Post your ch 3 theories here

[deteringwilliam]

I personally have no Idea, but it is fun to speculate.

[webking321]

Okay, this is ridiculous to most of you guys. But hear me out... you know that little girl from Andrew and Ashley's childhood that they locked her in the crate? What if... she is the Demon/Lord Unknown? There's a lot of things I can come up with, until I realized the big revelation. You know the shirt she wears in her sprites in the flashback scenes, there's a flower on it. In episode 2 where Ashley wakes up in the demon realm where she is summoned by Lord Unknown. In that segment, you pick up the flowers to get across the realm, but why flowers? If you put two and two together, and compare Nina's flower shirt to one of the Devlog 2's screenshots where Andrew's soul is looking at the flowers for some reason, the pattern of the flowers in the demon realm is similar to Nina's shirt.

So, what I believe is that Nina is gonna get back at Andrew and Ashley for what they did to her all those years ago, either if it's to separate them from each other, by waiting for them to kill each other. (Decay route) Or wait for the perfect opportunity to steal one of their souls. (Andrew especially, due to the fact he's marked in episode 2's ending going forward with the burial route)

Just a wild theory that Nina could be The Demon/Lord Unknown.

[17bookings]

Originalmente postado por webking321:

Okay, this is ridiculous to most of you guys. But hear me out... you know that little girl from Andrew and Ashley's childhood that they locked her in the crate? What if... she is the Demon/Lord Unknown? There's a lot of things I can come up with, until I realized the big revelation. You know the shirt she wears in her sprites in the flashback scenes, there's a flower on it. In episode 2 where Ashley wakes up in the demon realm where she is summoned by Lord Unknown. In that segment, you pick up the flowers to get across the realm, but why flowers? If you put two and two together, and compare Nina's flower shirt to one of the Devlog 2's screenshots where Andrew's soul is looking at the flowers for some reason, the pattern of the flowers in the demon realm is similar to Nina's shirt.

So, what I believe is that Nina is gonna get back at Andrew and Ashley for what they did to her all those years ago, either if it's to separate them from each other, by waiting for them to kill each other. (Decay route) Or wait for the perfect opportunity to steal one of their souls. (Andrew especially, due to the fact he's marked in episode 2's ending going forward with the burial route)

Just a wild theory that Nina could be The Demon/Lord Unknown.

yo that's actually an insane theory

[webking321]

Originalmente postado por 17bookings:

Originalmente postado por webking321:

Okay, this is ridiculous to most of you guys. But hear me out... you know that little girl from Andrew and Ashley's childhood that they locked her in the crate? What if... she is the Demon/Lord Unknown? There's a lot of things I can come up with, until I realized the big revelation. You know the shirt she wears in her sprites in the flashback scenes, there's a flower on it. In episode 2 where Ashley wakes up in the demon realm where she is summoned by Lord Unknown. In that segment, you pick up the flowers to get across the realm, but why flowers? If you put two and two together, and compare Nina's flower shirt to one of the Devlog 2's screenshots where Andrew's soul is looking at the flowers for some reason, the pattern of the flowers in the demon realm is similar to Nina's shirt.

So, what I believe is that Nina is gonna get back at Andrew and Ashley for what they did to her all those years ago, either if it's to separate them from each other, by waiting for them to kill each other. (Decay route) Or wait for the perfect opportunity to steal one of their souls. (Andrew especially, due to the fact he's marked in episode 2's ending going forward with the burial route)

Just a wild theory that Nina could be The Demon/Lord Unknown.

yo that's actually an insane theory

I want this theory to be on reddit, youtube, or any other source. This theory I made changes everything! Is the original creator of this insane game hiding something from us? Is Nina... the Demon? Is she the true villain of the story? We gotta find out once either Decay or Burial comes out. And thanks for replying to my theory, bro. I appreciate it.

[SharpenedRazors]

INCEST HELL YEAH

[Jowick™]

Just watch at the end of the game there’s suddenly going to be combat mechanics and one of the siblings is going to be the final boss depending on the route you take. If you take decay, Andrew will be the final boss, which alludes to the vision Ashley had when she shot him in her dream. Alternatively, on the burial route, Ashley will be the final boss. Each one ends with the other one dying.

