Bloons TD5
Tack shooter literally the worst tower in the game?
This is more or less a poll.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 31 comments
Zethex Apr 18, 2018 @ 4:28am 
Probably. It does have blade maelstorm but tbh i dont think i have ever have used it unless im spamming random towers and abilities.
Gakm4 Apr 18, 2018 @ 5:26am 
I don't know that i could call it the worst tower in the game but it is definitely in the bottom tier of towers.
gakm7 Apr 18, 2018 @ 7:04am 
I would say Tack Shooter might be the 2nd worst tower, just slightly better than the mortar tower.


If I had to do a "tier" system for the OVERALL usefulness/efficientness of towers, excluding the village and farm "utility" towers, and without really thinking about it all that much, I'd probably do something along these lines (these are in no particular order within the tiers):

TOP TIER:
Dart Monkey
Ninja
Chipper
Submarine
Monkey Engineer

HIGH TIER:
Bomb Tower
Helicopter

MID TIER:
Glue Gunner
Ice Tower
Monkey Apprentice
Super Monkey
Spike Factory
Boomer

LOW TIER:
Monkey Ace
Buccaneer
Sniper
Dartling Gun

BOTTOM TIER:
Tack Shooter
Mortar Tower


Sure, some towers could be argued to be moved up or down slightly since it's very hard to properly do a tier system based on a very generalistic "overall" classification, but I think this is a pretty good stab at it.
Last edited by gakm7; Apr 18, 2018 @ 7:09am
Originally posted by gakm7:
I would say Tack Shooter might be the 2nd worst tower, just slightly better than the mortar tower.


If I had to do a "tier" system for the OVERALL usefulness/efficientness of towers, excluding the village and farm "utility" towers, and without really thinking about it all that much, I'd probably do something along these lines (these are in no particular order within the tiers):

TOP TIER:
Dart Monkey
Ninja
Chipper
Submarine
Monkey Engineer

HIGH TIER:
Bomb Tower
Helicopter

MID TIER:
Glue Gunner
Ice Tower
Monkey Apprentice
Super Monkey
Spike Factory
Boomer

LOW TIER:
Monkey Ace
Buccaneer
Sniper
Dartling Gun

BOTTOM TIER:
Tack Shooter
Mortar Tower


Sure, some towers could be argued to be moved up or down slightly since it's very hard to properly do a tier system based on a very generalistic "overall" classification, but I think this is a pretty good stab at it.
I'm gonna be honest that really is not a "good stab" at it
gakm7 Apr 19, 2018 @ 5:01am 
Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
I'm gonna be honest that really is not a "good stab" at it
Sorry that you feel that way. If you would like to provide any reasoning as to why you feel that way, I would gladly provide detailed explanations for why I tiered each individual tower (based on OVERALL usefulness and efficientness) the way I did.

Note: I've played this game MUCH more than the 93 hours Steam shows I've played, so I do have MANY hundreds of hours of experience under my belt between all the different platforms.
Last edited by gakm7; Apr 19, 2018 @ 5:06am
gakm7 Apr 20, 2018 @ 5:19am 
Originally posted by gakm7:
Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
I'm gonna be honest that really is not a "good stab" at it
Sorry that you feel that way. If you would like to provide any reasoning as to why you feel that way, I would gladly provide detailed explanations for why I tiered each individual tower (based on OVERALL usefulness and efficientness) the way I did.

Note: I've played this game MUCH more than the 93 hours Steam shows I've played, so I do have MANY hundreds of hours of experience under my belt between all the different platforms.
Darn, I was really hoping that you would back up your assertion about how bad of a job I did, but nope, I guess it's much easier to simply say that my tiering sucks than to say WHY it sucks... too bad because I was ready to fully defend why I tiered how I did... apparently you're just talking out your ass... that's too bad...
Sebine Apr 20, 2018 @ 10:12am 
Tack Tower is pretty bad... I would say it's my least used tower

Best tower is clearly the Village.
Originally posted by gakm7:
Originally posted by gakm7:
Sorry that you feel that way. If you would like to provide any reasoning as to why you feel that way, I would gladly provide detailed explanations for why I tiered each individual tower (based on OVERALL usefulness and efficientness) the way I did.

