Am a doctor...

[( QC ) chiensale2005]

Yea right. You can't figure if the bite is from a human or a dog. Do someone else have a problem with this ? :)

[Pope Of Pumpernickel]

I don't think I have ever seen a person, alive or dead, leaving a bite the size of a forearm.

[Alex0391]

For me, the problem the doctor wanted a fever to be the proof that is was a walker bite, which is pretty dumb because no matter what type of bite it was, she was going to get a fever from infection anyways. That doctor sucks.

[DarkChiyo]

Messaggio originale di Kittycat:

Rebeca or whatever the hell her name is, doesnt make sence what so ever to be such a ♥♥♥♥♥ to a nine year old, just because she doesnt trust her? does she really think, a child can kill a full group of adults...?

Maybe not kill but they seem to be hunted by a man named Carver. It could be that they think that Clem is a spy sent by him. She could gather their trust and later when they least expect it, go back to inform him or do things that could make it easier for Carver to do what they want. That´s what I could imagine.

I also think that this doctor simply didn´t give much off a damn about Clementine (A mouth more to feed, possible danger beeing sent by Carver, Corruption of his daughter) or that he isn´t a doc in the first place. I doubt the latter because he was able to analyse and treat Clementine´s wound later. I guess he simply hoped the problem would solve itself later in the night with the infection of the wound (wich would have startened later without Clemetine beeing able to proven otherwhise resulting in a headshot)

Cold calculation. :/

[Suspector]

I wrote already that this guy might never a real doctor. A glitch has shown that he might be also the owner of the golden watch. However, a doctor should be able to sepearte between dental impression of a human and dog. Not only because of predator and omnivore teeth differences, is also on shape of head, power of the bite. I assume there much more differences.
However, another strange behaivor is that the barley medical supplies are good enought to spend an extra antiseptic for the daugther (without need), but not to a younger bleeding child.
I hope I'll get a chance to say thank you in a later episode :P

[kraidy117]

He's a quack.

[Hitsugi]

Messaggio originale di Temerity:

Clem is actually either 10 or 11 at this point in the story. That said; he told her to stay away because he doesn't want her to know about how dangerous the world has really grown and he is afraid that Clem will corrupt her. He's treating her like she is some kind of a precious flower. Well; I can't entirely blame him for that, but that kind of attitude might get her killed in this world.

I guess I understand his mindset, but it's still pretty crappy of him to talk to Clem that way. Eventually she WILL have to find out what's out there. The world is different, and nothing is safe anymore.

[( QC ) chiensale2005]

Messaggio originale di Hitsugi:

Messaggio originale di Temerity:

Clem is actually either 10 or 11 at this point in the story. That said; he told her to stay away because he doesn't want her to know about how dangerous the world has really grown and he is afraid that Clem will corrupt her. He's treating her like she is some kind of a precious flower. Well; I can't entirely blame him for that, but that kind of attitude might get her killed in this world.

I guess I understand his mindset, but it's still pretty crappy of him to talk to Clem that way. Eventually she WILL have to find out what's out there. The world is different, and nothing is safe anymore.

Well if you ask me, if we call this group ( good peoples ) ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ like this on young girl in this dark world, well i guess the world can burn, no more point to survive. Humanity is dead with lee, maybe no, still burning in Clem, but how much time a young soul like her will keep up ? This groups is just wrong in every way, i will kill myself if i have to say all i see wrong in this group.

[MorningLightMountain]

Messaggio originale di chiensale2005:

Messaggio originale di Hitsugi:

I guess I understand his mindset, but it's still pretty crappy of him to talk to Clem that way. Eventually she WILL have to find out what's out there. The world is different, and nothing is safe anymore.

Well if you ask me, if we call this group ( good peoples ) ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ like this on young girl in this dark world, well i guess the world can burn, no more point to survive. Humanity is dead with lee, maybe no, still burning in Clem, but how much time a young soul like her will keep up ? This groups is just wrong in every way, i will kill myself if i have to say all i see wrong in this group.

