The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Game of the Year Edition (2009)

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Game of the Year Edition (2009)

Is Glarthir really just paranoid?
This post will contain spoilers for a side-quest (not main-plot related at all) in the city of Skingrad. If you've never done it and don't want it spoiled then move along.

So in Skingrad there's a Wood Elf named Glarthir. When you go to the city he seeks you out and says he needs help but that he's being watched so he can't talk in the street. He asks you to meet him behind the great chapel at midnight. If you begin asking around town about Glarthir people will say he's the town eccentric - harmless. If you sleep or wait after asking people about him the commander of the city guard will come to you and threaten you (in the tone of his voice) and tell you to stay away from him and to notify the guards if he asks you to do anything "strange".

So Glarthir wants you to follow 3 people who live on the same street as him. He's convinced that they're part of a great conspiracy against him and are watching him all day. He asks you to follow them all day and catch them watching him, then report back to him.

At first I thought Glarthir was just paranoid schizophrenic (I have a paranoid schizophrenic in my family and I recognize the behaviour and the way they think) because when I followed the first woman, nothing happened. She simply went to her vineyard and worked all day. I went to Glarthir and reported to him that she was not following/watching him.

The second guy I followed was doing the same, except from a distance I saw another fellow creeping up behind him, then creep away. He then shouted "Thief! Guards!". Could this have been a secret meeting between the two, where they briefly exchanged information about Glarthir, but made it look like a pickpocketing incident? Alas, I had to report I found nothing.

The third guy I followed was the most interesting. He worked on the vineyard all day, went for lunch at 12pm, went home, then went out to his vineyard again in the evening and back home again. Whilst following him home at night I was suddenly arrested by a guard! He claimed I had stolen items in my inventory. But I didn't! I hadn't stolen anything! I believe the conspirators against Glarthir knew I was following them and planted stolen goods on me so I couldn't continue following the third guy and he could meet with another conspirator and conspire against Glarthir (and now me).

I told Glarthir I had no information for the third time. I wanted Glarthir to give me more time to follow the people (who I was now sure were part of a conspiracy due to strange goings on when I was following them) but Glarthir began attacking me with an axe, saying I was working for the conspirators. I had no choice but to defend myself and thus kill him (he wouldn't yield).

I got Glarthir's house key from his dead body (because I am a knight and will not use lockpicks as it is beneath me) and searched his house to see if I could find anything. I found notes about how the third guy I followed (Davide Surilie) buried something at his vineyard, but when Glarthir went to dig it up he found only disturbed earth - someone else had already dug it up. I went to see for myself, and I found many disturbed patches of earth at the Surilie farm. I believe Davide to be the chief conspirator! He is spying on Glarthir and leaving information buried on his vineyard for the Mythic Dawn to dig up and take!

All the Wikis say Glarthir is genuinely paranoid and nobody is conspiring against him or watching him, but I believe now that they are based on what I saw and what happened to me (especially me being framed for theft while following Davide).

What do you think? Has anybody found any information about this? I will have justice for Glarthir.
< >
6175/104 megjegyzés mutatása
I always felt that Glarthir knows there's SOMETHING odd about Skingrad, but he doesn't know quite what it is. Because he knows there's something strange, but nobody else seems to know or care, he naturally thinks it's either focused on him, or that he's been targeted. He's paranoid in that while there is a conspiracy at work in Skingrad, he's totally wrong about the conspiracy's goals.
Legutóbb szerkesztette: Valden21; 2021. júl. 14., 12:22
Anyone else notice the house of respawning undead in Skingrad? Nerastarel's house, a person who doesn't exist in the game. This city is definitely more than meets there eye.
I think it's harder to find a normal resident of Skingrad than it is to find the strange ones. About the most normal person in the city is probably the shepard, and he's still shady af...and surprisingly chill about you murdering his sheep/livelihood. Maybe some of the shopkeepers, but that's also debatable. Even the things that Skingrad does choose to acknowledge are odd. If somehow you haven't met the count yet:
The count is a vampire himself, who can and will actively send you to kill other vampires to protect his people and keep his affliction under wraps...yet he's also somehow oblivious or just doesn't care that yet another vampire also happens to live inside his castle feeding on his prisoners..He won't even mention her. Admittedly, if you mention her to him, he does seem surprised but also doesn't seem too bothered, though iirc I've only mentioned her after killing her, so the problem was already solved. Sure Janus prefers to leave details out he doesn't feel are important but with the relationship you can have with him, already knowing his affliction, possibly being afflicted by him, helping his wife, dealing with his steward, and a few of his other dirty secrets you would think he could at least toss out a "oh hey, try not to get arrested" at least. I suppose he sort of does, at one point he does tell you to stay out of trouble, but it didn't seem like a hint. He had just helped you with an ambush, contextually it seemed more like he wanted you to be less stupid about walking into ambushes.

