Tales of Graces f Remastered

Tales of Graces f Remastered

View Stats:
Feels like a very weak Tales of entry
After playing Tales of games like Berseria, Arise, Vesperia, Symphonia, Abyss this game feels half assed and boring, and too bare bones. I love the series and played like 15 of them in total and this is one of the weakest in the series in my opinion.

What are your thoughts?
< >
Showing 1-15 of 34 comments
Saibot Feb 19 @ 1:12pm 
My thought is, that your taste is... crap different.

Tales of Arise was beyond trash. The only thing that carried Arise was A) the visual improvements and B) Kisaras Ass. That thing was beyond beautiful.

Arise had Sponge enemies, not a single dungeon gimmick and everything could be skipped with a lot of CR or whatever the thing was called to destroy barriers, the story is beyond shallow with the: "OHH I HAVE TO FORGIVE EVERYTHING AND EVERYONE" and 99% of the skits are trash as well. They all are the same with the typical:

Shionne: *SIGH*
*nobody reacts*
Shionne: *BIGGER_SIGH*
Group: "Hey, whats up Shionne?"
Shionne: "It's none of your business"

THEN WHY DO YOU OPEN YOUR MOUTH!? The final dungeon is just a mini boss rush and higher difficulty only leads to enemies having more HP. Enemy variety? Non-existent. You have 20 enemies in total and they only change color patterns throughout the areas.
Oh and the best thing: It recieved an expansion that expanded NOTHING. NOT A SINGLE NEW AREA!!! Have you ever heard of an expansion that expands nothing? You get two new dungeons, much wow lol

Tales of Arise was beyond trash so saying that this abomination was better than Graces F? Yeah.. I think your taste is flawed.

Symphonia had better dungeon gimmicks, but both stories (Collete and journey of salvation and her love for Lloyd or Cheria and Asbels weird relationship) are quite identical in terms of cliché.

Does it have the best story? No. Does it have good gameplay? Yeah. You can play around with a lot of things. I also like the story. The only thing I disliked is that bosses receive super armor sometimes and destroy your combo and the difficulty spike of some bosses is weird. Everything else was fine.

TL;DR: Tales of Arise deserves a place in the trash bin
Saibot Feb 19 @ 1:16pm 
Also... Graces came out in 2009 and Berseria in 2016.
It had 7 more years to get better stuff so comparing later entries to previous entries is... kind of weird to begin with.
I love the game, the story and the gameplay and it gave me a beautiful time.

But if you didn't like it thats fine. Everyone's taste is different, hence why I personally love Tales of Symphonia - its my all time favorite. Nothing beats it, but objectively... a lot of entries beat it lol.
Not in my pink world though, I love Symphonia to death. Thats how different taste works and without different people like you we would only have the same thing so its all good :)

Sometimes you hit stuff and sometimes you get misses. Thats what life is all about
I've not finished the game yet, but for my two cents on the experience so far:

Narratively, I agree with you.
Gameplay, I don't.

Narratively the game is extremely "video gamey" by which I mean everyone's relationships, area availability and plot progression is entirely "we need this area to be this or that character to feel this because reasons". So even though I like some of the things the game sets up or some of the character relationships...you can see how flimsy it all is. Case in point: at the beginning of the game you form a friendship pact with a character and it's played as a really meaningful moment. Not long after the time skip happens and apparently at no point in those seven years did either character try to talk to each other...despite being in the same city. All so you could have a big reunion moment the story demanded. Or how about how the story has a moment where an important lord bans you from talking to the sovereign and wants to put you in prison for disagreeing, and then he helps lead an attack on a town you try to defend. Only, the next time you can talk to this guy he's totally happy to see you and says something like "good timing, I need help with this quest". Like buddy what? We were just on opposite sides of a civil war?!?