The way Clementine is being treated isn't that far off the way Lee's group initially treated Ben and also based on comments made by Lilly in episode two the way Mark was treated by certain characters as well.

[kraidy117]

Messaggio originale di MorningLightMountain:

Messaggio originale di chiensale2005:

Well if you ask me, if we call this group ( good peoples ) ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ like this on young girl in this dark world, well i guess the world can burn, no more point to survive. Humanity is dead with lee, maybe no, still burning in Clem, but how much time a young soul like her will keep up ? This groups is just wrong in every way, i will kill myself if i have to say all i see wrong in this group.

The way Clementine is being treated isn't that far off the way Lee's group initially treated Ben and also based on comments made by Lilly in episode two the way Mark was treated by certain characters as well.

Ben proved he was a burden though, as long as Clem can prove she is not, she'll be fine. So far Pete, Luke, Alvin(either neutral and supports you) Nick(if you accepted his appolgy)and Carlos if you are nice and agree with him have no issues with you. The big issue is Larry 2.0

[dustbiter]

What a quack, no medical training is required to tell from the toothmark pattern that bite wasn't from a human/walker. Bad writing? Plot device must go on?

[Hobbes]

He is pretty hopeless, not sure what type of Doctor he thinks he is, I wonder if fooled these guys to try and get into the group. Even if for some reason he can't differentiate between a dog bite and human walker bite, he should be well aware of the implications of leaving her in the shed overnight. I won't put much faith in that man....

Messaggio originale di FearGuy:

For me, the problem the doctor wanted a fever to be the proof that is was a walker bite, which is pretty dumb because no matter what type of bite it was, she was going to get a fever from infection anyways. That doctor sucks.

Lol, exactly.

[dynoman6]

Messaggio originale di Temerity:

Yeah, he should have been able to tell the difference from the bite. I notice things like this all of the time in books, TV, movies and video games... It comes from lazy writing. The writers don't know enough about what they are talking about and, instead of looking into it, they just go ahead and put something down and hope that it will work. Usually it doesn't. It wasn't a huge deal though, but it did bother me some.

I couldn't agree more, I'm not a doctor, have no medical training but I reckon I could make a good guess at whether a bite was made with human teeth or dogs teeth. I HAVE been bitten by a dog tho so maybe joe public couldn't tell, either way I find it unbelievable that a doctor couldn't tell. This is a pretty shallow plot thread, I sincerely hope it gets better.

[Scavenger]

I can buy the idea that the wound may have been so bad that even a doctor can't tell what caused it but surely he should have known a fever would likely follow any bite especially if it hasn't been cleaned. Not sure how they screwed this one up.

[Captain Shittastic]

Messaggio originale di Tonkinese:

To note I have seen plenty a dog bite that from the tearing has no longer resombled the basic visual appearance of a dog bite. Kind of like a tear or ip in the arm. Sadly it is an occourance amonst children and dog bites as the children are small and light so it is easer to damge.

I can understand that a a dog bite on a child arm may be difficult to identify as a dog bite , but no human , even undead , can match the bite , even if it's riped up so bad it's not recognisable as a dog bite. Actually , ripping open the full forearm like that only proves without a doubt it's not a zombie bite.

[Hitsugi]

Messaggio originale di MorningLightMountain:

Messaggio originale di chiensale2005:

Well if you ask me, if we call this group ( good peoples ) ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ like this on young girl in this dark world, well i guess the world can burn, no more point to survive. Humanity is dead with lee, maybe no, still burning in Clem, but how much time a young soul like her will keep up ? This groups is just wrong in every way, i will kill myself if i have to say all i see wrong in this group.

The way Clementine is being treated isn't that far off the way Lee's group initially treated Ben and also based on comments made by Lilly in episode two the way Mark was treated by certain characters as well.

People are just wary, and some of the people in the group felt bad about it at least.