Retribution

[Marcin Raelian]

This spell doesn't work as is written on the card.
Retribution can cancel effect from: Misfortune, Lucky Charm ( even used both at 1 fight ) and Feral hunger now.

[Marcin Raelian]

Perhaps Amazon's Redo battle is buggy too.

[ToothlessNightFury]

The effects from the first battle are meant to remain in force for Retribution or Amazon Redo battle (effects, Spells, abilities, etc.). This looks like a new bug then.

[Fomalhaut]

Retribution states that Any effects, special abilities, Objects, or Spells used in the first attack remain in effect for the second attack. By the time the first battle has ended Misfortune, Lucky Charm and Feral Hunger have already been dealt with, although the consequences of their use are still in play them as cards have been discarded. Remain in effect is different to recast/replay/reuse/played again.

[ToothlessNightFury]

Originally posted by Fomalhaut:

Retribution states that Any effects, special abilities, Objects, or Spells used in the first attack remain in effect for the second attack. By the time the first battle has ended Misfortune, Lucky Charm and Feral Hunger have already been dealt with, although the consequences of their use are still in play them as cards have been discarded. Remain in effect is different to recast/replay/reuse/played again.

I disagree. Using your process, you are saying that any Spell cast in the first battle cannot be used in the second battle. Then why would the word Spell be used in the special ability description? The Spells are not recast at all, they just remain in effect. Misfortune will still produce a roll of 1, Psionic Blast will still add starting Craft to Strength in the battle. The Lucky Charm's effect would also still be in effect. Could you please refer this matter to Carl. Thanks.

[Fomalhaut]

I consulted Jaxon and Tyr, we all agreed that Misfortune is a one shot play and isn't considered to have an overall on going effect that continuously affects play.

[ToothlessNightFury]

Ok I can accept that, but what about Spells like Psionic Blast or the Lucky Charm?

[Fomalhaut]

Lucky Charm would work the same as Misfortune - as it's listed here then I'll assume it is working correctly. I'm sure I tested Psionic Blast after reading this and it does continue over to the second fight - if this is incorrect then please let me know.

[ToothlessNightFury]

Could you please check Marked for Glory in relation to Retribution or the Amazon Redo?

[vidal22]

how about things like guardian angel or divine protection, they are supposed to protect after the battle is over and you have lost-but the amazon redo allows her to bypass a battle that she won but stand off was achieved after it was over

[Marcin Raelian]

I checked this one today: Amazon's Redo battle cancels Gambler's Reduce the odds. However Gambler still can uses this ability in second fight if he has points of Fate yet.