A House Divided stats are up!

[Nitro]

Me and 42.8% of players took the blame for Sarah's photo. I felt like owning up to it since I cursed when Carver noticed the photo, but I smiled when Sarah took the fall. She wasn't kidding when she made Clem her best friend.

Me and 34.2% of players sat with Luke at dinner. At first I was ecstatic to see Kenny but as many have mentioned he's...really off, somehow. In general I stayed extremely loyal to Carlos' group, both because I trust them, and because Carlos is a doctor. You ALWAYS stay with the doctor during a zombie apocalypse.

Me and 73.3% of players told Walter the truth. Lying is almost never a good strategy in TWD. It seemed like the right thing to do.

Me and 86.2% of players convinced Walter to forgive Nick. Nick's coming unhinged, but it's hard to blame the poor guy. He's not as strong as Luke, and he lost his entire family.

Me and 55% of players sought Kenny's help. I thought initially surrendering was going to get somebody killed, but when Carver started picking people off, I convinced Kenny to surrender in time to save Alvin.

What did you do?

[pdm]

Wondering why only 42.8% took the blame? they hate sarah or something?

[Hydrax]

Originally posted by Pud1M:

Wondering why only 42.8% took the blame? they hate sarah or something?

I remained silent for that part, since it was both of us and as far as I can remember there was no option to say that it was both clem and sarah.

[bananasloth]

It's interesting to see how the numbers shift over time. Here are my stats, taken maybe ~12hrs after the episode came out:

http://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=234913555

Originally posted by Pud1M:

Wondering why only 42.8% took the blame? they hate sarah or something?

I took the blame, but for me, when I briefly considered throwing Sarah under the bus, it wasn't so much about disliking her as about being afraid of Carlos' reaction since I had promised him I wouldn't get too close to his daughter.

The dinner table choice was sort of difficult, because logically, Luke and the others shouldn't have been too upset about Clem wanting to catch up with an old friend. Knowing how this game works, though, I pretty easily decided that I like Luke much better, and that Kenny's frankly shaky loyalty wasn't something I'm all that interested in.

I thought Walter deserved to know the truth about what happened to his partner, and besides, it looked like he had already pieced most of it together. I trusted him not to get violent, because he seemed like a well-meaning and forgiving person. Plus, he mentioned how he told Matthew not to wander away from the group for such long intervals because it would lead to trouble, so I thought he's understand that it was just a terrible accident.

Nick might be a liability, but I meant it when I said he was a good guy, that was a no-brainer.

I thought we'd be safer surrendering. Fortunately I screamed to Kenny to stop shooting, so Alvin didn't die either.

[Walker☻//︻ ---]

Originally posted by Sandrunner:

Originally posted by Pud1M:

Wondering why only 42.8% took the blame? they hate sarah or something?

I remained silent for that part, since it was both of us and as far as I can remember there was no option to say that it was both clem and sarah.

Well she diid take a photo so im not gonna say i took it and protect her.

[[TLGS] Mario-x]

I wanted Nick dead, so I let Walter make up his own mind. He killed Matthew, and I have the same first name. So Nick needed to die.

[samuricex]

Originally posted by pdm:

Wondering why only 42.8% took the blame? they hate sarah or something?

I think, like me, a lot of people took the "you wanted me to keep her busy!" answer, which seemed like the neutral answer but the game counts it as not taking the blame. I didn't want to put the blame on her but it wasn't my idea either...

I "blamed" Sara.

I sat with Luke.

I told the truth.

I got Walter to forgive Nick. I did promise Pete I'd take care of this manchild so...

I surrendered.

[Anathema]

Originally posted by TLGS Mario-x:

He killed Matthew, and I have the same first name. So Nick needed to die. :cgpout:

Flawless reasoning.

[IndigoHawk]

I took the blame for the photo. Clem took it, even if it was Sarah's idea.

I sat with Luke not because Kenny was off, but because I thought Luke's group was more on edge and needed to see that Clem wasn't going to immediately abandon people when someone else comes along. Besides, Clem already didn't vouch for Luke's group (Nick is trigger happy and the group is pretty selfish and made a little girl bleed in a shed).

I told Walter the truth, because lying gets people killed. I convinced Walter to forgive Nick (( didn't care if he forgave him ... I just wanted Walter to make up his own mind and not hold Clem responsible for having the knife).

I sought Kenny's help and got Alvin killed. I didn't really think about the fact that Carver is too important to die so he would have plot armor. In retrospect I see why surrendering is a good option, since Carver rounded up people instead of killing them. However, Kenny said he had the shot, and I think it was worth the risk to stop Carver right there.

[Hobbes]

I decided to take the blame, god knows why, I suppose I was trying to get in the girls good books.

I decided to sit with Luke, I'm not big on Kenny and I wanted to reassure my own group.

I told the truth because otherwise I felt like it was going to come back and bite me, it always seems to. This way everything was out in the open and we could work from there.

I convinced Walter to forgive him and said Nick was a good guy. I mean he sort of is, he is just a bit of an idiot...plus I promised Pete that I'd look after him.

I went looking for Kenny and Luke, I figured giving myself up wasn't going to help anyone. Ithen asked Kenny not to shoot because...well...it didn't make sense. You kill one persona dn then what? They get all defensive and could kill the rest. Thankfully I grabbed the gun off him before he got Alvin killed.

[F0rs4k3n]

I took the blame, sat with Kenny at dinner, told Walter the truth AND convinced him to forgive Nick, sought for Kenny's help and stopped him in time to spare Alvin.
P.S.: The reason why I told Kenny not to shoot when Carver was holding Alvin hostage was not because I thought Kenny would hit but not kill Carver and he would kill Alvin in return, but because I thought Kenny would hit Alvin by mistake.