How funny would it be if the thing Glarthir stumbled upon was the count's secret? or maybe that steward's secret, but since we get attacked almost instantly for even asking for a book, I don't think Glarthir would have lasted that long if he discovered THAT one.
Legutóbb szerkesztette: RequiemsRose; 2021. júl. 14., 15:47
Skingrad a weird place.
Valden21 eredeti hozzászólása:
I always felt that Glarthir knows there's SOMETHING odd about Skingrad, but he doesn't know quite what it is. Because he knows there's something strange, but nobody else seems to know or care, he naturally thinks it's either focused on him, or that he's been targeted. He's paranoid in that while there is a conspiracy at work in Skingrad, he's totally wrong about the conspiracy's goals.

There are several odd things about Skingrad. There's a house full of undead, the count is a vampire, some link between the mages guild there and Argent Dawn (or some other cult, I forget).
RequiemsRose eredeti hozzászólása:
I think it's harder to find a normal resident of Skingrad than it is to find the strange ones. About the most normal person in the city is probably the shepard, and he's still shady af...and surprisingly chill about you murdering his sheep/livelihood. Maybe some of the shopkeepers, but that's also debatable. Even the things that Skingrad does choose to acknowledge are odd. If somehow you haven't met the count yet:
The count is a vampire himself, who can and will actively send you to kill other vampires to protect his people and keep his affliction under wraps...yet he's also somehow oblivious or just doesn't care that yet another vampire also happens to live inside his castle feeding on his prisoners..He won't even mention her. Admittedly, if you mention her to him, he does seem surprised but also doesn't seem too bothered, though iirc I've only mentioned her after killing her, so the problem was already solved. Sure Janus prefers to leave details out he doesn't feel are important but with the relationship you can have with him, already knowing his affliction, possibly being afflicted by him, helping his wife, dealing with his steward, and a few of his other dirty secrets you would think he could at least toss out a "oh hey, try not to get arrested" at least. I suppose he sort of does, at one point he does tell you to stay out of trouble, but it didn't seem like a hint. He had just helped you with an ambush, contextually it seemed more like he wanted you to be less stupid about walking into ambushes.

How funny would it be if the thing Glarthir stumbled upon was the count's secret? or maybe that steward's secret, but since we get attacked almost instantly for even asking for a book, I don't think Glarthir would have lasted that long if he discovered THAT one.

It could be any number of things. Glarthir seems to have that special "it's all about ME" paranoia, so even though he thinks that he's stumbled onto something big, and he's convinced that he's a target, he's completely mistaken about what it is. You can tell by looking at his notes; one of the possible groups he mentions is the Marukhtati Selectives, and that group's been gone since roughly about the middle of the First Era because of that Dragon Break he caused. So Glarthir's just grasping at strings, but he doesn't know that. Furthermore, there are a few conspiracies going on in Skingrad, but even though his notes mention them, he proceeds to completely ignore them from then on, and he doesn't even seem to realize the Count's true nature.
Legutóbb szerkesztette: Valden21; 2021. júl. 15., 14:22
ReferableOrc374 eredeti hozzászólása:
Very intriguing fact, if you follow Davide at midnight you will find out that he is contacting with Dark Brotherhood and he is trying to murder Glarthir to earn the entrance. If you killed Davide you would be visited by dark brotherhood but others two suspects are not. Maybe the reason is dark brotherhood saw you killed the potential candidate and believe you are more competent than him. Hope this can help...
The only 2 men I've seen him speak to late at night are Reman Broder (UESP says his factions are Bandit, Thieves Guild, and Skingrad citizen) and his brother (UESP says his factions are Surilie Brothers and Skingrad citizen). I can understand thinking his brother might be DB since he wears the black hood. After several days of following Davide and telling Glarthir I haven't got enough info yet I have not seen him talk to anyone at night other than those two. I also spent a day just following Glarthir around and trying to see if anyone followed him for part or most of the day, nothing. I checked every single container of every single house of the alleged spies and found no proof of conspiracy. One thing I did notice though was if I didn't do the dialogue option about Glarthir with the accused they sort of ignored me if I was in their home and after speaking with them about Glarthir they would follow me and keep their eyes on me - even when I did the convo about Glarthir outside and followed them during hours where it wasn't trespassing so they shouldn't be acting like that.

