Baldur's Gate II: Enhanced Edition

Baldur's Gate II: Enhanced Edition

Visa statistik:
If we all agree that a Fighter/Mage is the most powerful class in the game then who is the 2nd most?
I think it's fairly universally accepted by now that Fighter/Mage's are in a league of their own.
But it seems that the 2nd best is often the most up for debate - and it's this debate that interests me most :)

EDIT: Guys - I think people are overanalyzing this WAY too much.
It's not orders of magnitude difference between a Fighter/Mage multiclass vs Berserker dualled to a Mage vs Wizard Slayer dualled to a Mage vs Kensai dualled to a Mage.
A FIghter/Mage is a FIghter/Mage.

A guy or gal who can wield axes and two-handed swords like Conan and cast spells. What could be more bada**?

My question is, what is #2 most bada**? Don't overthink and overanalyze ;P
Senast ändrad av gregorsamsa; 25 apr, 2023 @ 13:04
< >
Visar 16-30 av 71 kommentarer
2 maj, 2023 @ 17:24 
Fighter mage thief is the most powerful late game in my opinion. followed closely by fighter mage cleric. Of course they take longer to build their power and even more so in a party but I think the FMT becomes a better warrior than the rest around level 7/7/7. The moment you can use stoneskin, mirror image and blur with spirit armor while casting haste /slow and dual wielding, it's a no brainer. They do have a bit of a dip in thaco vs pure class fighters in Baldur's Gate 2 but it's nothing serious. By TOB they are using UAI with time stop traps and X5 backstabs at 10APR thanks to mislead and with critical strike it's capable of like 700 damage a round. Ridiculous, and they are fully protected by all the magical protections and can fall back on magical full plate at any time. If you want them to use the holy avenger it's no problem thanks to UAI but I find Crom Fayer and the +3 Nijato that only monks can use without UAI to be the best combo for 10APR with 25 strength thanks to CF. Nothing does more DPS than that combo.
Senast ändrad av ; 2 maj, 2023 @ 17:33
Zotliatlicor 2 maj, 2023 @ 22:40 
Years back i played through the whole Saga with a friend, we were playing a Fighter/Mage/Thief and a Fighter/Mage/Cleric. We totally ruled the game at every instance.

But i think i recall we used a Mod to uncap the 8 mill XP limit and something that extended the spell memorisation tables beyond 8 million. So we both got our lvl 9 spells. A good & fun memory.
Ursprungligen skrivet av gregorsamsa:

EDIT: Guys - I think people are overanalyzing this WAY too much.
It's not orders of magnitude difference between a Fighter/Mage multiclass vs Berserker dualled to a Mage vs Wizard Slayer dualled to a Mage vs Kensai dualled to a Mage.
A FIghter/Mage is a FIghter/Mage.

A guy or gal who can wield axes and two-handed swords like Conan and cast spells. What could be more bada**?

My question is, what is #2 most bada**? Don't overthink and overanalyze ;P
Well, since in the last almost 25 year noone referred to a dual character as F/M it was an hard guess for anyone :P.

Multi and dualled are not so similar, due to different HLA and progression.

So answering to your question. Berserker --> thief or fighter / thief (I prefer the first).
gregorsamsa 3 maj, 2023 @ 1:15 
Ursprungligen skrivet av stef.corsi:
Ursprungligen skrivet av gregorsamsa:

EDIT: Guys - I think people are overanalyzing this WAY too much.
It's not orders of magnitude difference between a Fighter/Mage multiclass vs Berserker dualled to a Mage vs Wizard Slayer dualled to a Mage vs Kensai dualled to a Mage.
A FIghter/Mage is a FIghter/Mage.

A guy or gal who can wield axes and two-handed swords like Conan and cast spells. What could be more bada**?

My question is, what is #2 most bada**? Don't overthink and overanalyze ;P
Well, since in the last almost 25 year noone referred to a dual character as F/M it was an hard guess for anyone :P.

Multi and dualled are not so similar, due to different HLA and progression.

So answering to your question. Berserker --> thief or fighter / thief (I prefer the first).

I don’t mean to say that all fighter/mages are the same, but if we get too pedantic and ask which classes are the best, the entire dialogue is going to be dominated and debated with lists like

1. Berserker level 9> Mage
2. Berserker level 13> Mage
3. Kensai 9> Mage
4. Kensai 13>Mage
5. Berserker level 7>Mage
6. Kensai level 7>Mage
7. Fighter/Mage Elf
8. Fighter/Mage Half-Elf
9. Fighter/Mage Human
10. Wizard slayer 9>mage

You see where I’m going?

No offense, but I don’t give two quips about which variation of a character who is a fighter and a mage is the best.

I want to know which is the second best.

Druid?
Sorcerer?
Fighter/Thief?
Paladin?

I really really really don’t care to differentiate a multi or dual class. The difference between a fighter dualled to mage and a fighter/mage multi is not as big as a fighter/mage mutli vs a sun soul monk.
red255 3 maj, 2023 @ 7:13 
Ursprungligen skrivet av :
Fighter mage thief is the most powerful late game in my opinion. .

