When it comes to war games, should I buy this or Total War: Three Kingdoms?

[Corey]

I know I'll probably get biased answers but I kinda wanna hear what y'all think anyway.

[GamingWithSilvertail]

The only thing I will say is tthat one is a generic total war game and mnb is mnb.

In otherwords, Youi cant really compare them.

[Shade]

completly different types of games
Total war is a RTS , Warband has RTS elements in it but its actualy more like a 3rd person / first person RPG / Strategy / Hack and slash
It really is something unique , it has elements of all of the things above

[madracc00n]

Dunno.But i wouldnt reccomend any of the 2,since bannerlord is just not rdy to be played.And 3 kingdoms are just generic total war,that has almost no new stuff for my taste.

[Larus]

M&B is not so much a war game as it is a roleplay sandbox with wars. So I guess go for total war instead since they're all about war.

[Go0lden_Archer]

TWTK will have more indepth mechanics to strategic and tactical layers. Specially so right now.
The appeal of MnB is that you arent god above, but a general on the field.

And to me, who loves RPG is amazing in itself to lead armies instead of getting eagle overview

[datCookie]

Originally posted by Project Danny:

i wouldnt play this game just yet lots of unfinished things lots of bugs sure it can be fun for a little while but the more you play it the more you will find how empty and shallow it is....

now this is the part people will quote me and say...

"Reee its early access what you expect"
"Reeee dont listen to him hes a troll"
"Reeeeee my game is flawless and this is so much fun and anyone who says anything negative is a troll reeeeee"

as i said the game can be fun but after a while you will see its really unfinished.... and i have over 100+ hours.....

pssst.... this is the part you quote me again and say "reeeeeee bUh Its EaRly AccEsss OfCouRse Its NoT fINiShEd"

When you miss the entire point of Early Access and do nothing but bash the game for being finished, despite the fact that it is advertised to be in an unfinished state, yes, you are going to get "reeee it's early access".

To the OP: Both games are entirely different. Don't really know how to draw a comparison

[datCookie]

Originally posted by Project Danny:

Originally posted by datCookie:

When you miss the entire point of Early Access and do nothing but bash the game for being finished, despite the fact that it is advertised to be in an unfinished state, yes, you are going to get "reeee it's early access".

To the OP: Both games are entirely different. Don't really know how to draw a comparison

POINT Proven right here "Reee iTs EaRlY AccEsss"

as i said... if you even botherd to read at all... i said its a good game at the start.... bashing would mean i give it 0 compliments.

stop using the "Reeeeee its EaRly AcCeSs" as a shield to stop anyone from saying anything bad about it....

You're deluded if you think that what you've been saying the last hour or so in multiple threads isn't considered as bashing the game. Sure, you may pay a compliment or two, most of which are backhanded anyway.

And not a single person has said you can't criticise a game, not even I've said that. But you HAVE missed the point of Early Access. You've gone and judged the game as if it is meant to be finished. You've just told the OP here "Don't play it because it is unfinished, has lots of bugs and is shallow and lacking all depth". Those statements are true, but you fail to acknowledge (to the OP) that this is a part of Early Access and all of the things you have mentioned will change down the line as development continues.

Again, no one is saying you cannot criticise the game, but there is a right way of doing it..

[SuperCrumpets]

Total war is really shallow so bannerlord all the way.

[I got 1984'd]

Get Total War three kingdoms that game is fun and optimized. This game... meh. I would wait before spending 50 bucks on it if you havent got the discount