Completion marks are wrong?

[Lockdown]

Seriously this is so frustrating. Going for specific achievements and my completion marks are wrong. It tells me I haven't beat Satan with certain characters even though I did months ago. Is there anyway to fix this? As far as I know all my completion marks are incorrect - some stuff I did isn't reflected on there so I'm wasting all this time achieving goals I've already attained.

Help

[Nazemec]

Common explanation: you got revived as another character.
Let's say you played as Eve and found Ankh. You get killed and revived as Blue Baby (thanks to Ankh). Any boss you kill afterwards will be considered as a Blue Baby kill, so you'll get Blue Baby marks and items (and not Eve's).

Things which respawns you as other characters:
Ankh and Broken Ankh, as Blue Baby (also known as ???).
Lazarus' Rags, as Lazarus (second life).
Judas' Shadow, as Black Judas (considered as Judas).
Missing Poster, as the Lost (if you have Afterbirth).


If you don't find here any clue to explain what you experience, be more specific. Which marks for which characters precisely?

[Manbarondenna]

Originally posted by Nazemec:

Common explanation: you got revived as another character.
Let's say you played as Eve and found Ankh. You get killed and revived as Blue Baby (thanks to Ankh). Any boss you kill afterwards will be considered as a Blue Baby kill, so you'll get Blue Baby marks and items (and not Eve's).

Things which respawns you as other characters:
Ankh and Broken Ankh, as Blue Baby (also known as ???).
Lazarus' Rags, as Lazarus (second life).
Judas' Shadow, as Black Judas (considered as Judas).
Missing Poster, as the Lost (if you have Afterbirth).


If you don't find here any clue to explain what you experience, be more specific. Which marks for which characters precisely?

Nah, dude, I have killed mega satan as judas, samson and eden a long time ago, when there was no mark for the mega satan. Now there is, and Ive beaten MS with isaac and got the mark, while there was no marks for previously mentioned characters.

[Nazemec]

Originally posted by Manbarondenna:

Originally posted by Nazemec:

Common explanation: you got revived as another character.
Let's say you played as Eve and found Ankh. You get killed and revived as Blue Baby (thanks to Ankh). Any boss you kill afterwards will be considered as a Blue Baby kill, so you'll get Blue Baby marks and items (and not Eve's).

Things which respawns you as other characters:
Ankh and Broken Ankh, as Blue Baby (also known as ???).
Lazarus' Rags, as Lazarus (second life).
Judas' Shadow, as Black Judas (considered as Judas).
Missing Poster, as the Lost (if you have Afterbirth).


If you don't find here any clue to explain what you experience, be more specific. Which marks for which characters precisely?

Nah, dude, I have killed mega satan as judas, samson and eden a long time ago, when there was no mark for the mega satan. Now there is, and Ive beaten MS with isaac and got the mark, while there was no marks for previously mentioned characters.

Mega Satan kills were not recorded in Rebirth, at all. The only thing saved was the corresponding ending (which means you only had to kill him once). That's why the mark isn't there in Afterbirth, because there's nothing in the Rebirth save for that. ;-)

[Manbarondenna]

Originally posted by Nazemec:

Originally posted by Manbarondenna:

Nah, dude, I have killed mega satan as judas, samson and eden a long time ago, when there was no mark for the mega satan. Now there is, and Ive beaten MS with isaac and got the mark, while there was no marks for previously mentioned characters.

Mega Satan kills were not recorded in Rebirth, at all. The only thing saved was the corresponding ending (which means you only had to kill him once). That's why the mark isn't there in Afterbirth, because there's nothing in the Rebirth save for that. ;-)

well yeah, thats specific

[Lockdown]

Originally posted by Nazemec:

Common explanation: you got revived as another character.
Let's say you played as Eve and found Ankh. You get killed and revived as Blue Baby (thanks to Ankh). Any boss you kill afterwards will be considered as a Blue Baby kill, so you'll get Blue Baby marks and items (and not Eve's).

Things which respawns you as other characters:
Ankh and Broken Ankh, as Blue Baby (also known as ???).
Lazarus' Rags, as Lazarus (second life).
Judas' Shadow, as Black Judas (considered as Judas).
Missing Poster, as the Lost (if you have Afterbirth).


If you don't find here any clue to explain what you experience, be more specific. Which marks for which characters precisely?

One for example, it tells me I haven't beaten Satan with Isaac but I have Mom's Knife achievement unlocked. Very annoying. You would hope and trust that the system would reflect things accurately.

I still don't understand your explanation. How do I unlock an achievement with Isaac and it doesn't trigger the mark?

[CheddarExuberant]

Originally posted by Lockdown:

One for example, it tells me I haven't beaten Satan with Isaac but I have Mom's Knife achievement unlocked. Very annoying. You would hope and trust that the system would reflect things accurately.

I still don't understand your explanation. How do I unlock an achievement with Isaac and it doesn't trigger the mark?

Did you play Rebirth before getting Afterbirth? In Afterbirth there is/was a glitch where completion marks on imported Rebirth files got all screwed up and didn't transfer.