If we are soloing and remove the level cap.

but if you don't you don't even reach 9th level spells
Ursprungligen skrivet av gregorsamsa:
I don’t mean to say that all fighter/mages are the same, but if we get too pedantic and ask which classes are the best, the entire dialogue is going to be dominated and debated with lists like

1. Berserker level 9> Mage
2. Berserker level 13> Mage
3. Kensai 9> Mage
4. Kensai 13>Mage
5. Berserker level 7>Mage
6. Kensai level 7>Mage
7. Fighter/Mage Elf
8. Fighter/Mage Half-Elf
9. Fighter/Mage Human
10. Wizard slayer 9>mage

You see where I’m going?

No offense, but I don’t give two quips about which variation of a character who is a fighter and a mage is the best.

I want to know which is the second best.

Druid?
Sorcerer?
Fighter/Thief?
Paladin?

I really really really don’t care to differentiate a multi or dual class. The difference between a fighter dualled to mage and a fighter/mage multi is not as big as a fighter/mage mutli vs a sun soul monk.
Who's pedantic now? :-)
You were joking, I was joking, why immediately you get it so seriously?
Anyway I answered to your question, why do you want to argue about something that I didn't argue about?
No one was pedantic, your first question wasn't clear, For me multi and a dualled are quite different in playing style and game experience, while the different variation of a dualled character (or of a multi) are quite similar (if in the same order, because a mage-->fighter or a fighter---> mage are not similar at all). I couldn't know they were the same for you. You have made it clear now, let's move on.

I said fighter/thief or berserker--> thief in my opinion in an overall game experience in a group play. But the answer can be different depending on what you mean for most powerful.
Senast ändrad av Wicket W. Warrick; 3 maj, 2023 @ 11:08
red255 3 maj, 2023 @ 10:53 
I've always found fighter/thief to be my favorite because I love having a high level thief in the party.

event did swash ->Fighter once, and still had fun
Senast ändrad av red255; 3 maj, 2023 @ 10:53
Iso Koala 3 maj, 2023 @ 14:54 
Ursprungligen skrivet av gregorsamsa:
Ursprungligen skrivet av Iso Koala:
I dont count anything that is OP at the middle of ToB as OP. A build that requires "use any item" isnt OP 90% of the game, and at that point anyone is anyway.

But fighter/mages are solid already in lvls 3/3 early in BG1, or kensai or berserker mages early in BG2.

I dont like druid builds for their ridiculous exp table.

FIghter/mage/thief would be strong for solo, especially if you dont remember all the games traps.

Except that the question wasn't "which build is OP." The question was, which build is #2, second only to a fighter/mage
Yes, I know.
I just said, that I dont consider a build that is godly in middle of ToB a powerful class. It has just high end game numbers, but 90% of the game just avarage, which matters more. A class that relies on "use any item" is not the second best if thats the idea to make strong class.
Fighter/Mage is great because it works all BG1, 2, and ToB without long waiting to become useful. Even at 1/1 levels he has some protective magic and can hold any weapon while buffing.

I would prooobably say fighter/cleric as the 2nd best. Good offensive, good defensive, good support for the whole team. Fights like a warrior, but can also buff himself, add blade barriers, protections, and heal.

Fighter/mage/thief and fighter/mage/cleric are obviously super good too, but with party of 6, they are lacking in exp.

Sorcerer is strongest solo, but requires a lot of micromanagement, and for the whole series playthrough, he is weak quite long, and relies on others unless you know well what to do and buy.


Fighter/mage + cleric/thief duo would conquer everything as a super duo :).
Ellbekarym 5 maj, 2023 @ 17:31 
The very holy and very truthful Davaeorn has made a 4.5 hour video where he gives us his wisdom on this subject. And the truth is: the strongest class is Berserker dual to Mage (significantly stronger than a mere fighter/mage) and the second strongest class ( hence better than fighter/mage) is Wild Mage. Amen.
red255 5 maj, 2023 @ 19:31 
I mean a class where you can potentially cast level 9 spells with a level 1 spell with the power of save and load, is technically powerful on paper.

Not sure where I'm going with this.

i Do Agree that a beserker dualed to mage is better than the Kensai dualled to mage that someone made popular at some point at time, so at least thats done with.

I'm going to define the 'most powerful class' as a class that can deal with the unmodded game lets say on Core rules with the least amount of saving and loading. (aggravation)

if there are multiple classes that are tied with these restrictions we can start shifting the difficulty up.

this would throw out Classes like the wild mage which cause basically a game over from casting spells so save often.

Now I know this doesn't exactly make a fair definition of the word 'powerful' but this is adding a bias.

secondly Classes have a support function, and the game allows 6 party members and 5 summons and I think 8 traps?

So really the question becomes 'what is the best class to beat the game with the least amount of saving and loading on core difficulty with up to a full party and summons. of your choice.
gregorsamsa 5 maj, 2023 @ 22:41 
Ursprungligen skrivet av Ellbekarym:
The very holy and very truthful Davaeorn has made a 4.5 hour video where he gives us his wisdom on this subject. And the truth is: the strongest class is Berserker dual to Mage (significantly stronger than a mere fighter/mage) and the second strongest class ( hence better than fighter/mage) is Wild Mage. Amen.

