Workshops not generating money?

[Widget]

Just like the title says i have a question regarding workshops. Are they currently bugged has i have noticed that in both a vanillia and a modded game workshops do not make money they are literally producing 0 income. the first time this happened to me, it was with a pottery in vlandian in pravand i bought a pottery shop and it was making me no money i had to spend 4000 just to switch it from pottery to a smithy and then back to a pottery shop before it started to make any income for a pottery shop, now after getting the workshops advanced mod and loading a new game i had started just the other day, i bought a silver smith in ortysia and it was not producing any income i let it sit for 2-3 ingame days and checked again no income, i just finished installing and tinkering with mods to reload the same game i started yesterday to still see no income comin in from my silver smith, so i again gave it 2-3 in game days and still no income, the mods i am using has of this moment, are MCM,Harmony, Butterlib, EIextender, modlib, dismemberment and gore, workshops advanced, auto trader, gov's resolve issues, I do not believe it is a mod conflict has an older save from a vlandia playthrough was the one i had issues with the pottery shop, but i was able to fix that one however it doesnt seem has tho this workshop is fixed even after doing the same method has the pottery shop workaround and that was a 1.8 playthrough. just prior to release. So if anyone else has had this issue or knows of a way to fix it i would be very greatful for the assist.

Thanks.

[Ruffio]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n0OVxHpU6bM

[Widget]

thats not my issue has a matter of fact this is a silver workshop in ortysia, and its litteraly producing 0 income, this has never happened before.

[Ritouf™]

I agree with Widget, currently having 5 workshops supplied by 2 villages or 3 sometimes.
Four of them are giving me 0 income (such as the Pottery shop in Pen Cannoc (supplied by 2 villages...), only one is giving +200 a day.

I think it's currently completely bugged.

Same thing with the caravans, they produce during 2-3 days then stop (disapear from your income list) then after few days the caravans will come back in your list and will start to give you a small income again...

And I don't use any mods.

[Widget]

Originally posted by Ritouf™:

I agree with Widget, currently having 5 workshops supplied by 2 villages or 3 sometimes.
4 are giving me 0 income (such as the Pottery shop in Pen Cannoc (supplied by 2 villages...), only one is giving +200 a day.

I think it's completely bugged currently.

Same thing with the caravans, they produce during 2-3 days then stops (remove from your income list) then afetr few days they will start to give you a small income again...

And I don't use any mods.

So I'm not the only one then, cause i have experienced this both without and with mods, and have listed all the ones i am using, but a silver smith that is in ortysia is usually a gaurnteed good income from one shop. i have always made a silver smith there and its always been the most profitable of my shops now its not generating any income at all and its been over a week in game time. somethin funny about that fellas.

[Lore]

i was about to make a thread asking for the same thing, before i oculd just put a few workshops here and there and they made revenue, making enough to cover early game army, but isnce release they dont generate anything, i made a brewery shop in pravend and it made 0 for a week and there was a lot of grain in the city store

[Ruffio]

Originally posted by Rajion:

i was about to make a thread asking for the same thing, before i oculd just put a few workshops here and there and they made revenue, making enough to cover early game army, but isnce release they dont generate anything, i made a brewery shop in pravend and it made 0 for a week and there was a lot of grain in the city store

How much beer on the market?

[Skuffe]

Had the same issue.

They had 0 supplies to make stuff from, so i changed the outcome, and the cash began to flow again.

You simply can't make beer without grain

[Widget]

heres another thing i can add i just switched my silver smith in orytesia to a winery and let it sit for an in game week and still 0 income. since release something got bork bork borked

[Ruffio]

Originally posted by Widget:

heres another thing i can add i just switched my silver smith in orytesia to a winery and let it sit for an in game week and still 0 income. since release something got bork bork borked

Ortysia doesn't even have an bound village that do grapes. The bound villages does; Grain, Salt and Silver..

If you run a workshop and it doesn't make any income. Check the market in the city and see how much of the product is on the market and check the price. As with real life. You can make a ton of stuff, but if no one buys it you wont make any money from it.

[Clovis Sangrail]

Originally posted by Widget:

thats not my issue has a matter of fact this is a silver workshop in ortysia, and its litteraly producing 0 income, this has never happened before.

One possibility -- Check and see if your silver ore source has dried up. Usually that Ortysia silversmith is a good bet, but check the village that is supplying silver ore and make sure its Trade Bound town is still Ortysia.

