"Crew" ability is Unbalanced

[taba]

I think Crew ability is unbalanced, please make depend from mana points.

Regards

[rops]

Surprisingly I like them, the let creature decks a chance against planes walker / board wipe decks.

[CleanWater]

Artifact destroyers, kill all the crew, spell biding... So many ways to deal against it. I don't think it's really that unballanced.

[oootttoooo]

dont worry, i'll fix it soon.

[Tri Rang]

CleanWater の投稿を引用：

Artifact destroyers, kill all the crew, spell biding... So many ways to deal against it. I don't think it's really that unballanced.

artifact destruction works in versus battles but not against AI.
I have tried to build a deck with artifact destroyers but then AI had a deck where "big" artifacts were rarely cast, instead of this you had dwarfs popping servo tokens and rocs. Only aggro deck (red white) can beat them quickly because the crew is forced to block or the vehicle don't take risk to attack. But in AI battles i d' like to play different decks, not only red white aggro so AI should not only play artifact deck.

[Fiddle Gastro]

KULECZKA の投稿を引用：

CleanWater の投稿を引用：

Artifact destroyers, kill all the crew, spell biding... So many ways to deal against it. I don't think it's really that unballanced.

artifact destruction works in versus battles but not against AI.
I have tried to build a deck with artifact destroyers but then AI had a deck where "big" artifacts were rarely cast, instead of this you had dwarfs popping servo tokens and rocs. Only aggro deck (red white) can beat them quickly because the crew is forced to block or the vehicle don't take risk to attack. But in AI battles i d' like to play different decks, not only red white aggro so AI should not only play artifact deck.

The AI should be playing decks that were used throughout the history of the game so we get some ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ variety.

[Marginal0]

The AI needs to improve to handle crew. It was kind enough to activate all its crew cards in response to my mass removal spell, but it shouldn't have to do that.

[srsface]

I find the best artifact hate decks are that on the side, and are mainly landramp. Everything that isn't artifact hate is something that gets you more land, or is a big giant mean thing. Lifegain is extremely useful for this, too.

[ernest p. worrell]

srsface の投稿を引用：

It's almost like they made a mechanic that's really strong but can still be easily defeated.

Vehicles can be pretty good. Crewing them can be pretty good. It doesn't mean it doesn't have weaknesses. Run some artifact hate and you'll laugh at anyone who brings vehicles.

I don't think vehicle/crew is even powerful, I am very skeptical of it in fact, I doubt it will be a very relevant mechanic in standard or even here on Duels. Could be wrong about that but still.

Anyways, jjust running hate in your decks is not really viable in any format, much less this one where it's a one-off game with no sideboard. I wish they'd make these into best of 3 matches. Of course everyone is ADHD nowadays, and I guess you can't split the queues into a more competitive oriented one and a simple one-off one, with the size of this player base, but it would really be nice.

[Isilith]

Why do casuals or people that don't play mtgo or mtg in real life feel the need to voice their opinion on mechanics? Crew is pretty weak in my opinion; sure it is situational haste but you are tapping creatures. Now something like infect was an overpowered mechanic.

On a side note; first time playing duels(started to try new kaladesh cards) and its alright, but MTGO is much better besides the 2hg, which I wish they would add to mtgo.

[Marci]

IsilithTehroth の投稿を引用：

Why do casuals or people that don't play mtgo or mtg in real life feel the need to voice their opinion on mechanics?

It seems to me that many of those comments are made by people who are not even aware of how small portion of this game is of the MTG world.

Crew is pretty weak in my opinion

With the cards in Duels, sure. But it's a fun "Johnny" mechanic, especially outside Duels (just think of all the creatures with the untap cost).

[Wavekid]

After planeswalkers here comes the veichle cry, you guys obviously don't know what are the real broken stuff

[☾༻𝕳𝖊𝖒𝖓༺☽]

Car can drive bike ... New rules of world.!.

[Tie]

thatmtgguy の投稿を引用：

After planeswalkers here comes the veichle cry, you guys obviously don't know what are the real broken stuff

exactly! they should be happy there arn't any cards that had to be banned in standard in this game. Those where the real OP/Broken cards.

[Wavekid]

Tie - Tymessen の投稿を引用：

thatmtgguy の投稿を引用：

After planeswalkers here comes the veichle cry, you guys obviously don't know what are the real broken stuff

exactly! they should be happy there arn't any cards that had to be banned in standard in this game. Those where the real OP/Broken cards.

What do you mean? There wasnt a banned card in standard in a very long time