Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

Vampire: The Masquerade - Bloodlines

Mr X 2016 年 9 月 14 日 下午 12:46
What generation are we in the game?
Is there a way to know the generation of the protagonist? In the game you fight against manypowerfull foes and you 're pretty powerfull by the end of the game, which should take place in thre time span of a couple of weeks! Is it possible for a vampire to become so powerfull in such short time? I'm not an expert with the WoD, I only read a few things becouse it's really fascinating, so I'm asking you guys.
< >
目前顯示第 31-45 則留言,共 72
Anderson 2016 年 9 月 23 日 上午 12:06 
引用自 furbleburble
I've been thinking about playing this again, came across this thread, thought I'd add a few thoughts and see what responses come up.

It's been quite a while since I played last...

The following is all in reference to the Grout Mansion portion of the story:

LaCroix wants 4 people gone: protagonist, Grout, Nines, and Ming. (I'm sure there are others, but especially these)

I was always under the impression that Ming killed Grout and framed Nines for it. However, Ming didn't really need to kill Grout, but simply be there disguised as Nines, to give the appearance that Nines is guilty. I always wondered why Bach was there though, aside from the obvious, "Die, Vampire!". It seems that "someone" informed Bach that LaCroix might be there, and Bach (iirc) seemed to think that was the case. It's possible that LaCroix tried to get the protagonist, Nines, Ming, and Grout removed in one fell swoop.

We see what happens when LaCroix calls a Bloodhunt (is that the right term?) on Nines. Removing Nines from his seat of power would only help LaCroix. So much is obvious. But he can't do it himself, or through his lackeys, for risk of harm to himself.

Removing Ming from the seat of power for the Kuei-Jin would have a similarly obvious effect for LaCroix. If Ming is somehow killed by Bach, then cool for LaCroix as he can blame the Vampire Hunters. If the protagonist somehow kills Ming, LaCroix can simply hand over the protagonist to the Kuei-Jin, problem solved. However, if Ming is not killed by Bach, oh well, as another attempt on her life can happen later. If Bach doesn't show up at Grout's at all, and Ming somehow is killed, then it would be very easy for the Kuei-Jin to blame the vampires as a whole, and thus start a war, which is obviously bad for LaCroix, or, again, LaCroix can simply hand over the protagonist whether s/he is guilty or not. So, Bach is an insurance policy, whether anyone dies or not. If anything not human dies while a vampire hunter is around, just blame the vampire hunter. If the protagonist dies, regardless of anyone else dying, then LaCroix finally gets rid of the protaganist, as he wanted anyway.

LaCroix can't have the protaganist kill Grout or Nines for obvious reasons; the murder(s) would be linked directly to LaCroix. If Ming kills anyone as herself then it could, and most likely would, lead to a war that neither Ming nor LaCroix can afford to have. However, LaCroix could have Ming kill someone while she is disguised as someone important, which is apparently what happens. If Ming kills Grout while disguised as Nines, easy frame job. Bach is (possibly) tipped about the Grout mansion and is, unwittingly, an insurance policy for LaCroix in case anything goes wrong at the mansion; just blame Bach.

Another thing to consider. Grout mentions taking precautions to protect himself and his wife, along with not knowing the full spectrum of vampire abilities. It's entirely possible that he fled, and the body on the bed is not his. I'm not aware that we actually learn if Grout was truly killed.

(Edit: LOL Fortunately I reread this, realised I posted without finishing a thought I had started. I have since removed that.)
Same line of thought here. You're much better than me at articulating this.
We can't and shouldn't be so categoric about the Grout mansion for the reason that everything is so vague and ambiguous.



引用自 Sesh
One thing that always seems to be overlooked in the "why can LaCroix dominate me early but fails when he tries late in the game?" question is the possibility that LaCroix and the player are the same generation. Early LaCroix is taking advantage of the player character's inexperience, by the end you've surpassed him (not really hard to do given his rather limited capabilities).

As for generation: 8th generation, making you quite strong in a world fillied with generations 10+, you aren't exactly an ancient monster but your power relative to the environs of LA make you a force to be reckoned with. And to the rapid growth: you're playing a person who was born to be a vampire, someone with an amazing amount of natural talent for being a vampire that allows them to capitalize on thier potential quickly.