Note: I've played this game MUCH more than the 93 hours Steam shows I've played, so I do have MANY hundreds of hours of experience under my belt between all the different platforms.
Darn, I was really hoping that you would back up your assertion about how bad of a job I did, but nope, I guess it's much easier to simply say that my tiering sucks than to say WHY it sucks... too bad because I was ready to fully defend why I tiered how I did... apparently you're just talking out your ass... that's too bad...
Ah so you're the kind of person who needs to get the last word in. Kind of sad my dude.
Someone who can aim can make excellent use of the gatling dart as the doom ray upgrade though expensive is extremely good, 2-3 super monkeys are top tier minimum, bucaneer and monkey ace are extremely good when fully upgraded, monkey sub's decent for maps where water is far away from the track but other than that its only redeeming quality is the nuke. (Don't remember the skill name). bomb shooter should be moved down to mid. Dart monkey is high but most certainly not top, etc.
If that's the response you wanted, you got it kid.
Gakm4 Apr 20, 2018 @ 4:32pm 
I know gakm7 will reply to this but i have to respond to this also

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Someone who can aim can make excellent use of the gatling dart as the doom ray upgrade though expensive is extremely good
It can be a good tower but it precludes you from using farms or it makes it far more difficult to do so unless you are using agents and it is not a very cost effective tower for what it can do. Due to that i would put it at the mid to low tier myself.

It is a $950 that is not very accurate to start with and has expensive upgrades but it does have infinite range going for it. You need to spend $2050 on upgrades to get it to be a fairly good tower and another $1000 to make it pop lead and frozen bloons. So to make it a good tower that pairs with ice and can pop leads you are having to spend $4000. Now to bring out the true power of it you are having to spend another $6000-7000 which in my opinion is not a worth while investment for a tower that isnt even that great.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
2-3 super monkeys are top tier minimum
Again not cost effective at all for what it can do. it is very space efficient but cost inefficient.

To get this you are spending $23,500 on a single tower and i can spend that much to stop almost anything under moab class and for $7,000 more than that i can stop an infinite amount of anything under moab class. You could also buy 3 4/2 chippers for that price which i feel would be far more worth it than a single 2/3 super monkey.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
bucaneer and monkey ace are extremely good when fully upgraded
The ace is good when fully upgraded but it pales in comparison to the heli pilot and again it isnt cost nor space efficient.

The bucaneer is an average tower at best but in comparison to the sub it is far inferior. Being that it fills the same roll as a sub it is a tower that is not worth using save as a support tower to the sub

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
monkey sub's decent for maps where water is far away from the track but other than that its only redeeming quality is the nuke. (Don't remember the skill name)
Airburst dart combined with advanced intel can make it an infinite range tower that does good damage. Add in balistic missile and it is popping leads and doing good damage to moabs and it doesnt rely on advanced intel to shoot that. First strike gives it the ability to pop ZOMG and you get the money from the pop unlike the boat ability that can pop up to a BFB.

The sub is weak in 2 aspects. the first is no good build in camo detection and the second is regrow bloons. The first is easy to overcome with cheap camo detection towers like the ninja or dart or you can add in a boat as a suppport tower. The second is overcome with a x/3 village or infinite popping setup.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
bomb shooter should be moved down to mid.
please give some reasoning here. as to why it should be lower ranked

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Dart monkey is high but most certainly not top, etc.
A total of $1050 gives you very good popping power at the 2/3 dart. It has camo detection. It has the best specialty building. A few 0/0 darts properly placed and targeted can get you up to your first farm on impoppable.

With the specialty building active on impoppable you can use ~6 2/3 darts to get you up to round 40 where you get a 0/0 chipper. By round 46 you have 2 4/2 farms and a 4/2 chipper. This is done on advanced tracks with all premiums and monkey lab upgrades turned off.

Please do elaborate more on your ect.

I do not fully agree with Gakm7's arrangement of towers, but in an overall essence i agree that it is a good stab at it... I would move many towers but only up or down but that is based off of personal preference of each tower and most towers are only off 1 rank in my mind
Last edited by Gakm4; Apr 20, 2018 @ 4:37pm
Originally posted by Gakm4:
I know gakm7 will reply to this but i have to respond to this also

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Someone who can aim can make excellent use of the gatling dart as the doom ray upgrade though expensive is extremely good
It can be a good tower but it precludes you from using farms or it makes it far more difficult to do so unless you are using agents and it is not a very cost effective tower for what it can do. Due to that i would put it at the mid to low tier myself.

It is a $950 that is not very accurate to start with and has expensive upgrades but it does have infinite range going for it. You need to spend $2050 on upgrades to get it to be a fairly good tower and another $1000 to make it pop lead and frozen bloons. So to make it a good tower that pairs with ice and can pop leads you are having to spend $4000. Now to bring out the true power of it you are having to spend another $6000-7000 which in my opinion is not a worth while investment for a tower that isnt even that great.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
2-3 super monkeys are top tier minimum
Again not cost effective at all for what it can do. it is very space efficient but cost inefficient.