Skyvion25 eredeti hozzászólása:
Interesting story man, I tested out your theory and hopped on to my Imperial Knight (perhaps similar to yours) and I am not one to pickpocket or steal but I do loot dead bodies for my earned riches, but besides the point I headed over to Garthir in Skingrad and made sure I had absolutely no bounty on my head. When that was taken care of I went over to talk to Glarthir and Happened to notice Davide slightly pearing past the chapel corner as if listening ( just as a reminder I also use oscuro's Oblivon overhaul and Fanscesco's Oblivion Overhaul as well). I finished up with Glarthir and looked over to where Davide was. I decided to walk over their but to my disappointment he was not there by then I was intrigued by your theory so I investigated more. I did as Glarthir told me and to no avail was there any suspicious activity with the first two folks. Then I was ready to sniff out Davide so I did the exact thing you did, then it was by midnight as he walked home, I was quite surprised that he stayed out that late but then as he gos inside his house I didn't think much of your theory anymore, until I turn around to report my findings to Glarthir the Captain of the Guard himself runs up behind me and arrests me by then I was very jumpy at the time maybe he arrested me on purpose, especially since I did not touch anything the whole time I was in Skingrad. I honestly thought that the Captain of the guard had something to do with the conspiracy. I then reported activity to Glarthir about Davide after I got out of prison. yet he thought I was suspicious and he ended up in a pool of blood sadly... Nothing ever happened after that except one thing. Whenever I am visiting Skingrad now Davide follows me around whenever I am near him. I have also been arrested for nothing over many other occasions. Tell me what your thoughts are. Thanks, BigBoy.

I can't say for sure since I have a good number of mods installed, but I *think* you get arrested while stalking the people if you don't tell Dion that Glarthir asked you for help because he thinks there's a plot against him. Dion thanks you for letting him know and tells you to report to the guard if anything else happens, and you get fame for giving a guard the Death List so I think that makes the most sense. You get arrested for suspicious activity and obstruction of justice basically. OR you guys accidentally trespassed probably.
Radiant AI is great.
As for guards arresting you for no reason it should be possible to find script for that in the editor, if there is one. That alone wouldn't prove anything though because it makes sense for guards to be concerned about a stranger spying on locals, and you've been warned already. Trespassing accidentally is also a possibility.

There's a lot of environmental storytelling in Oblivion hinting at strange and shady things all over the place so yes I think this quest is intentionally open for interpretation
Legutóbb szerkesztette: theo; 2022. aug. 3., 10:09
Guys, I have new shocking and compelling evidence the Marukhati Selective are in fact in Skingrad and likely keeping Glarthir under surveillance.

Valandrus Abor is one of them, think about it. I overheard him saying:
"A primate has better things to do than provide tourist information. Beggars have plenty of time on their hands. I'm sure you'll have much in common."

The Marukhati Selective worshipped the divine primate figure known as "the Missing God" or "Shezarr." This missing aspect of Lorkhan's identity played a significant role in the beliefs of the Marukhati Selective. Pretty odd for him to use that specific wording, given how rare it would be to see a primate in Cyrodil... "Primate" is just not in the vocabulary of Cyrodilic people. Additionally, locals seem to have little regard for his abilities as a priest. "I have no idea why Valandrus Abor even serves at the chapel." This is a quote from Skingrad local concerning Abor, it's likely he isn't putting much effort into maintaining cover. He is arrogant and self-serving, telling people to call him "your eminence". This is odd behavior for a priest of Julianos in particular. As a god of knowledge, wisdom and scholarly learning his followers would approach his position with humility and openness right? Not laud over other people and act as he does. Why would a priest of Julianos of all people refuse to share knowledge and dismiss it as "tourist information" unless he wasn't really a priest at all. This shows he is secretive with information, as an agent would be. Perhaps he is a high ranking Marukhati who finds his current mission tedious and beneath him. Due to how Glarthir is often seen hiding behind the Chapple of Julianos, it makes sense they would choose this location to send a plant to keep a close eye on him.

Abor is seen wandering around Skingrad after mid-day, potentially spying under the guise of "priestly duties" as he goes nowhere in particular. But he isn't acting alone. That would be too suspicious! This is where Bernadette Peneles comes in. She is the perfect agent. She cannot be killed using a poisoned apple, suggesting she is trained in covert tactics and assassination. In Glarthir's notes he recalls how she is one of the few people to show him kindness, clearly in an attempt to get close to him and find out what he knows. Bernadette visits the Chapel every day after 6am. She spends a couple hours there each day. We all know from interacting with shrines it does not take 2 hours to pray to the gods. What else could she be doing there except feeding information to Valandrus Abor? She lives a seemingly happy, quaint life, so has no need to be praying to Julianos for multiple hours a day... Unless she is praying to the god of information for information regarding Glarthir.

