needs help choosing a tennis game

[JFranck7]

I see this one that seems legit but with top spin coming up .. whats the best option

graphics ?
how many players ?
regular updates ?

few questions so I can choose the best tennis game :)

my last game was AO tennis 2

thanks guys

[euphoreonz]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย NathW14:

TopSpin 2K25:

Gameplay - 8/10
Graphics - 5/10
Presentation 7/10
Career Mode - 6/10
Roster - 3/10
Playable Venues - 9/10

Tiebreak:

Gameplay - 4/10
Graphics - 5/10
Presentation - 6/10
Career Mode - ?
Roster 10/10 (once complete)
Playable Venues - 7/10

Pick your poison. They both have major drawbacks in different areas.

Man, what are people expecting from a tennis game that TS and TB are only 5/10's for graphics? Stadiums look GREAT in TS, best ever in a tennis game. Players look average, but stadiums are more important. Players look GREAT in Tiebreak. They're both at leas 7 in the graphics department.

[Nico]

what is the probleme with tie break gameplay ?

[euphoreonz]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย Nico:

what is the probleme with tie break gameplay ?

It's not fluent, it doesn't do what you want it to a lot of the time. It's way too difficult and quick at the moment.

[JFranck7]

I reinstalled AO Tennis 2 to remember how it was and honestly its not as bad as people make it sound ...

[NathW14]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย euphoreonz:

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย NathW14:

TopSpin 2K25:

Gameplay - 8/10
Graphics - 5/10
Presentation 7/10
Career Mode - 6/10
Roster - 3/10
Playable Venues - 9/10

Tiebreak:

Gameplay - 4/10
Graphics - 5/10
Presentation - 6/10
Career Mode - ?
Roster 10/10 (once complete)
Playable Venues - 7/10

Pick your poison. They both have major drawbacks in different areas.

Man, what are people expecting from a tennis game that TS and TB are only 5/10's for graphics? Stadiums look GREAT in TS, best ever in a tennis game. Players look average, but stadiums are more important. Players look GREAT in Tiebreak. They're both at leas 7 in the graphics department.

No chance either are worth a 7. If either game came out 10 or years ago on PS4/Xbox One then yes, but a 7 by 2024 standards? Not even close.

[[RS] Kyusai]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย JFranck7:

I reinstalled AO Tennis 2 to remember how it was and honestly its not as bad as people make it sound ...

You're not wrong, but they did a "tons" of patches.
Tiebreak will probably be the same.

[BeGoatGamer]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย JFranck7:

Ill take TS gameplay with TB roster .. is that possible :P

If bigant and 2k create tennis game jointly it is possible dude.

[BeGoatGamer]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย JFranck7:

I reinstalled AO Tennis 2 to remember how it was and honestly its not as bad as people make it sound ...

AOT2 is still master piece. It has everything. Just pick and play have fun.

[BeGoatGamer]

Tiebreak is still in growing stage, right now We can't say anything about the game because of early access. Bigant main challenge is Gameplay and player movement in the court. Once they corrected these things. Definitely it will become a good tennis game. Let wait and see. We shall expect from bigant, what mistakes they have made in previous tennis games, those will be corrected in the Tiebreak.

[JFranck7]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย BeGoatGamer:

Tiebreak is still in growing stage, right now We can't say anything about the game because of early access. Bigant main challenge is Gameplay and player movement in the court. Once they corrected these things. Definitely it will become a good tennis game. Let wait and see. We shall expect from bigant, what mistakes they have made in previous tennis games, those will be corrected in the Tiebreak.

one thing is for sure, they have no limits for the players, they just got nadal federer and djokovic

[BeGoatGamer]

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย JFranck7:

โพสต์ดั้งเดิมโดย BeGoatGamer:

Tiebreak is still in growing stage, right now We can't say anything about the game because of early access. Bigant main challenge is Gameplay and player movement in the court. Once they corrected these things. Definitely it will become a good tennis game. Let wait and see. We shall expect from bigant, what mistakes they have made in previous tennis games, those will be corrected in the Tiebreak.

one thing is for sure, they have no limits for the players, they just got nadal federer and djokovic

To bigant licence doesn't matter. They already in the top seat. Only worry is about the gameplay smoothness and player movement. I will wait till the end of this year before buy the TIEBREAK and TOPSPIN 25. These both games will take time to polish more. Until I will play AOT2. This is more than enough to me right now. I am supporting both games. Definitely 2024 will be big treat to tennis fans.