Well on that note... Maybe if the Grout mansion story took place in the end of the game - we could've found out more details on this mystery. Considering how easily for example the Fu Syndicate, the Giovanni and their secrets were uncovered (especially if you sneak through the back of the mansion).
Or how at the end of the day we see for real who Lacroix really is through his hysteric mania for power.
Chances are there would at least be clues left. In the scenario that the Grout mansion would be the ending level (just imagine that) and all major plot climactic events unfolded there.
That theory also in light of the "potent blood" the protagonist has and litterly the ultimate test through fire and sword.
It's a cool thing kind of not to know tha answer about Grout but also maybe a missed opportunity.
On the other hand imagination is far more active for what we can't see in Ocean House hotel too and it worked in its favour as well. Perhaps same rule goes for the Grout story?
最後修改者:Anderson; 2016 年 9 月 23 日 上午 12:12
furbleburble 2016 年 9 月 23 日 下午 3:11 
About Grout:

I think not knowing about Grout with any kind of certainty is a good thing. It's left open to interpretation pretty well, and I think LaCroix would want it no other way in case something goes wrong; no one could link him to it without some pretty substantial reaching.

On the chance that something goes unaccording to plan and Ming were to say something, not only would she implicate herself, but who would believe a Kuei-Jin? After all, there appears to be no witnesses or evidence to any of this (Grout's recordings possibly).

About LaCroix dominating the protagonist:

Strauss says something to the protagonist at the end of the game if you take a certain ending. While I can't remember what exactly, (iirc) he does say something about it being rare for one so young to become so powerful (though in that ending, one could argue that Strauss influenced that particular scene). On that note, it's possible that, by the end of the story, the protagonist has gained so many reasons to distrust the Prince (or anyone for that matter) and has gained so much confidence in himself, that overpowering the Prince's domination wasn't difficult. While expressing it that way makes it seem anti-climactic, it's certainly possible. (I think this has already been mentioned, I'm essentially agreeing. Also, I think it was what I was gonna end my previous post with.)

A funny thing... I never knew that the Prince would dominate you throughout the game until I read about it online a while back, and I had already beaten the game several times by then. I either played along as his lackey, or I pretended I was his lackey while working for Nines. I guess it always just made sense to me to play that way given that the Prince "spared my life," even if I was playing a character who knew better. I've never gotten around to playing as one who attempts to rebel against the Prince even though I think about doing so every time I want to play the game now. Maybe next time...

Random stuff:

To this day, the Ocean House still gives me the creeps (even just thinking about it), and I've been there maybe a dozen or more times now. I love it; it's one of the scariest things in any video game or movie for me, and yet I know what happens. That place is absolute brilliance. The sewers and the warrens are pretty creepy as well, but no where near the Ocean House. The Ocean House, especially, allows the player's imagination to run wild with what one might expect to see but never comes. And it's that, right there, that makes it so grand.
Luxivus 2016 年 9 月 29 日 下午 9:39 
I'm pretty sure i read somewhere that the protagonist (you) is 8th generation.
dbithead 2019 年 6 月 20 日 下午 6:40 
引用自 Anderson
引用自 wesp5

Because we never find out at which point the Antedeluvian is replaced with a bomb either. In Turkey or at the Giovanni mansion? Or at the Elizabeth Dale?


I am surprised anyone mistakes Messerach for an Antedeluvian. Surely Messerach, while mighty and memorable, was a mortal as evidenced.
dwarfpcfan 2019 年 6 月 20 日 下午 6:57 
The protagonist is 8th generation, dominate in VTM had a rule that a character can only be dominated by someone of equal or better generation and that if someone attempting to dominate another critically failed (remember it's a tabletop game with dice) that person become immune to further attempts at dominate for a scene (an encounter if you will). The initial times, Lacroix succeeded his checks, on the last time he critically failed and you laughed in his place. given the situation there is nothing unusual about this as in the game, emotional state, past experience that a person has used dominate on the character before etc can give circumstantial bonuses to resist a new attempt at dominate

8th gen accounts for everything without any epileptic tress of speculation. He is the only one to try this, you can boost your stats up to 5 and you have a very big blood pool for a starting vamp. All accounted for.
Abstergo 2019 年 6 月 22 日 上午 5:04 

Because we never find out at which point the Antedeluvian is replaced with a bomb either. In Turkey or at the Giovanni mansion? Or at the Elizabeth Dale?