To get this you are spending $23,500 on a single tower and i can spend that much to stop almost anything under moab class and for $7,000 more than that i can stop an infinite amount of anything under moab class. You could also buy 3 4/2 chippers for that price which i feel would be far more worth it than a single 2/3 super monkey.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
bucaneer and monkey ace are extremely good when fully upgraded
The ace is good when fully upgraded but it pales in comparison to the heli pilot and again it isnt cost nor space efficient.

The bucaneer is an average tower at best but in comparison to the sub it is far inferior. Being that it fills the same roll as a sub it is a tower that is not worth using save as a support tower to the sub

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
monkey sub's decent for maps where water is far away from the track but other than that its only redeeming quality is the nuke. (Don't remember the skill name)
Airburst dart combined with advanced intel can make it an infinite range tower that does good damage. Add in balistic missile and it is popping leads and doing good damage to moabs and it doesnt rely on advanced intel to shoot that. First strike gives it the ability to pop ZOMG and you get the money from the pop unlike the boat ability that can pop up to a BFB.

The sub is weak in 2 aspects. the first is no good build in camo detection and the second is regrow bloons. The first is easy to overcome with cheap camo detection towers like the ninja or dart or you can add in a boat as a suppport tower. The second is overcome with a x/3 village or infinite popping setup.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
bomb shooter should be moved down to mid.
please give some reasoning here. as to why it should be lower ranked

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Dart monkey is high but most certainly not top, etc.
A total of $1050 gives you very good popping power at the 2/3 dart. It has camo detection. It has the best specialty building. A few 0/0 darts properly placed and targeted can get you up to your first farm on impoppable.

With the specialty building active on impoppable you can use ~6 2/3 darts to get you up to round 40 where you get a 0/0 chipper. By round 46 you have 2 4/2 farms and a 4/2 chipper. This is done on advanced tracks with all premiums and monkey lab upgrades turned off.

Please do elaborate you your ect.

I do not fully agree with Gakm7's arrangement of towers, but in an overall essence i agree that it is a good stab at it... I would move many towers but only up or down but that is based off of personal preference of each tower and most towers are only off 1 rank in my mind
Your name is "Gakm4" and you expect me to believe you're totally not Gakm7 using an alt
Gakm4 Apr 20, 2018 @ 4:41pm 
Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Your name is "Gakm4" and you expect me to believe you're totally not Gakm7 using an alt
We are two completely separate people. You can believe that if you want to or not but you completely ignored all of my reasoning i had done to defend certain towers and went to that. I applaud your method of evasion.
Originally posted by Gakm4:
Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Your name is "Gakm4" and you expect me to believe you're totally not Gakm7 using an alt
We are two completely separate people. You can believe that if you want to or not but you completely ignored all of my reasoning i had done to defend certain towers and went to that. I applaud your method of evasion.
I genuinely don't care how you feel about those towers, and only responded because you were being a ♥♥♥♥ about not responding.
gakm7 Apr 20, 2018 @ 5:04pm 
Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Ah so you're the kind of person who needs to get the last word in. Kind of sad my dude.
Yup. I just had to get the last word in on myself. Myself can go SUCK it!! This is already starting out swimmingly...

