(Spoiler) Who watched him die.

[damn daniel]

Again, spoiler alert. Do not move your mouse down to the black line if you don't want to see something you didn't see yet.

Who watched Carver die? Because I did. That ♥♥♥♥ deserved what he got.

[Heckley]

I smiled the whole way through.... Hehe.

[Parasoul]

This was one of the most interesting choices in the game, and really made use of the fact that the protagonist is a child.
They made us want to watch his death, but since the narrative follows Clementine, we had to choose. Either spare Clementine the sight and miss it ourselves, or further mess Clementine up (and possibly make her more prone to that kind of revenge attitude in future years).

Personally I chose to watch, and I'm okay with it. I feel like it's something Clementine would have probably chosen to do, with how everyone except Kenny treats her like a child, and she'd just watched Carver hurt and kill. (He also hit her, of course.)

[damn daniel]

Originally posted by Wisewolf:

This was one of the most interesting choices in the game, and really made use of the fact that you're controlling a little girl. They made us want to watch, but since the narrative follows Clementine, we had to choose. Either spare Clementine the sight and miss it ourselves, or further mess Clementine up (and possibly make her more prone to that kind of revenge attitude in future years).

Personally I chose to watch, and I'm okay with it. I feel like it's something Clementine would have probably chose to do, with how everyone except Kenny treats her like a child, and she'd just watched Carver hurt and kill. (He also hit her, of course.)

Agreed. After seeing Carver kill people that meant no harm, I think Clementine has a right to watch what he gets.

[Sig]

So massive spoilers somewhat influenced by the comic & comic spoilers

You have to kill dangerous people off until you have a colony that has the capabilities to begin putting people on trial, to jail them. It's waaaaayyyy too dangerous to assume someone is dead when you leave them because they may not be and come back to get you when your guard is down. Like in the comic, Negan is spared to end the cycle of violence, its the first time in the comic where it looks like there a legitimate chance of rebuilding society and it has to start with justice.

[Bile JAR]

I wanted to see him die so bad, after what he did to a few characters on the last episode. He slapped me in the beginning of the episode because I was staring at him, lol. Clem has already seen everything, so what's the matter if she see's someone else die, too?

[bananasloth]

No. I told Kenny to shoot him (because he was a huge threat to Clem's group and later potentially other people), but I didn't think mashing his face into a pulp was justified, and I wouldn't want Clem to think so either.

[bcom33]

I felt like the game forced my hand to have Clementine stay and watch Carter get his face mashed in. I definitely at first chose the dialog option to have Luke just shoot Carter, he obviously needed to die, and deserved it as much as anyone.

Once he was shot and on the ground, the camera focused on him several times showing he had a pistol still holstered. Kenny then proceeds to walk over to get the crowbar, and put down his own gun. So, at this point I'm thinking there's a huge possibility that Carter goes for his gun at some point as a last ditch attempt to save himself, or go down firing. That along with the fact that people keep leaving the room so Kenny can handle his business, led me to believe even more than this was a place where Kenny might die if I wasn't there to stop Carter somehow when he went for his holstered pistol.

I guess I might be overthinking it, but I think having the pistol on him was very misleading by the developers. It made it less of a moral decision for me, and completely a decision of practicality and trying to protect my friend.

[lizard81288]

I wanted to tie him up and get eaten.

[You takin notes]

I left with Sarita, i know clem has seen all kinds of ♥♥♥♥, but staying to watch is just doing what Carver wants.

[damocles23]

I watched him die. I wanted to be sure he would never hurt anyone ever again.

[ShaZam]

This decision was a no-brainer. Clem killed Carver, Kenny was just the one holding the crowbar. Because she killed him, she had a responsibility to watch him die. You don't just look away when you take a life, good guy, bad guy, or zombie guy. You take responsibilty, and my Clem is a responsible Clem. She's also a hugger.

[LT]

I would like to Sarah watch it too. Girl needs to get real. That stupid man Carlos can't grow a child.

Btw, had everyone taken the gun from the table? Or how does Carver die, if you don't do it? Clem jumps on him?

[Demoman?]

Originally posted by LT:

I would like to Sarah watch it too. Girl needs to get real. That stupid man Carlos can't grow a child.

Btw, had everyone taken the gun from the table? Or how does Carver die, if you don't do it? Clem jumps on him?

If Alvin is alive, he'll actually take the gun and shoots the guy who comes up to the office. The guy fatally shoots Alvin though. If that happens, or you simply don't grab the gun, you'll just jump on him and the guys combo in the same way.

[Hillbilly_Dave]

Originally posted by LT:

I would like to Sarah watch it too. Girl needs to get real. That stupid man Carlos can't grow a child.

Btw, had everyone taken the gun from the table? Or how does Carver die, if you don't do it? Clem jumps on him?

Yeah. I left the gun with Alvin so he could go out in a blaze of glory so my Clem sidled her way across the racking then jumped on Carver, which allowed Kenny and Luke to disarm him. From there, I told Luke to kill Carver, but he wouldn't, so Kenny put a bullet in each of Carver's knees so he couldn't get away then Kenny beat him to death with a crowbar, and I watched the whole thing. I wish it had let us see more of it instead of cutting away, showing some change, then cutting away again, showing more change, repeating till finished.

[Rumpelcrutchskin]

Bashing his head with crowbar ten times was not exactly choice one, he was huge threat and needed to be eliminated but bullet to the head would have been enough.
Ah hell, goooooo Kenny!