Gameplay speaks for itself. I'm not sold on it being "best in the series" but it's quite enjoyable with some decent challenge that rewards some skill expression. Definitely a stronger entry in the series from the games I've played.
Razer Feb 19 @ 7:10pm 
Graces is one of the better Tales games. Arise is by FAR the worst entry. Which is a shame. Berseria is alright. It's kind of poor in terms of story, even with the great premise and prologue it just quickly goes down hill.
Gamrage Feb 20 @ 9:29pm 
Honestly, I cant agree with this. Graces is one of the more mechanically developed out of the "Tales of" franchise. Zesteria, Vesperia, and Arise took some mechanics from this game's 3D combat, but I feel like this game still does it better than the sum.

My reasoning is that the games aforementioned punished players for playing defensively and often had major faults either with the combat or general mechanics. ESPECIALLY ARISE WITH THEIR DAMAGE CHECK BOSSES.. The bosses in this game give CLEAR indication when their guard is broken, when they have super armor, and the game rewards you for playing to your own specific playstyle, be it offensive of defensive.
Gamrage Feb 20 @ 9:31pm 
Originally posted by Azulmagia88:
I wouldn't say it is a weak tales game but more like a tales game in its purest form with excellent combat.
Also arise is garbage.
Yes. Arise is GARBAGE!!
It's only popular because most people don't know how good the previous games are.
Gamrage Feb 20 @ 9:34pm 
Originally posted by Saibot:
My thought is, that your taste is... crap different.

Tales of Arise was beyond trash. The only thing that carried Arise was A) the visual improvements and B) Kisaras Ass. That thing was beyond beautiful.

Arise had Sponge enemies, not a single dungeon gimmick and everything could be skipped with a lot of CR or whatever the thing was called to destroy barriers, the story is beyond shallow with the: "OHH I HAVE TO FORGIVE EVERYTHING AND EVERYONE" and 99% of the skits are trash as well. They all are the same with the typical:

Shionne: *SIGH*
*nobody reacts*
Shionne: *BIGGER_SIGH*
Group: "Hey, whats up Shionne?"
Shionne: "It's none of your business"

THEN WHY DO YOU OPEN YOUR MOUTH!? The final dungeon is just a mini boss rush and higher difficulty only leads to enemies having more HP. Enemy variety? Non-existent. You have 20 enemies in total and they only change color patterns throughout the areas.
Oh and the best thing: It recieved an expansion that expanded NOTHING. NOT A SINGLE NEW AREA!!! Have you ever heard of an expansion that expands nothing? You get two new dungeons, much wow lol

Tales of Arise was beyond trash so saying that this abomination was better than Graces F? Yeah.. I think your taste is flawed.

Symphonia had better dungeon gimmicks, but both stories (Collete and journey of salvation and her love for Lloyd or Cheria and Asbels weird relationship) are quite identical in terms of cliché.

Does it have the best story? No. Does it have good gameplay? Yeah. You can play around with a lot of things. I also like the story. The only thing I disliked is that bosses receive super armor sometimes and destroy your combo and the difficulty spike of some bosses is weird. Everything else was fine.

TL;DR: Tales of Arise deserves a place in the trash bin
You are a TRUE "Tales of" fan.
I hadn't realized that Arise had that much hate around it in the Graces community. I personally found the game quite fun and liked the feel of the combat. I'll reserve judgement on whether it's better or worse than Graces until after I've finished this game though.
Originally posted by Seisachtheia:
I hadn't realized that Arise had that much hate around it in the Graces community. I personally found the game quite fun and liked the feel of the combat. I'll reserve judgement on whether it's better or worse than Graces until after I've finished this game though.
My 2 cents: Arise started fine, but around the 40~60% of story mark, it starts to go downhill in quality. That is, when whats his name Edgy Sephiroth Wannabe gains plot relevance.

Party members start becoming more and more one-note, and skits start becoming more and more of "oh hey, party member, what do you think about the most recent story scene?" which they respond to in their one-note way. There is less of what could be called character interaction, and more like they were just bots giving pre-set responses.

In fact, the last 3~ areas/dungeons of Arise are absolutely bloated with skits of that above nature. "Party Member, what do you think about the recent story scene?" being repeated with each member, it was funny how repeated it is originally, and then it keeps being repeated and loses the comedic value... and keeps being repeated, more and more and...