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Someone who can aim can make excellent use of the gatling dart as the doom ray upgrade though expensive is extremely good
While that is true, I specifically said twice that I did my tiering based on "overall usefulness/efficientness". While doom ray is really good and powerful, it isn't particularly useful (or even necessary) in most situations, and it REALLY isn't cost efficient in the slightest. I could get plenty of other fully upgraded top tier towers for the cost of that doom ray upgrade alone, let alone the cost for the rest of the upgrades leading up to it, and the cost of the tower itself. That would be a much more useful and efficient use of my money than getting a gun that takes over my mouse positioning (unless I use the specialty building, which is a total waste since there are better speciality buildings than the dart gunner one). It's not a bad tower per se, but it's quite expensive and inefficient comparatively and it's simply not necessary to have in any way.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
2-3 super monkeys are top tier minimum
If we were talking strictly about MOAB popping ability, or popping power per pixel, sure... I'd put it right in the top tier. But since I said I'm ranking towers by "overall usefulness and efficientness", the 2/3 supermonkey falls down to being a mid tier tower. It's not really all that "useful" because it's overkill in most situations, and it is quite expensive to get when compared to the cost of other 3rd tier upgraded towers. Many players who suck at the game get towers such as this when it would be much more efficient for them (and better in the long run) to just get something like a few 2/3 dart monkeys, or to get a single 4/x bloonchipper, both of which are cheaper and more useful options as they both serve very important specialized purposes.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
bucaneer and monkey ace are extremely good when fully upgraded
Sure they are. So is any other tower pretty much, and a decent amount of those are cheaper than those two towers you listed. A monkey ace has very little usefulness until it gets seeking ammo, and even then, there are more cost efficient tower options. A fully upgraded monkey ace, while good, is very expensive and very unnecessary. Plus, the helicopter outclasses it in many ways. Same with the bucaneer... the sub outclasses it in many ways, thus making the bucaneer not that useful, and the sub can do SO much more than the bucaneer can for the same cost. Again, I'm not just focusing on one specific trait about these towers; I'm looking at the big overall picture.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
monkey sub's decent for maps where water is far away from the track but other than that its only redeeming quality is the nuke. (Don't remember the skill name).
They are excellent on ALL water tracks because, with cheap towers like dart monkeys spread out across the whole track, they can shoot across the WHOLE track, not just one area of the track. That alone makes them a top tier tower. And they can handle any type of bloon pretty much, while the bucaneer can only handle certain bloon types depending on which upgrade path you choose. All of the sub upgrades are very useful and quite cheap compared to the power the upgrades pack into the tower.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
bomb shooter should be moved down to mid.
Again, overall usefulness and efficientness... it is a quite cheap tower and can be focused either on MOABS or on bloon control depending in which upgrade path you take. It can be used in conjunction with glue and ice to make a barrier that can easily handle round 63 without a single thought. It has varied important uses and it is very cheap and cost efficient compared to other options for the same uses. It missed top tier because it's not as "all around" or "best of the best at a specific thing" as those towers, but it's more efficient and useful than most of the mid tier towers.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Dart monkey is high but most certainly not top, etc.
Dart monkey is very essential for the most cost efficient beginning of the game setup for farming, it packs a lot of punch for a very very cheap cost, and it has the best specialty building bar none (further helps with farming at the beginning of the game). With the speciality building, darters can handle ANYTHING through the first thirty some rounds in their sleep. No other tower can boast this, especially for how low of a price darters are. Dart monkey is EASILY a top tier tower, even though it isn't anywhere near the most powerful, because it is a very important and efficient part to any beginning of a game.

Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
If that's the response you wanted, you got it kid.
Ahhh, more attitude to end the post... splendid... usually when people toss around names like that, it's describing their own insecurities, but thank you kind Sir/Ma'am.
Last edited by gakm7; Apr 20, 2018 @ 5:08pm
gakm7 Apr 20, 2018 @ 5:15pm 
Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Originally posted by Gakm4:
We are two completely separate people. You can believe that if you want to or not but you completely ignored all of my reasoning i had done to defend certain towers and went to that. I applaud your method of evasion.
I genuinely don't care how you feel about those towers, and only responded because you were being a ♥♥♥♥ about not responding.
I was only being a ♥♥♥♥ about you not responding because you were being a ♥♥♥♥ by making a completely unsupported accusation towards my apparently pi$$ poor attempt at a tier system for the towers. I would think pulling that kind of ♥♥♥♥ on me deserves a ♥♥♥♥♥ response in return...
Last edited by gakm7; Apr 20, 2018 @ 5:21pm
Gakm4 Apr 20, 2018 @ 5:15pm 
Originally posted by TheHandsomeArrow:
Originally posted by Gakm4:
We are two completely separate people. You can believe that if you want to or not but you completely ignored all of my reasoning i had done to defend certain towers and went to that. I applaud your method of evasion.
I genuinely don't care how you feel about those towers, and only responded because you were being a ♥♥♥♥ about not responding.
As stated I am not Gakm7.

If you make a claim you should be able to back up said claim with your own line of reasoning which as you can see both Gakm7 and I have done. If you put someone else's statements down without providing a line of reasoning or examples as to why you think they are wrong then you should expect one to be an ass towards you.

Edit: Actually you did care what others feel about at least one tower and that is why you made this thread in the first place. I am trying to understand why your care only extends to that individual tower that is sub par.
Last edited by Gakm4; Apr 20, 2018 @ 5:22pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 31 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Apr 18, 2018 @ 1:45am
Posts: 31