The pieces are all falling into place!
Legutóbb szerkesztette: GAMMA; 2023. aug. 26., 1:16
GAMMA eredeti hozzászólása:
Guys, I have new shocking and compelling evidence the Marukhati Selective are in fact in Skingrad and likely keeping Glarthir under surveillance.

Valandrus Abor is one of them, think about it. I overheard him saying:
"A primate has better things to do than provide tourist information. Beggars have plenty of time on their hands. I'm sure you'll have much in common."

The Marukhati Selective worshipped the divine primate figure known as "the Missing God" or "Shezarr." This missing aspect of Lorkhan's identity played a significant role in the beliefs of the Marukhati Selective. Pretty odd for him to use that specific wording, given how rare it would be to see a primate in Cyrodil... "Primate" is just not in the vocabulary of Cyrodilic people. Additionally, locals seem to have little regard for his abilities as a priest. "I have no idea why Valandrus Abor even serves at the chapel." This is a quote from Skingrad local concerning Abor, it's likely he isn't putting much effort into maintaining cover. He is arrogant and self-serving, telling people to call him "your eminence". This is odd behavior for a priest of Julianos in particular. As a god of knowledge, wisdom and scholarly learning his followers would approach his position with humility and openness right? Not laud over other people and act as he does. Why would a priest of Julianos of all people refuse to share knowledge and dismiss it as "tourist information" unless he wasn't really a priest at all. This shows he is secretive with information, as an agent would be. Perhaps he is a high ranking Marukhati who finds his current mission tedious and beneath him. Due to how Glarthir is often seen hiding behind the Chapple of Julianos, it makes sense they would choose this location to send a plant to keep a close eye on him.

Abor is seen wandering around Skingrad after mid-day, potentially spying under the guise of "priestly duties" as he goes nowhere in particular. But he isn't acting alone. That would be too suspicious! This is where Bernadette Peneles comes in. She is the perfect agent. She cannot be killed using a poisoned apple, suggesting she is trained in covert tactics and assassination. In Glarthir's notes he recalls how she is one of the few people to show him kindness, clearly in an attempt to get close to him and find out what he knows. Bernadette visits the Chapel every day after 6am. She spends a couple hours there each day. We all know from interacting with shrines it does not take 2 hours to pray to the gods. What else could she be doing there except feeding information to Valandrus Abor? She lives a seemingly happy, quaint life, so has no need to be praying to Julianos for multiple hours a day... Unless she is praying to the god of information for information regarding Glarthir.

The pieces are all falling into place!
Brilliant.
GAMMA eredeti hozzászólása:
Guys, I have new shocking and compelling evidence the Marukhati Selective are in fact in Skingrad and likely keeping Glarthir under surveillance.

Valandrus Abor is one of them, think about it. I overheard him saying:
"A primate has better things to do than provide tourist information. Beggars have plenty of time on their hands. I'm sure you'll have much in common."
That's just plain arrogance on Valandrus' part. I still think that Glarthir stumbled upon the Mythic Dawn and got confused about their goals. He thinks he's their target.
Legutóbb szerkesztette: Valden21; 2023. aug. 27., 9:02
Valden21 eredeti hozzászólása:
That's just plain arrogance on Valandrus' part. I still think that Glarthir stumbled upon the Mythic Dawn and got confused about their goals. He thinks he's their target.

This is also true, as Glarthir suspected. It's highly likely Else God-Hater was one of these Marukhati agents originally before becoming a sleeper agent for the Mythic Dawn. She likely started with this group, however their hatred for Auri-El didn't go far enough, so she was disillusioned and switched to the Mythic Dawn where her hatred extended to all gods. The Mythic Dawn claim the Divines are traitors who murdered Lorkhan. As Else was drawn in to this new theology, Valandrus Abor likely recruited Bernadette Peneles shortly afterwards. Else being a skilled warrior meant Abor was powerless to stop Else leaving. Abor let his arrogance show because he could lower his guard the more Glarthir descended into paranoia and was seen as a nutcase to locals.

