all these you tubers have so much trouble with that last choice?! I played and thought it was completely obvious to sacrifice Chloe! You kill all the people in the town for one person just because they are your best friend and you STILL have many characters that are friends! That's dumb. I mean Is it not obvious? Easiest choice in the game by far.

[Day Walker]

https://youtu.be/VoinS21NcPY

[Radene]

Definitely too easy. After all, there's only one way for Max to not drag on the madness she's gotten herself into.

Arcadia Bay? That place is not relevant at all. It's "my sanity" vs "Chloe" in the end.

[Bardewi]

Save people I just met a month ago, or my best friend (love) of a lifetime? Mmmm hard .... Bye Arcadia :D

[Zammy]

Actually the easiest choise was to eat bacon whenever possible.

[House of Rahl]

that last choice was pretty nuts. both options sucked but i mean.... why not just go back and try again, and again till it works or she nukes the planet.

when youve already morgaged the house and bet the farm, all you can do is double down till you get the pair you need.

even if the super tornado blows through you could always just try various ways to get the town to evacuate. several of those timelines she had some pretty good cred with the town folk, including the police. i took a long look at that screen and was like.... wheres option 3?!?

[Day Walker]

Originally posted by Ju:

Save people I just met a month ago, or my best friend (love) of a lifetime? Mmmm hard .... Bye Arcadia :D

Good to see you back ju :)

[Ogami]

Yup, was a very easy choice. Goodbye Arcadia Bay.

[Undead Rufus]

Easy or not, for better or worse, the last choice was necessary per the story arc.

That said, I kind of agree with @Jesus Freak - Blade. Max was aware of the tornado for most of the game, and she had the option of cultivating relationships in a variety of ways. Some kind of warning, maybe based on an "influence check" with certain characters, might have made sense. But — in strict narrative terms — the binary finality of the ending would have been lost. I'm not sure which I would prefer, but I found myself satisified with the ending as written.

[Brewski]

Funny, really, since it's been almost 50/50 in the stats since day 1.

Also funny that it's usually everyone aruging that it's easy to always pick Bae over Bay instead.

Trolls gotta troll. :)

[Radene]

Originally posted by bringstrom:

Funny, really, since it's been almost 50/50 in the stats since day 1.

Also funny that it's usually everyone aruging that it's easy to always pick Bae over Bay instead.

Trolls gotta troll. :)

I don't think that's "trolls" as much as people who just like to ship the two.

[talemore]

You have to physically make an action to sacrifice chloe and save Bay. It's easy to judge the end choice by saying that saving the many is the right choice. The vortex suddenly disappear because you didn't saved chloe. In the end it was all just a dream because anyone who seen a tornado or a hurricane or a twister knows that you can't walk up to it and ask it to leave in the way the game make it perfect sense that once in a while a girl must be sacrificed to plead the Tobanga.

[Silviechan]

It all depends on your chooises since it depends how chloe will threat and act towards you and the more you like her the easier it become to pick her over the town
and the less you like her the easier it become to pick the town over her
it is one of the easiest chooises in the game since your opinion of how important chloe is at that point is already rock solid and as such it is kinda braindead chooise regardless of what you pick since your opinion is already stuck but that doesnt matter that your chooise is same as all others chooise but most find it quite easy

[|Y^2| Nording]

If you choose sacrifice Arcadia Bay - that doesn't means everyone in Arcadia Bay die. If you play again dinner (where you need to get a photo from Warren) from Episode 5 - you will see same destructions as in the end movie after tornado. You can see alive people who is escaping from the town. Only few minor differences, for example building where was Alice even damaged less, so what means Alice is alive. David and Mr. Jefferson are definatelly alive, because they were in a basement when strom hit the town. Two whales looks more damaged in the end looks like every one is dead inside, but things could be different and they could escape. I want to say that when you watching the end movie after sacrifice Arcadia Bay you can see only 5 dead bodies. I bet most population is alive. For example the school is far from coast line and it could be not damaged by storm at all.

update:some one think same as me, because found a nice fan made video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZ56iz4EIhk

[JustinSkiz(ЏастинСкиз)]

You know what is so farking stupid?, Warren was in the diner when Warren gave Max the photo to travel back in time. So when Max travelled back in time, she could of told Warren about the tornado and not to go to the diner after he took the photo of him and Max so both Chloe and Max could of survived. Joice and David, i hope they both survived too but i doubt Joice did since she was in the diner with Warren when the storm hit. But David could of survived because he was in the bunker (The Dark Room) with Mr Jefferson.

I am kind of disappointed in the ending a bit because they could of made more then 2 endings and could of made it with a lot of different endings and scenarios depending on what choices you choose in the game but i think they kind of rushed the last episode of this game and the ending too.

But i still give it a 10/10 game rating because it was an awesome farking game, makes you really connect with the characters depending on what choices you make and what happens in the game.

[|Y^2| Nording]

Since Max didn't lost her gift, any of those ending could be rewinded later. Max could rewind to any photo, doesn't matter who made it. So if Cloe is dead, Max can miss her and decide to save her and rewind to that moment in toilet (she still has that photo) and she can also rewind and save people in Arcadia Bay. I see an episode 6 here where Max is sorting out that all. Groundhog Day until everything will be solved best.