[Drakoxblue]

It is just so large (the 3rt part). No idea, have no more near family so they are ¨free¨. Maybe go to fk the water company or go and play with existences powers cause, we already saw demons so it could be easily related. Anyway, I bet that the new part will be satisfactory, like, we have an word edgy, toxic relationship with manipulation and a original author

[webking321]

Remember the insane theory I made about Nina as the demon? Well, I made another insane mind blowing theory about what's gonna happen in episode 3 (Decay and Burial.) At some point of episode 3 (Regardless of the routes you choose to take.) The Demon will be a 3rd playable character and have it's own character sprite when it comes to interacting with Lord Unknown or The Graves Siblings as the Demon, which will turn out to be Nina all along. And maybe at the end, you have the choice as Nina to choose the fate of the Graves siblings. How it ends is up to the player to decide while playing as Nina.

[deteringwilliam]

I don't know, if the demon really was Nina, wouldn't they have already mentioned something about it before? Lord Unknown at least has an excuse on the account of communication difficulties if you've summoned them before.

[webking321]

Originalmente postado por deteringwilliam:

I don't know, if the demon really was Nina, wouldn't they have already mentioned something about it before? Lord Unknown at least has an excuse on the account of communication difficulties if you've summoned them before.

For the time being, until Decay or Burial comes out. We'll find out whether or not Nina turns out to be the demon. I'm getting a feeling that I could be right.

[deteringwilliam]

Just so we are clear, are you talking about Lord Unknown, or the smaller demon?

[webking321]

Originalmente postado por deteringwilliam:

Just so we are clear, are you talking about Lord Unknown, or the smaller demon?

The demon, obviously. There's no way Nina is Lord Unknown. I believe the smaller demon could be Nina, no matter how my theory sounds insane or ridiculous to some people.

[Mrsmoku98]

More backstory Julian and Andrew demonic power for sure next we have split route i think one route may ending of killing one sibling like in vision another route may create satamistic canibalistic duet and one sub route sex

[morea爆]

more incest

[A xuxuzinha]

I believe they will try to live a happy ever after ... however, since we have different paths that change their personalities (When you decide either to accept or decline the offer OR when you decide to trust or not on her brother) I believe it might have a couple of endings as well ...

1) They live together in a quite place, but Ashley ends up fearing his brother gonna kill her and kill him first and eats him so he'd never leave her.

2) They start a romantic relationship, living together. Andrew snaps and ends up killing her in some sort of mental breakdown.

3) Now they both have a demon's scar, the demon might fake their visions so they both get scared from one another, to kill them and offer to the demon

[MEHavard]

Originalmente postado por Ashley Graves :3:

i honestly rlly hope that there will be a flashback (idm if its from andy or leyley) about mr graves, with like more pics drawn of mr graves and where he actually talks & stuff

I have a feeling Mr. Graves was NOT an integral part of their lives and that the mother was solely doing everything, which involved forcing the brother to do everything and not being involved and keeping the husband even further out of it. If anything, I'd expect comments like how the man wasn't in their lives enough to even remember, while the mother was the one they'd focus to hate.

Originalmente postado por T44v1:

I assume we will meet Julia at some point and ashley will either kill or ask andrew to kill her as a final test of his loyalty.

His girlfriend would HAVE to be the next part of this since they're kind of focusing on the people they closely know. There'll probably be endings such as killing her, forcing her to do their bidding in multiple ways, and her screwing them over. With how the Alabama ending went, I could also see the ex-lover having similar twisted endings from killing them all (the sister making her suicidal or such) or even a "If you can't beat them, join them" scenario and she joins with the sister in a dark manner. Depends on how much writing the dev has involved I suppose.

I'd also imagine there's more on the hitman to come around since that revolves around the overarching plot of the supposed quarantine going on, which is sounding more like a hoax to get people to willfully stay out of sight and be harvested for parts for whatever reasons needed. I'm wondering whether it's cults, organ selling, or that weird soda always being advertised (Can anyone else say, "It's made of people!" ?) That might be more after everything is done with their personal stuff, so perhaps if there's a chapter four and five to explore.