Did Mel crush her baby when climbing that cage fence?

[boRZ]

really thought she was going to boost Abby up first before that.

Any surgeons in here know whether scraping your baby while you are trying to climb squashes said baby??

[cha0tic]

The thing about Mel is that for such a smart person she made a lot of dumb decisions because she was always worried that Owen and Abby would hit it off again behind her back.

[boRZ]

her eyes will haunt me more than anything I seen in the game

[PONPOKO]

Ellie kills the baby.

[Bͥatͣmͫan]

Originally posted by PONPOKO:

Ellie kills the baby.

Wrong
the mother killed herself & the baby
by going outside the base while being pregnant!

she did it to herself!

[PONPOKO]

Originally posted by Bͥatͣmͫan:

Originally posted by PONPOKO:

Ellie kills the baby.

Wrong
the mother killed herself & the baby
by going outside the base while being pregnant!

she did it to herself!

Joel did it to himself by killing Abby's dad. Same logic.

[Bͥatͣmͫan]

Originally posted by PONPOKO:

Originally posted by Bͥatͣmͫan:

Wrong
the mother killed herself & the baby
by going outside the base while being pregnant!

she did it to herself!

Joel did it to himself by killing Abby's dad.

Joel did it to save an innocent little girl
something he couldn't prevent sadly from his own daughter
but he had a choice now to save Ellie & so he did!

Joel did the right thing

getting pregnant very pregnant, this ain't earlie on or anything.
And still choose to go on missions risking the baby's life and your own
is what got her killed!

She would have been a terrible mother anyway so
this was the best outcome!

Ellie you did nothing wrong!

[Nox]

Originally posted by PONPOKO:

Originally posted by Bͥatͣmͫan:

Wrong
the mother killed herself & the baby
by going outside the base while being pregnant!

she did it to herself!

Joel did it to himself by killing Abby's dad. Same logic.

Abby's dad and Marlene never gave Ellie the choice about the surgery that would kill her.
They took her after she almost drowned and started prepping her without a second thought and then straight up threatened Joel at gunpoint.

[Bͥatͣmͫan]

Originally posted by Nox:

Originally posted by PONPOKO:

Joel did it to himself by killing Abby's dad. Same logic.

Abby's dad and Marlene never gave Ellie the choice to go through the surgery that would kill her.

They took her after she almost drowned and started prepping her without a second thought and then straight up threatened Joel at gunpoint.

Mic

[cha0tic]

Originally posted by Nox:

Originally posted by PONPOKO:

Joel did it to himself by killing Abby's dad. Same logic.

Abby's dad and Marlene never gave Ellie the choice about the surgery that would kill her.
They took her after she almost drowned and started prepping her without a second thought and then straight up threatened Joel at gunpoint.

Then it turns out that's exactly what Ellie wanted and is exactly the reason they were on bad terms. Pay attention Mark

[PONPOKO]

Originally posted by Nox:

Originally posted by PONPOKO:

Joel did it to himself by killing Abby's dad. Same logic.

Abby's dad and Marlene never gave Ellie the choice to go through the surgery that would kill her.

They took her after she almost drowned and started prepping her without a second thought and then straight up threatened Joel at gunpoint.

I didn't say Joel did anything wrong. I just applied the same absurd logic to a different situation.

[Bͥatͣmͫan]

Originally posted by cha0tic:

Originally posted by Nox:

Abby's dad and Marlene never gave Ellie the choice about the surgery that would kill her.
They took her after she almost drowned and started prepping her without a second thought and then straight up threatened Joel at gunpoint.

Then it turns out that's exactly what Ellie wanted and is exactly the reason they were on bad terms. Pay attention Mark

She don't get to make that choice not when Joel is around
he is not losing another daughter!

[Hundinger]

Originally posted by Bͥatͣmͫan:

Originally posted by PONPOKO:

Joel did it to himself by killing Abby's dad.

Joel did it to save an innocent little girl
something he couldn't prevent sadly from his own daughter
but he had a choice now to save Ellie & so he did!

Joel did the right thing

getting pregnant very pregnant, this ain't earlie on or anything.
And still choose to go on missions risking the baby's life and your own
is what got her killed!

She would have been a terrible mother anyway so
this was the best outcome!

Ellie you did nothing wrong!

Idiotic take. Making stupid decisions and taking unnecessary risks doesn't give someone else a carte blanche to murder you. It's still murder.

[mark1971]

I found it hair-raising, to watch her climb and taking an obstacle with her belly first. Doing this in reality wouldn't be healthy at all. It's like an injury for the unborn child.

That's the only thing that bothers me on Part II.

[Bͥatͣmͫan]

But with Joel dead.

Ellie can go & end herself for all i care
she let AbbySmash go so shes just as bad!


If they ever do a the last of us part 3 make it about Tommy kill Abby & let Ellie die in the end

Make Tommy the soul survivor
that's how you make a perfect 3rd game!

perfect ending, Tommy gets the 9 iron and bashes her head in!
and rides into the sunset!

[Fiestaodin]

Mel is the stupids charakter in the game. A pregnant woman and a doctor in endtime leaves the safe base for what? Doctors a precious in endtimes. Its like Alien Prometheus with the stupid "science" persons.