(Possible Spoiler) Kill or save the witch, and best female

[Dash Attack]

I want Edwin and Mincs in my party but I just realised their quests are in conflict with each other. What happens if I I don't kill the witch but bring Edwin along?

Wile I wanted to have at least one women in my party for romance. The Half elf druid who's name I was going to be it but I wanted to get rid of her friend and so she left the party. My party is now consitent of my a half orc cleric, Dorn, Xan, Minss, Rasaad, and Edwin. Edwin though he looks cool is rude and annoying but he has more aggressive spells then Xan who has that amazing sword +3 sword. Any suggetions?

[Yuil]

Originally posted by Dash Attack:

What happens if I I don't kill the witch but bring Edwin along?

He will leave.

[Gustuv Wynd]

If you have her join your party and then just let her die, or have Minsc just kill her for kicks, then you can have Minsc and Edwin.

And don't worry about Xan's moonblade...it is worthless on a low level mage. He isn't a bad mage as enchantment magic is really powerful in BG1, but give him throwing daggers, darts, or a sling. I am sure some one will say "you don't know how to use him" and suggest you first put the enemies to sleep and then have him attack. Well, in that case you could have a kitten with a rusty spoon go in to do the kills and it would do just as good as Xan and his moonblade. The fight is over and won the second they fail their save...and the spell from Xan will be harder to save against.

[Dash Attack]

Originally posted by Gustuv Wynd:

If you have her join your party and then just let her die, or have Minsc just kill her for kicks, then you can have Minsc and Edwin.

And don't worry about Xan's moonblade...it is worthless on a low level mage. He isn't a bad mage as enchantment magic is really powerful in BG1, but give him throwing daggers, darts, or a sling. I am sure some one will say "you don't know how to use him" and suggest you first put the enemies to sleep and then have him attack. Well, in that case you could have a kitten with a rusty spoon go in to do the kills and it would do just as good as Xan and his moonblade. The fight is over and won the second they fail their save...and the spell from Xan will be harder to save against.

Another thing, I can't seem to find the entrance to the inside of the fortress. I figured if I just stormed it Monty Python style I'd find the door. Its probobly hidden with all the outdated textures. Do you have a general idea where the entrance is. I found the caves at the bottom.

[.//slayer]

Originally posted by Dash Attack:

Originally posted by Gustuv Wynd:

If you have her join your party and then just let her die, or have Minsc just kill her for kicks, then you can have Minsc and Edwin.

And don't worry about Xan's moonblade...it is worthless on a low level mage. He isn't a bad mage as enchantment magic is really powerful in BG1, but give him throwing daggers, darts, or a sling. I am sure some one will say "you don't know how to use him" and suggest you first put the enemies to sleep and then have him attack. Well, in that case you could have a kitten with a rusty spoon go in to do the kills and it would do just as good as Xan and his moonblade. The fight is over and won the second they fail their save...and the spell from Xan will be harder to save against.

Another thing, I can't seem to find the entrance to the inside of the fortress. I figured if I just stormed it Monty Python style I'd find the door. Its probobly hidden with all the outdated textures. Do you have a general idea where the entrance is. I found the caves at the bottom.

Inside, as in "the map of interior of the fortress"? Cause there's no such map. You only get to explore the place around the keep. There's no door or anything.

[wendigo211]

Originally posted by Dash Attack:

Wile I wanted to have at least one women in my party for romance.

There are no female romances in BG except for Neera. There are in SoD and BG2, but feel free to ignore romances in BG.

[Dash Attack]

Originally posted by .//slayer:

Originally posted by Dash Attack:

Another thing, I can't seem to find the entrance to the inside of the fortress. I figured if I just stormed it Monty Python style I'd find the door. Its probobly hidden with all the outdated textures. Do you have a general idea where the entrance is. I found the caves at the bottom.

Inside, as in "the map of interior of the fortress"? Cause there's no such map. You only get to explore the place around the keep. There's no door or anything.

That saves me alot of time. I’ll have to explore the other areas to see where the gnolls are hiding the witch.

[Giblets]

Originally posted by Dash Attack:

Originally posted by .//slayer:

Inside, as in "the map of interior of the fortress"? Cause there's no such map. You only get to explore the place around the keep. There's no door or anything.

That saves me alot of time. I’ll have to explore the other areas to see where the gnolls are hiding the witch.

I had trouble finding her, as she's in a bit i didn't know you could access (i thought it was just a bit of decoration lol)

[nome22]

Don't talk to Minsc.
Go invite Edwin, do his quest and kill the witch.

Had back to town talk to Mince -
he will ask you to help find and save her, and you can say you already found her dead, and he will say something like he has fail and has lost all his honor, then ask if he can join you get help get it back.

This work's to get both in party and i don't think they will try to kill each other because the fight gets started is between Dynaheir and Edwin..

[Centurion]

Hmm, I tried this and Minsc won't talk to me even without Edwin around. Could be that my PC is really evil?