Magic Duels

Magic Duels

View Stats:
Bedge Jul 3, 2017 @ 3:01am
The game is dead now
Wizards told us that Magic Duels would be THE game to play on PC for MTG and they would keep adding expansions to it and new game modes etc.

However, they lied and would prefer to keep re releasing new games with the same old broken net code. I wonder what the next digital product will be like? Will they pay attention to the community and fix issues that have existed since Duels of the Planeswalkers 2012? Of course not. I'm sad to say I have spent real money on these games because a measly 30 coins a game with daily limit is slave labor. Goodbye Wizards, you royally f'ed up.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 41 comments
Lynad Jul 3, 2017 @ 10:44am 
you are right!
Junipercat Jul 3, 2017 @ 2:04pm 
Magic Duels was inteneded to be the ongoing platform. New card sets were released, additional cosmetic content, and they did implement 2HG. For whatever reason it didn't live up to the dream.

Since this was the attempt at an ongoing version, jumping from the yearly releases (including the mess that Magic 2015 was), I hope that it was a big learning point from them. I am very curious about Magic Digital Next and hope (cautiously so) that it is an improvement and expansion on the prior games, and not a simple cut and paste.

Free to play games money spent is always a risk. And by the nature of the model, if they made it too comfortable to earn content free then no money is to be made. It is a tricky balance.

In any case, I say check the annoucement in Septemeber and see if Magic Digital Next does step up where it needs to or not.

P.S. Yes I want them to fix the bug in the old ones saving 2 less decks then you have total in the game. I still play them now and then because I love the theme decks.
Novancere Jul 3, 2017 @ 2:45pm 
Fun tip: Get Magic: The Gathering ONLINE
They'll never ship that ♥♥♥♥.
Junipercat Jul 3, 2017 @ 4:02pm 
Originally posted by Novancere:
Fun tip: Get Magic: The Gathering ONLINE
They'll never ship that ♥♥♥♥.

MTGO is fun, but a bit painful to look at with the very old grainy graphics. Since Magic Digital Next is soundling like an umbrella sitaution for all digital products, it might include an update to MTGO as well.

In about 3 months we will have official info. It better be very informative and not simply a "teaser".
Last edited by Junipercat; Jul 3, 2017 @ 4:03pm
GeneralVeers Jul 3, 2017 @ 6:23pm 
Originally posted by Junipercat:
Magic Duels was inteneded to be the ongoing platform. New card sets were released, additional cosmetic content, and they did implement 2HG. For whatever reason it didn't live up to the dream.
One of two reasons.

#1, and most likely: budget issues. The game wasn't making money.

#2: From all the complaints in this forum, it's obvious there were some ongoing technical issues that kept not getting fixed. It's possible WoTC got fed up with Stainless and fired them.
Like Black Screen Bug never solved, Yeah
e vil Jul 4, 2017 @ 9:14am 
Originally posted by GeneralVeers:
One of two reasons.

#1, and most likely: budget issues. The game wasn't making money.

At the same time, I believe some people were buying more paper cards than before. That was my case, as well as Mojo´s. And may be other´s as well.
So maybe they should not just see how much money they were getting directly with Magic Duels, but the real profit the company was getting during the game´s life span.
Last edited by e vil; Jul 4, 2017 @ 9:17am
Torgan Jul 4, 2017 @ 9:26am 
Originally posted by GeneralVeers:
Originally posted by Junipercat:
Magic Duels was inteneded to be the ongoing platform. New card sets were released, additional cosmetic content, and they did implement 2HG. For whatever reason it didn't live up to the dream.
One of two reasons.

#1, and most likely: budget issues. The game wasn't making money.

#2: From all the complaints in this forum, it's obvious there were some ongoing technical issues that kept not getting fixed. It's possible WoTC got fed up with Stainless and fired them.

Here is leaked revenue for ccg in 2016:
https://mmos.com/news/digital-ccg-hearthstone-earns-395m-2016-shadowverse-100m

Magic duels was not so bad, especially compared with MTGO. MTGO support cost much more so I would not be surprised if profit is bigger in duels than in MTGO, not to mention that cards are redeemable in MTGO so if people decide to reedem cards, they can even go into negative profit.

After I saw this report, I'm more convined that Duels is not canceled because low profit(because if that is the case, MTGO should be canceled long time ago). I think we can espect another f2p digital game in September, but this time they will do it properly. Duels is very limited and full of bugs since beginning. But with little push, it can easily leave MTGO in dust. MTGO players should be worried, because if some digital platform does not earn enough money, compared to invested money, that is MTGO...
Last edited by Torgan; Jul 4, 2017 @ 9:27am
Abisha Jul 4, 2017 @ 9:28am 
O yea this is the final nail in coffin i would likely never ever buy their product again.
and i was loyal custumer to MTG for a Long long time even have the old microprose magic the gathering with Alpha card set. never again never.
I kinda wish they'd have finished up the guildpact's saga (nicol bolas kerboomes them all in hour of devestation). I'm sure they're not making money on duels which may or may not have something to do with the fact that each set costs like $100 to buy outright. I mean $20 pre-order for a set and say early access for it (say a month or something) and people would jump on it. But... $100? That's... kinda steep considering you can build 2 or 3 competative pauper decks in MTGO for that.
Did they say they wont support magic duels anymore or whats up?
Captain_Narol Jul 6, 2017 @ 2:14pm 
They announced there will be no other expansions added to Magic Duels as from now on they will focus on their future still announced products :

"These are all exciting beginnings, but with new beginning comes one ending. In order to make room for the next generation of Magic digital products, Amonkhet will be the last new content update for Magic Duels. Hour of Devastation will not be released on the platform.

Magic Duels is still downloadable and playable, but our digital teams are focused on the next generation of Magic digital gaming. We're proud of what Duels accomplished, and we'll be using what we learned from that game to make even better Magic experiences in the future."

Official source :

http://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/magic-digital/magic-digital-next-update-2017-06-13

In other words, they are letting us down... (by us I mean Magic Duelists)
Last edited by Captain_Narol; Jul 6, 2017 @ 2:15pm
GeneralVeers Jul 6, 2017 @ 2:51pm 
They didn't let you down.

They gave you a FREE video game, and you had no right to expect pay-to-play quality from a FREE game. And if you were dumb enough to pay real money for virtual online goods, that's nobody else's fault.
PiddleFish Jul 6, 2017 @ 3:59pm 
lol. anyone defending the way this was handled should jump off a bridge
GeneralVeers Jul 6, 2017 @ 4:07pm 
This game was handled great. I got FREE MAGIC THE GATHERING. For two years.

Booyah.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 41 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Jul 3, 2017 @ 3:01am
Posts: 41