So... which animatronic actually killed the Phone Guy? :: Five Nights at Freddy's General Discussions

Store Page

Five Nights at Freddy's

All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews

Five Nights at Freddy's > General Discussions > Topic Details

Moles Holes has Five Nights at Freddy's

Nov 4, 2014 @ 6:43pm

So... which animatronic actually killed the Phone Guy?

Right... before I say anything, I'm not going to based how he died with theory - I will be basing how he died with the game mechanics and the animatronic's noises in the call.

To start of with, we hear foxy constantly banging on the door as he is speaking... implying that the left door is constantly closed, so this eliminates Bonnie AND Foxy from killing him.

Now, the second thing we hear in the call is Freddy's laughter; then followed by his jingle. From this we can assume that he moved from either the Show Stage, Dining Area, Restrooms, East Hall and the East Hall Corner to the Kitchen, as this is the only other time you can hear Freddy's jingle (if the power has not ran out.) This means that Freddy is also eliminated.

Now... this is the confusing bit - we know that Bonnie, Foxy and Freddy could not have killed the phone guy... which means that it had to either be Chica or Golden Freddy right? However, there is one problem with this.

In the call, you hear the moans that Bonnie/Chica make; but you can only hear this if you are viewing the camera. Now, this means that Chica is inside the room... so Chica killed him right?... Well, if that's the case when WHY did we hear Golden Freddy's death scream? Golden Freddy appears if you lower the camera whilst seeing the Golden Freddy poster.. resulting him to be lifeless on the floor, and eventually killing you (if you stare at him)

However... if Chica was already inside, if he lowered the camera, Chica would have killed him - preventing Golden Freddy killing him; so again WHY did we hear Golden Freddy's scream?.. and how did he die!?

-THEORIES-

1 )

Since we know that it couldn't have been any of the 5 animatronics if we compared the call to what in actual gameplay... The only other explaination is the Phone Guy himself may have died due to insanity and extreme paranoia... it may have caused him to imagine all these sounds and may have had a heart attack due to pressure.

HOWEVER, there is one fatal flaw with this theory - YOU, YOURSELF can hear the sounds in the recording... therefore this theory isn't likely

2) Now, this one may be the only one to actually make sense to fix all the plot holes... the phone guy faked death himself. Think about it, it was night 1 and 2 when he told you about the mechanics of the animatronics and what they do... so, if he had this much knowledge about them, he may have been able to manipulate the animatronics to fool us thinking he died... seeing as he knew all the patterns of them.

But nonetheless... no matter how many times you think/listen about it... it seems like it is impossible to tell what killed him.... if he died that is.

< >

Showing 1-15 of 15 comments

Sandshark

Nov 4, 2014 @ 9:07pm

>Has doors closed because all the animatronics are outside trying to get in
>power goes out
>Freddy laughs
>jingle plays
>death
(was that really that hard)

Lavenders_pink has Five Nights at Freddy's

Nov 5, 2014 @ 4:24am

wow, all that typing for nothing. why does it even matter so much!?!?!?!? HE DIED, who cares who killed him.

That guy with the Spoon has Five Nights at Freddy's

Nov 5, 2014 @ 5:53am

more important is that hes back in fnaf2

sombrez2 Nov 5, 2014 @ 7:07am

Originally posted by Ginosaji:
more important is that hes back in fnaf2 :spazhorror:

hes not back in fnaf2 what are you talking about

Justin

Nov 5, 2014 @ 7:29am

Originally posted by Cpt. Fudgecakes #Arena Respawn:
Originally posted by Ginosaji:
more important is that hes back in fnaf2 :spazhorror:
hes not back in fnaf2 what are you talking about

His voice can be heard.
This means one of the three things.
He barely survived his encounter, and something drew him back to working for the new pizzaria. (Either the managers have something on him, like they're covering up for something bad he did. Or he simply still loves that place despite it's dark past, and the fact it tries to kill him).

He is back as a phantom, which I honestly do think is possible.

Or his voice only made an appearance for commercial reasons, and he isn't actually in the new game.

sombrez2 Nov 5, 2014 @ 7:57am

Originally posted by Crying Wolf:
Originally posted by Cpt. Fudgecakes #Arena Respawn:
hes not back in fnaf2 what are you talking about

His voice can be heard.
This means one of the three things.
He barely survived his encounter, and something drew him back to working for the new pizzaria. (Either the managers have something on him, like they're covering up for something bad he did. Or he simply still loves that place despite it's dark past, and the fact it tries to kill him).

He is back as a phantom, which I honestly do think is possible.

Or his voice only made an appearance for commercial reasons, and he isn't actually in the new game.

Or maybe that's mike schmidt from the first game.
theres only one developer for these games and thats scott cawthon so he has to do the voice acting himself too.

Last edited by sombrez2; Nov 5, 2014 @ 7:58am

Moles Holes has Five Nights at Freddy's

Nov 5, 2014 @ 1:07pm

Originally posted by Silvercity:
>Has doors closed because all the animatronics are outside trying to get in
>power goes out
>Freddy laughs
>jingle plays
>death
(was that really that hard)

Not necessarily, If you listen until the very end of the call, you hear foxy banging before Golden Freddy's scream..., the right door was closed; so the power didn't run out.

Originally posted by Slipknot:
wow, all that typing for nothing. why does it even matter so much!?!?!?!? HE DIED, who cares who killed him.

That's what discussion are for... he may or may not have died :P

That guy with the Spoon has Five Nights at Freddy's

Nov 5, 2014 @ 1:11pm

he didn't because hes in the fnaf2 trailer.

NomsOnWorlds has Five Nights at Freddy's

Oct 17, 2015 @ 9:05am

Or he's the purple guy, was attacked by golden freddy, used the crank to disable the springtrap suit, and then permanently broke him.
And then didn't show up for work the night after because he was too buy plotting to dismantle the other four. =D

That guy with the Spoon has Five Nights at Freddy's

Oct 17, 2015 @ 9:33am

way to dig up graves on the steamforums...

#10

SilverJ17

Oct 17, 2015 @ 9:46am

Why bump a thread that's been dead for almost a year? A freaking year.

#11

Connor158910 Mar 21, 2020 @ 12:38am

Originally posted by SilverJ17:
Why bump a thread that's been dead for almost a year? A freaking year.

Bump. lol.

#12

NomsOnWorlds has Five Nights at Freddy's

Mar 21, 2020 @ 12:40pm

Originally posted by Connor158910:
Originally posted by SilverJ17:
Why bump a thread that's been dead for almost a year? A freaking year.

Bump. lol.

#13

Rainbow Spy has Five Nights at Freddy's

Mar 23, 2020 @ 7:26pm

Originally posted by Sandshark:
>Has doors closed because all the animatronics are outside trying to get in
>power goes out
>Freddy laughs
>jingle plays
>death
(was that really that hard)

this

Last edited by Rainbow Spy; Mar 23, 2020 @ 7:26pm

#14