This will probably be explained in the Prelude to Bloodlines :)! [/quote]

Necroing this thread to ask:

WHAT PRELUDE?
:O :O
Anderson 2019 年 6 月 22 日 上午 8:01 
引用自 Abstergo
Because we never find out at which point the Antedeluvian is replaced with a bomb either. In Turkey or at the Giovanni mansion? Or at the Elizabeth Dale?

This will probably be explained in the Prelude to Bloodlines :)!
Necroing this thread to ask:

WHAT PRELUDE?
:O :O
Mod for Bloodlines. Google it.

引用自 dwarfpcfan
The protagonist is 8th generation, dominate in VTM had a rule that a character can only be dominated by someone of equal or better generation and that if someone attempting to dominate another critically failed (remember it's a tabletop game with dice) that person become immune to further attempts at dominate for a scene (an encounter if you will). The initial times, Lacroix succeeded his checks, on the last time he critically failed and you laughed in his place. given the situation there is nothing unusual about this as in the game, emotional state, past experience that a person has used dominate on the character before etc can give circumstantial bonuses to resist a new attempt at dominate

8th gen accounts for everything without any epileptic tress of speculation. He is the only one to try this, you can boost your stats up to 5 and you have a very big blood pool for a starting vamp. All accounted for.
The simple explanation is the most plainly divine!
最後修改者:Anderson; 2019 年 6 月 26 日 上午 8:50
Luxivus 2019 年 6 月 22 日 下午 3:23 
引用自 Anderson
引用自 Abstergo

This will probably be explained in the Prelude to Bloodlines :)!

Necroing this thread to ask:

WHAT PRELUDE?
:O :O
Mod for Bloodlines. Google it.

引用自 dwarfpcfan
The protagonist is 8th generation, dominate in VTM had a rule that a character can only be dominated by someone of equal or better generation and that if someone attempting to dominate another critically failed (remember it's a tabletop game with dice) that person become immune to further attempts at dominate for a scene (an encounter if you will). The initial times, Lacroix succeeded his checks, on the last time he critically failed and you laughed in his place. given the situation there is nothing unusual about this as in the game, emotional state, past experience that a person has used dominate on the character before etc can give circumstantial bonuses to resist a new attempt at dominate

8th gen accounts for everything without any epileptic tress of speculation. He is the only one to try this, you can boost your stats up to 5 and you have a very big blood pool for a starting vamp. All accounted for.
The simple explanation is the most plainly divine! [/quote]


引用自 Abstergo
Because we never find out at which point the Antedeluvian is replaced with a bomb either. In Turkey or at the Giovanni mansion? Or at the Elizabeth Dale?

This will probably be explained in the Prelude to Bloodlines :)!

Necroing this thread to ask:

WHAT PRELUDE?
:O :O [/quote]
Lol. All this simply because I asked what generation the player character was. That aside though, I am super hyped for the new bloodlines coming out, though I certainly hope a third person toggle will be implemented, for those who want to play first and those who don't, fingers crossed!
malvex_pavak17 2019 年 6 月 25 日 上午 3:45 
8th generation does make the most sense given that the player has a blood pool of 15, that said, we could have also developed the Iron Will merit that lets one spend will power to resist domination.

There is something else to take into account though, Andrei mentions that our blood smells more potent during the final confrontation with him. There is also an unused generation mechanic in the game files that kinda implies that it was planed for one to be able to change their generation. A solution that has been brought up before is that Caine gradually lowers our generation while also being the reason why we get so much xp during such a relatively short amount of time: Caine is playing a game, we are the pawn but we needed to be a powerful piece and so we were made to be powerful so long as we tried for it. (All the chess emails, our cab driver, the end scenes where both Caine and Jack watch Lacroix burn, the thin blooded oracle talking about smiling Jack, "Why is he smiling? Is it the father behind him?" and Jack sets up the sarcophagus and E mentions the oracle saying a Jack in the box coming out when you save Lily...)