Tales series character interaction and banter is usually a strong point (or at least, not a negative), but Arise is likely the weakest of the games in a looooong time... I think Arise might be the first game in the series (that I know of anyway) where I could safely skip a meaningful % of skits, due to already knowing exactly what they'll be about, because there is seemingly no effort in having the cast talk about anything other than the most recent events.
From what I heard, the story itself is just average, but the gameplay is one of the best. I can't say anything about the story yet, but I'm enjoying my playthrough so far.
Haiyaaaa Feb 22 @ 9:39am 
Originally posted by Saibot:
Also... Graces came out in 2009 and Berseria in 2016.
It had 7 more years to get better stuff so comparing later entries to previous entries is... kind of weird to begin with.
I love the game, the story and the gameplay and it gave me a beautiful time.

But if you didn't like it thats fine. Everyone's taste is different, hence why I personally love Tales of Symphonia - its my all time favorite. Nothing beats it, but objectively... a lot of entries beat it lol.
Not in my pink world though, I love Symphonia to death. Thats how different taste works and without different people like you we would only have the same thing so its all good :)

Sometimes you hit stuff and sometimes you get misses. Thats what life is all about

Saying Arise is trash but his favorite is Symphonia. LMAO Nostalgia really blind peoples so much and reduce their IQ to room temperature as well. :steamhappy:
Saibot Feb 22 @ 9:48am 
Originally posted by Haiyaaaa:
Originally posted by Saibot:
Also... Graces came out in 2009 and Berseria in 2016.
It had 7 more years to get better stuff so comparing later entries to previous entries is... kind of weird to begin with.
I love the game, the story and the gameplay and it gave me a beautiful time.

But if you didn't like it thats fine. Everyone's taste is different, hence why I personally love Tales of Symphonia - its my all time favorite. Nothing beats it, but objectively... a lot of entries beat it lol.
Not in my pink world though, I love Symphonia to death. Thats how different taste works and without different people like you we would only have the same thing so its all good :)

Sometimes you hit stuff and sometimes you get misses. Thats what life is all about

Saying Arise is trash but his favorite is Symphonia. LMAO Nostalgia really blind peoples so much and reduce their IQ to room temperature as well. :steamhappy:

No its called different taste. Even after all these years Symphonia had beautiful and diverse dungeon gimmicks with the Mana Ring.
You can say and insult me however you want, but that is not purely driven by Nostalgia. Instead of insulting other people over different opinions on the Steam forum I would recommend to pull some metal and do something for yourself instead of wasting your time playing keyboard warrior online.
Last edited by Saibot; Feb 22 @ 9:49am
I found this game pretty disappointing too, although I found arise disappointing as well
Tales is one of those fun series I guess where everyone has different opinions.
For me, I never understood the hype for Tales of Berseria, I found everything about it unappealing, so things like combat, world design, dungeons, story and characters.

I wonder why all of us agree on Vesperia though. What is it about this entry that everyone agrees on? Never met anyone who thinks Vesperia is not a Top 3 Tales game at least.
Last edited by Elbs Final One; Feb 22 @ 10:06pm
Seisachtheia Feb 23 @ 12:21am 
Originally posted by ElbsFinalOne:
Tales is one of those fun series I guess where everyone has different opinions.
For me, I never understood the hype for Tales of Berseria, I found everything about it unappealing, so things like combat, world design, dungeons, story and characters.

I wonder why all of us agree on Vesperia though. What is it about this entry that everyone agrees on? Never met anyone who thinks Vesperia is not a Top 3 Tales game at least.

Yo it's me. I'm one of those people. Though I think what makes Vesperia so good for most people is the cast. Really like that cast, and I personally think Yuri is maybe the best protagonist in any Tales game, very refreshing to have a character that feels like he has a lot of agency and the plot isn't just "happening" to...not to mention it's nice to play as a mentor instead of a mentee. Lots of these games put you in the shoes of the young know-nothing, but Yuri's his own man and is very clearly the leader.

I don't care for Vesperia's combat though. I find it awkward, clunky, and takes nearly a full playthrough to eventually become good. I think Graces is far superior and everything they tried, and failed, to do in Vesperia they succeeded with in Graces. But I get that's not the majority opinion.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 34 comments
Per page: 1530 50