Should they start a Gothic 4 Remake ?

[REY]

I was very disappointed of Gothic 4, they did great work on the previous Titels and i personaly loved them but that was a realy bad ending for the Story in my Opinion. So my Question is why they dont learn from those misstakes and put out a new Version on the Market, a Remake would be awesome i think!

by the way im streaming Risen 3 - Titan Lords so when you want join mey ;)
It would be a pleasure !! http://www.twitch.tv/reytv

[naomha]

Gothic 5 is supposedly in the works. So, umm, no.

[EN16M471C]

naomha původně napsal:

Gothic 5 is supposedly in the works. So, umm, no.

Great! If your source is valid.
Buut yeah. Don't know about G4 remake, wouldn't make much sense since the game is not that old. However Gothic 1,2,3 remake would be awsome. Although considering how PB is small-ish studio I doubt that will happen.

[pw1108]

I don't think they should make Gothic.
because Gothic is end and it's plot connected to Risen.
God forsaked the world and humanity is risen again and what's next?
maybe struggle between human?

[Sparhawk122]

Why not. As long as it's a whole new storyline.

[Carver]

Honestly I could dig an RTS with RPG elements that focuses on the war against the orcs instead.

[Smaloki]

You do know that Gothic 4 was made by a completely different dev studio, right? So it's highly unlikely that Piranha Bytes would remake that game. If anything, they'd make a whole new game in the Gothic universe.

Anyway, while Piranha Bytes have regained the rights to the Gothic series, they might still continue Risen. The Gothic franchise lost a lot of prestige after the release of Gothic 3. And Gothic 4 might have been the final nail in the coffin (then again... most fans of the old series know that the fourth one was made by a different company; if PB would make a new Gothic game it could still sell very well).
In the end, it's probably up to their publisher.

[pw1108]

It might not be offcial, but I think Risen and Gothic are connected with lore.
At Gothic 3, there are three choices: Innos, Beliar or let them forsake world.
at Gothi..eh... Arcania, they choosed Innos ending.
that's the reason why Nameless hero was king in Arcania.
but at Risen, at the very first part of game, they refer G3's Xardas' ending: the mage who want to make human free make gods forsked the world.
so PB forsaked Goth.. Arcania.

so, I don't think there would be Gothic 5.
but I'm sure they will continue Gothic+Risen saga with new franchise or with old franchise.
but there might be one part or lore that can be good motivate for Gothic 5: last king and inquisition.

Forsaken god? they didn't understand meaning of returning of NH and Xardas.
it's meaningless trash.

[Stonechat]

Gothic 4 doesn't exist. ArcaniA no longer has the title of "Gothic"

[0pp0]

There is no Gothic 4. They can't remake a game that doesn't exist (yet)

[tracksone]

I know that you people are raging mad about it, but arcania was made as gothic 4, what came after that is irrelevant and it still has to be acknowledged. Wheter that makes you mad or not.

[1984]

Arcania wasn't even titled as Gothic 4. It was called ArcaniA: The Gothic Tale
Not totally a bad game too

[kris.aalst]

ZER0 %K původně napsal:

Arcania wasn't even titled as Gothic 4. It was called ArcaniA: The Gothic Tale. Not totally a bad game too

This is not correct. 'Arcania: A Gothic Tale' was a working title that never became official. On release, the game was called 'Arcania: Gothic 4'. Plenty of proof:

https://www.ign.com/games/arcania-gothic-iv
https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/272429/jowood-productions-arcania-gothic-4-pc.html
https://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/arcania-gothic-4
https://rpgamer.com/review/arcania-gothic-4-review/
https://www.amazon.com/Arcania-Gothic-4-Xbox-360-pqube/dp/B002FGT59O

and many, many others

Stonechat původně napsal:

Gothic 4 doesn't exist. ArcaniA no longer has the title of "Gothic"

This is correct. As PB regained the rights to the Gothic name, Arcania had to drop the 'Gothic 4' from the original title. The result is indeed:

0pp0 původně napsal:

There is no Gothic 4. They can't remake a game that doesn't exist (yet)

[1984]

kris.aalst původně napsal:

ZER0 %K původně napsal:

Arcania wasn't even titled as Gothic 4. It was called ArcaniA: The Gothic Tale. Not totally a bad game too

This is not correct. 'Arcania: A Gothic Tale' was a working title that never became official. On release, the game was called 'Arcania: Gothic 4'. Plenty of proof:

https://www.ign.com/games/arcania-gothic-iv
https://tweakers.net/pricewatch/272429/jowood-productions-arcania-gothic-4-pc.html
https://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/arcania-gothic-4
https://rpgamer.com/review/arcania-gothic-4-review/
https://www.amazon.com/Arcania-Gothic-4-Xbox-360-pqube/dp/B002FGT59O

and many, many others

You don’t have to reply to me. You said you reported me for harassing you and now you constantly seek attention from me please stop.

[kris.aalst]

Believe me I don't crave your attention. I've been active on these forums for years and everyone can vouch for me not clinging to people for everything they post like you do. If someone posts false facts, I I post a friendly reply with arguments and even links to websites that prove my point. I have no idea what you think I did wrong here.