From a lore stand point the player does way too many incredible things for a month old (guessing from how often one needs to feed Heather blood and the frequency one can get paid from Venus) Kindred: kill a powerful (at least) 7th gen Nagloper who knows Vicissitude 6 and is specced for combat as well as a Kuei-jin Ancestor who knows Demon Shintai and (perhaps on a lesser note as I don't know Andrei's rank, the wiki has him be an Archbishop but I take that with a grain of salt) a powerful Tzimisce that knows at least rank 5 Vicissitude (Zulo Shape) and likely also a Kuldon Sorcerer given the barrier of fire at King's Way along with a small army of Sabbat. For a fledgling/Neonate to do all of that at the end on top of everything else is... Yeah. And this assumes you ran from the werewolf instead of killing it which is also possible.

So, your generation is what Caine wishes it to be because you are touched by the hand of Caine.
最後修改者:malvex_pavak17; 2019 年 6 月 25 日 上午 3:52
Wesp5 2019 年 6 月 25 日 上午 4:04 
引用自 malvex_pavak17
So, your generation is what Caine wishes it to be because you are touched by the hand of Caine.

Good summary :)!
malvex_pavak17 2019 年 6 月 25 日 上午 6:13 
引用自 wesp5
引用自 malvex_pavak17
So, your generation is what Caine wishes it to be because you are touched by the hand of Caine.

Good summary :)!
Yeah, I mean we are better off than most vampires, but if Caine wasn't so horrifically powerful we should sue for harassment.
Luxivus 2019 年 6 月 25 日 上午 11:27 
They did leave it relatively vague whether the cab driver was caine or not, but, yeah, I have heard the theory that it was caine doing it all. How exactly would caine change our generation and empower us though, that doesn't make much sense to me. Yes he's first generation, but I don't ever recall anything saying he could psychically or just magickally make us lower generation or stronger. He didn't sire us, so, unless I'm missing something with him being able to just want us to be stronger and we get stronger, idk how that would work.
Unless ofcourse you are talking about us being directed to do difficult tasks to gain experience fast and take a crash-course on being a strong vamp through hard work rather than age
malvex_pavak17 2019 年 6 月 26 日 下午 10:37 
引用自 Mikha'el
They did leave it relatively vague whether the cab driver was caine or not, but, yeah, I have heard the theory that it was caine doing it all. How exactly would caine change our generation and empower us though, that doesn't make much sense to me. Yes he's first generation, but I don't ever recall anything saying he could psychically or just magickally make us lower generation or stronger. He didn't sire us, so, unless I'm missing something with him being able to just want us to be stronger and we get stronger, idk how that would work.
Unless ofcourse you are talking about us being directed to do difficult tasks to gain experience fast and take a crash-course on being a strong vamp through hard work rather than age
The whole generation thing? That is a curse from Caine. Originally vampires didn't have to worry about generation but then what would be known as the third gens killed the second gens so Caine felt he should spread the joy and cause each following generation be weaker than the last unless they devour the soul of their elder because this is the World of Darkness and we can't have nice things. If he doesn't want it to affect you it will not and if he wants it to partially affect you it will.

Also the Malkavian protagonist straight up calls the cabbie "The Dark Father" and starts screaming in fear upon realizing this.

I think, circa this era of meta plot (Oct 2004), Caine is in a cave somewhere in Turkey but his spirit is roaming about possessing people and doing things, so the cab driver may just be some poor guy being possessed. Take that with a grain of salt as, well, it is meta plot from 2004 and the time of Judgement (Gehenna and other end of the world stuff) happened soon afterward iirc all of which muddies the waters.
最後修改者:malvex_pavak17; 2019 年 6 月 26 日 下午 10:45
Luxivus 2019 年 6 月 27 日 上午 9:51 
Why do you think he's in a cave somewhere possessing people from afar? is that stated in an older edition's lore or something? I love ingame lore, so I love reading about this kinda stuff
Wesp5 2019 年 6 月 27 日 下午 12:42 
引用自 Mikha'el
Why do you think he's in a cave somewhere possessing people from afar? is that stated in an older edition's lore or something? I love ingame lore, so I love reading about this kinda stuff

This is described in the horrible Gehenna novel, but as this isn't canon anymore, we can all now guess what Caine was doing at the time :)!
< >
目前顯示第 31-45 則留言,共 72
每頁顯示: 1530 50

張貼日期: 2016 年 9 月 14 日 下午 12:46
回覆: 72