[flyingscot1066]

Originally posted by Widget:

Just like the title says i have a question regarding workshops. Are they currently bugged has i have noticed that in both a vanillia and a modded game workshops do not make money they are literally producing 0 income. the first time this happened to me, it was with a pottery in vlandian in pravand i bought a pottery shop and it was making me no money i had to spend 4000 just to switch it from pottery to a smithy and then back to a pottery shop before it started to make any income for a pottery shop, now after getting the workshops advanced mod and loading a new game i had started just the other day, i bought a silver smith in ortysia and it was not producing any income i let it sit for 2-3 ingame days and checked again no income, i just finished installing and tinkering with mods to reload the same game i started yesterday to still see no income comin in from my silver smith, so i again gave it 2-3 in game days and still no income, the mods i am using has of this moment, are MCM,Harmony, Butterlib, EIextender, modlib, dismemberment and gore, workshops advanced, auto trader, gov's resolve issues, I do not believe it is a mod conflict has an older save from a vlandia playthrough was the one i had issues with the pottery shop, but i was able to fix that one however it doesnt seem has tho this workshop is fixed even after doing the same method has the pottery shop workaround and that was a 1.8 playthrough. just prior to release. So if anyone else has had this issue or knows of a way to fix it i would be very greatful for the assist.

Thanks.

Now THIS is how you ask for help. Well writ, OP.

I haven't had the opportunity to play with workshops in 1.0.0 yet, but they were prectically throwing money at me in 1.9 so I will have to do some experimentation this evening. I'll let you now what I find out, along with any tricks I manage to figure out how they work now, if they have changed.

[Widget]

Originally posted by Ruffio:

Originally posted by Widget:

heres another thing i can add i just switched my silver smith in orytesia to a winery and let it sit for an in game week and still 0 income. since release something got bork bork borked

Ortysia doesn't even have an bound village that do grapes. The bound villages does; Grain, Salt and Silver..

If you run a workshop and it doesn't make any income. Check the market in the city and see how much of the product is on the market and check the price. As with real life. You can make a ton of stuff, but if no one buys it you wont make any money from it.

i built the winery because of the video you linked it was one of the recammended workshops plus it was an opturtunity to test a differnet workshop to see if the issue perssisted and it did, when i say i am literally generating 0 income in over the span of a week and then swith workshops and still generate 0 income over the course of a second week i mean i am literally not making any bank, not with a silver smith, not with a winery, and i suspect not likely with any other workshop in game.

[Widget]

Originally posted by Clovis Sangrail:

Originally posted by Widget:

thats not my issue has a matter of fact this is a silver workshop in ortysia, and its litteraly producing 0 income, this has never happened before.

One possibility -- Check and see if your silver ore source has dried up. Usually that Ortysia silversmith is a good bet, but check the village that is supplying silver ore and make sure its Trade Bound town is still Ortysia.

i let the silver smith sit for a week and nothing changed it over toa winery let that sit for a week and still 0 income, i havent a clue whats going on, but given some of the other replys it seems i am not the only one affected by this issue and caravans are also affected. oh bother.

[Starwight/ttv]

Originally posted by Widget:

Originally posted by Ruffio:

Ortysia doesn't even have an bound village that do grapes. The bound villages does; Grain, Salt and Silver..

If you run a workshop and it doesn't make any income. Check the market in the city and see how much of the product is on the market and check the price. As with real life. You can make a ton of stuff, but if no one buys it you wont make any money from it.

i built the winery because of the video you linked it was one of the recammended workshops plus it was an opturtunity to test a differnet workshop to see if the issue perssisted and it did, when i say i am literally generating 0 income in over the span of a week and then swith workshops and still generate 0 income over the course of a second week i mean i am literally not making any bank, not with a silver smith, not with a winery, and i suspect not likely with any other workshop in game.

Then you're not doing workshops properly. When streamers, other players, and myself can have profitable workshops and you can't, that should tell you it's not the game. Either that, or you have a mod that is messing ♥♥♥♥ up.

[Ruffio]

Originally posted by Widget:

Originally posted by Ruffio:

Ortysia doesn't even have an bound village that do grapes. The bound villages does; Grain, Salt and Silver..

If you run a workshop and it doesn't make any income. Check the market in the city and see how much of the product is on the market and check the price. As with real life. You can make a ton of stuff, but if no one buys it you wont make any money from it.

i built the winery because of the video you linked it was one of the recammended workshops plus it was an opturtunity to test a differnet workshop to see if the issue perssisted and it did, when i say i am literally generating 0 income in over the span of a week and then swith workshops and still generate 0 income over the course of a second week i mean i am literally not making any bank, not with a silver smith, not with a winery, and i suspect not likely with any other workshop in game.

Here is the thing...

If the town belong to one faction.... and castles around it belong to another. The bound villages for those castles will go to closest town of their faction to trade their goods. In case where close castles have bound villages that supply what your workshop need, but then owner of town or castles change faction owner. It will mess up your production chain.