Game vs. show vs. comic?

[RIOT|RIOT|AlphA]

I say show > game > comic

[76561198149519561]

I have never read the comic but I hear it's good. The show had me hooked until season 2 it was boring.

[ThePlagued]

Publicado originalmente por prap123:

game>comic. The show does not deserve to be included in this discussion.

This.

[Walker☻//︻ ---]

Mean while on finland (2012)Police on action and bullet shooted! (tires maybe)?) arrested unharmed of 2men! eat this americans!! our police is better and no gun fire needed! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ohB-D7az7KY over 40minutes chase police wins! epic car chase! Absololity not TWD2 issue but see how cool police we has! No gunfire needed! after 40 min chase they captured escapers and put handguffs of rogues! Call police we dont never giveup and and we can end thiese wihtout fired! See Americans! Not that hard!

[iVladYKT]

I haven't read the comic yet, so I don't have the full vision. Though, I can say that the game is much better than the show.

[Adel]

Game>Show>Comic.. Game cuz it let me be the character and is diffent from any other game I played + I enjoy the story. Show over comics cuz I simply don't like comics much.. started reading the walking dead comics just now but so far I prefer the show... atleast that lasts for like 40 min + per episode and I can read the comics to fast like 2 mins and it's over... well.... what now I think.. so yeah the comic is last simply for being a comic. Maybe I'll like the books though... guess we'll have to wait and see.

[Rainman]

Comic>Game>Show

[Bauhaus]

Comic>Game>>>>>>Show

The game may have some likeable characters, but they're all a bunch of ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ compared to the intelligent, well-rounded and believable characters from the books. Clemclem may have that hard-ass mofo' stare, having survived 2 years of the zombie poxiclypse, but the game still forces us to do all kinds of stupid ♥♥♥♥ like stepping over zombies and walking past loosely shuttered windows/fences, just for that "oh noes, I've been grabbed again" sequence.

"What's that Clem? You wanna chase a rolling water bottle into a stall? Best leave that clunky gun behind, it's HEAVY. What's that Clem? You're unarmed and searching an abandoned camp for food? Don't bother picking up one of those pots or frying pans to defend yourself, they're not food!"

But it's all part and parcel of the game's linear and predictable storyline, where none of your choices matter. Did you just manage to save a member of your party? Good job! Oh, and spoiler alert: they're dead within two episodes.

Game's still a fun experience for an interactive movie, just wish all the best bits weren't ripped straight from the comics.

Publicado originalmente por Adel:

Maybe I'll like the books though... guess we'll have to wait and see.

I don't have the patience to get tiny bits of story here and there, either. Find someone to borrow The Walking Dead Compendium Vol. 1 from. Or take the plunge and buy it, it's definitely worth it.

[Mom's Spaghetti]

I really love the game, is properly the best game I've very played, so i say game first. The show was kinda boring the first 3-4 episodes but after that I liked it. I haven't read the comics so I can't tell if it better or worse.

[-3xA'Lu©κy the disappearing act]

Publicado originalmente por ThePlagued:

Comic>Game>Show. The show lacks the complexity and subtlty of the Game and Comic. and the Game cannot entirely catch the original source materials hold on us, especially with season 2.

Someone who holds the same view point is rare these days.

Glad people like you still exist :)

[-3xA'Lu©κy the disappearing act]

Publicado originalmente por prap123:

game>comic. The show does not deserve to be included in this discussion.

Why not; it's a part of the universe and canon.

Also, what about the TWD books?

[Jamison]

Show>Game>Comic

I own the first three books of the comics (which I regret buying). The comics are so simplistic, not to mention that the female characters have no real character from what I can tell. In the first few issues, all the female characters were looking for some guy to bang. There is nothing in the comics (books1-3) that stand out to me at all.

The show started off slow in season 1. Parts of season 2 felt like I was watching a soap opera, but mid-point season 3 to now has been pretty damn good in my opinion. I'm also looking forward to season 5.

[a high blue cat]

Comic>Game>>>>>Show

[MorningLightMountain]

Publicado originalmente por -3xA'Lu©κy:

Publicado originalmente por prap123:

game>comic. The show does not deserve to be included in this discussion.

Why not; it's a part of the universe and canon.

Also, what about the TWD books?

The show isn't part of the shared canon of the books, game and comic. As it's an alternate adapation.

[-3xA'Lu©κy the disappearing act]

Publicado originalmente por MorningLightMountain:

Publicado originalmente por -3xA'Lu©κy:

Why not; it's a part of the universe and canon.

Also, what about the TWD books?

The show isn't part of the shared canon of the books, game and comic. As it's an alternate adapation.

Well fine, it's in the same universe and is Kirkman's baby, if I can say that without sounding weird :D

I'd still call it canon though, but yeah, it doesn't share the canon with the game, comics and books. The books weren't good now that I think about it anyway, except for the first one.

[Epik_Leyf]

GAME&COMIC>SHOW(cuz didnt watch it)