I tried a Wild Mage and it was exceedingly frustrating.
First and foremost with all the saving and reloading.

Secondly, with all the spell failure. People tell you "oh well not all the results are summoning a demon or losing all your gold." "You can live with certain outcomes."

Yes - that is very true. I can live with berries or gems in my pocket, or even swirly colors, but if this is what I get when I'm trying to cast my only Stoneskin or when I'm about to use Breach on a powerful wizard, then the level of frustration goes through the roof for me - I don't know about you guys.

Believe me - you are going to need those extra spell slots because your spells are going to fail to cast.

I tried playing as a monk, and it was extremely frustrating for me, but nothing made me want to quit playing this game altogether like a Wild Mage.
Ellbekarym 5 maj, 2023 @ 23:26 
Ursprungligen skrivet av gregorsamsa:
Ursprungligen skrivet av Ellbekarym:
The very holy and very truthful Davaeorn has made a 4.5 hour video where he gives us his wisdom on this subject. And the truth is: the strongest class is Berserker dual to Mage (significantly stronger than a mere fighter/mage) and the second strongest class ( hence better than fighter/mage) is Wild Mage. Amen.

I tried a Wild Mage and it was exceedingly frustrating.
First and foremost with all the saving and reloading.

Secondly, with all the spell failure. People tell you "oh well not all the results are summoning a demon or losing all your gold." "You can live with certain outcomes."

Yes - that is very true. I can live with berries or gems in my pocket, or even swirly colors, but if this is what I get when I'm trying to cast my only Stoneskin or when I'm about to use Breach on a powerful wizard, then the level of frustration goes through the roof for me - I don't know about you guys.

Believe me - you are going to need those extra spell slots because your spells are going to fail to cast.

I tried playing as a monk, and it was extremely frustrating for me, but nothing made me want to quit playing this game altogether like a Wild Mage.

Wild surges don't happen that often (1 in 20) but yes a Wild Mage is not stronger than a mage (which is already very strong) at low level. But once you can cast Improved Chaos Shield this class becomes absolutely monstrous. You can cast level 9 spells under Improved Alacrity with level 1 slots. The only thing that prevents you from reducing the whole game to radioactive steam is that the ring that doubles the number of level 1 spells is not present in BG2.
Zotliatlicor 6 maj, 2023 @ 9:17 
Or you could have that one with you from BG1, could you not?
How many spells do you cast in a playthrough? ANd during a fight?
They cause litteraly hundreds or thousands of wild surges.

The all point is an old (not only in RPG) debate about what most powerful means. Max the profits or minimize the risk?
The point in the confrontation is: when exactly this gives a real advantage in term of the chances to win a fight? Because the risk of a wild surge is always present, while the real advantage no. In most of the game a single 9th level spell is sufficient to win the fight, expecially when you get HLA, so having tons of them is useful but not mandatory. The risk of failure asks you to prepare strategies that works without the wild mage for most of the fights, so the risk is leaving him/her without doing nothing for most of the game and using only on though fights.

Also a sorcerer ends up with tons of spells, but with no wild surge.

If this frustration is more ore less than the advantages is an opioni that can be different for everyone.
Zotliatlicor 7 maj, 2023 @ 2:57 
This Daeveron fellow, i follow him on YT, and have watched him in action. Yes he claims that a well built Wild Mage is incredible powerful, BUT:

He plays on Permadeath, No Reload, with Insane Ascensinon an SCS installed. On that difficulty i would never even consider a Wild Mage. He has been challenged to play a Wild Mage more than once, and sometimes (quite often) they end in Death: New Game.

Wild Mage is for the reload Quicksave games, and referably no higher than Core difficulty. Even then, doing a big preparation before a big fight, only to have Neera mess up the whole thing, well...that is not for me.

And Wild Mage "need" to reach a certain high level to even try to function properly. Before lvl 14 they are just a tag-along sling/dart user with occasional spells.

I agree With Daeveron on Berserker-dual-Mage is THE most powerful thing you can build for 'CHARNAME', but the 2nd most is actually difficult to answer. I landed on Kensai-dual-Thief, but the most fair would be it is tied between several good ones. Berserker-Cleric is also a Powerhouse, and so is even the MC Ranger/Cleric.

My self-made Cleric/Illusionist, my Blade Bard, my Archer, also all became insanely powerful characters. Becausee i Meta-Game them.

Sorcerors, well they need no further Explanantion.

I did a FMT with a small mod that removed the XP cap. Very fun, doing most alone with all the NPC's tagging along for personal quests. No until TOB did i assemble a party.
Senast ändrad av Zotliatlicor; 7 maj, 2023 @ 2:59
< >
Visar 16-30 av 71 kommentarer
Per sida: 1530 50

Datum skrivet: 24 apr, 2023 @ 14:28
Inlägg: 71