Am I missing something?

[stev]

Love this game, played the whole thing! But I NEVER unlocked what's underneath the serving window?? Help?

[Lx Studio]

Crafter Sheldon at Banamas should have given you a key for the Display Case. If you didn't receive it by the Conch or Lighthouse, there is a console command as last resort:

Press the Tidle (~) button 5 times quickly, and type in: spawn.item
Then use Tab to select FoodDisplayKey and hit Enter

[WAFFLES? DON'T U MEAN CARROTS!!]

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3395498525

[Tay]

I am at the Crafter quest. he has an exclamation above his head. When I click it, he tells me he is stressed about his lucky coin and maybe would feel better if he eats. He doesnt tell me what he wants so I looked in my Journal. It says to make him a smoothie with mango, banana and lemon. So, I do. When I go back to him with smoothie there is nothing that says give him smoothie. So, now I have found what I believe to be his coin and there is no give coin to him. I have also tasted the smoothie and saw the flashback. So now I have everything he wants. What do i do now. OH! someone says to press the tilde key. Nothing happens when I press it.

[pha]

Originally posted by Tay:

I am at the Crafter quest. he has an exclamation above his head. When I click it, he tells me he is stressed about his lucky coin and maybe would feel better if he eats. He doesnt tell me what he wants so I looked in my Journal. It says to make him a smoothie with mango, banana and lemon. So, I do. When I go back to him with smoothie there is nothing that says give him smoothie. So, now I have found what I believe to be his coin and there is no give coin to him. I have also tasted the smoothie and saw the flashback. So now I have everything he wants. What do i do now. OH! someone says to press the tilde key. Nothing happens when I press it.

The tilde key has to be pressed five times in quick succession, in order to open the command line, but we enable that so that people can get back special items that may be lost.
In your case it just sounds like one of the quest goals were skipped, namely serving the smoothie, because it cannot be "given".
When the Crafter asks for a smoothie, or anyone in the game asks for food, you have to open the truck for them, and serve them the smoothie/food through the truck window, so that they can pay you.
Objects that are not food, like the coin you should be able to give them while walking up to them. However, the Crafter won't accept the coin before you have served them the smoothie from the truck window.
The game is set up in a way that requires you to follow the goals of the quest step by step, and if unclear, the goals are noted in the journal.

Hope that helps :)