Look what Else says about Glarthir:
"Not that you'll get anyone else in town to admit it. 'Oh, he's harmless, we're used to him.' Harmless, ha! One day he'll snap. Then watch out."

it's clear she's been watching him. She is the only person to admit he is dangerous, and can recall his antics over the years. Is he dangerous, or is what he knows dangerous? Some strong words coming from a religious fanatic cultist... Glarthir is aware the Mythic Dawn are watching him, he just isn't aware Else was a Mythic Dawn sleeper agent yet. Given time he likely would have known Else was involved in the plot against him.

But why would the Mythic Dawn be watching him? Because in the note in Glarthir's house he claims to know The Blades secret. And what is the Blades secret? It can only be one thing, that the assassination of Uriel Septim was an INSIDE JOB! That's right. Connect the dots.

How did they know exactly where to strike in the secret escape tunnel in the prison? How did they know to ambush Weynon Priory? There has to be a mole inside The Blades. Uriel had seen his fate in a dream and knew he was destined to die in that sewer. Why would he resign himself to this gruesome death instead of requesting a larger amount of troops to at least try and turn the tide or take a different route? Why were they even in a sewer? The palace must not have been safe which could have only been because an inside threat. Uriel must have known The Blades were rotten to the core, and no matter what they would make sure he died. This explains why there are so few Blades left after the assassination. Either the good ones were also assassinated or the corrupt ones fled after the murder.

Glarthir must have caught wind of this which is why the Mythic Dawn are stalking him. To find out what he knows and tie up loose ends.
Legutóbb szerkesztette: GAMMA; 2023. aug. 27., 12:28
GAMMA eredeti hozzászólása:
Valden21 eredeti hozzászólása:
That's just plain arrogance on Valandrus' part. I still think that Glarthir stumbled upon the Mythic Dawn and got confused about their goals. He thinks he's their target.

This is also true, as Glarthir suspected. It's highly likely Else God-Hater was one of these Marukhati agents originally before becoming a sleeper agent for the Mythic Dawn. She likely started with this group, however their hatred for Auri-El didn't go far enough, so she was disillusioned and switched to the Mythic Dawn where her hatred extended to all gods. The Mythic Dawn claim the Divines are traitors who murdered Lorkhan. As Else was drawn in to this new theology, Valandrus Abor likely recruited Bernadette Peneles shortly afterwards. Else being a skilled warrior meant Abor was powerless to stop Else leaving. Abor let his arrogance show because he could lower his guard the more Glarthir descended into paranoia and was seen as a nutcase to locals.

Look what Else says about Glarthir:
"Not that you'll get anyone else in town to admit it. 'Oh, he's harmless, we're used to him.' Harmless, ha! One day he'll snap. Then watch out."

it's clear she's been watching him. She is the only person to admit he is dangerous, and can recall his antics over the years. Is he dangerous, or is what he knows dangerous? Some strong words coming from a religious fanatic cultist... Glarthir is aware the Mythic Dawn are watching him, he just isn't aware Else was a Mythic Dawn sleeper agent yet. Given time he likely would have known Else was involved in the plot against him.
But that doesn't explain why the Blades WITH Uriel Septim killed the Mythic Dawn agents in the sewers. If they really were working with the Mythic Dawn, then they would have ignored the Uriel and killed the Champion right there in the cell, and then cut Uriel down as soon as they were in the tunnel. So if what you say is true, then why did neither of those two things happen? Your explanation seems just a little too tidy for me. How do we know YOU'RE not a Mythic Dawn agent, sent to Skingrad to keep the guards there occupied by gaslighting Glarthir?
Legutóbb szerkesztette: Valden21; 2023. aug. 27., 15:22
Valden21 eredeti hozzászólása:
But that doesn't explain why the Blades WITH Uriel Septim killed the Mythic Dawn agents in the sewers. If they really were working with the Mythic Dawn, then they would have ignored the Uriel and killed the Champion right there in the cell, and then cut Uriel down as soon as they were in the tunnel. So if what you say is true, then why did neither of those two things happen? Your explanation seems just a little too tidy for me. How do we know YOU'RE not a Mythic Dawn agent, sent to Skingrad to keep the guards there occupied by gaslighting Glarthir?

These fanatics have no problem dying for the cause as they gain access to paradise. Killing a few of their own to maintain cover makes sense. Looking further into this Glenroy raises suspicion. he does in fact want to kill the prisoner, he says "Dammit, it's that prisoner again! Kill him, he might be working with the assassins." A clear attempt to tie up loose ends with an extrajudicial killing. Glenroy also says "We should find a defensible spot and protect the Emperor until help arrives." This shows other Blades knew about this route and would come at a later point making the mole theory a lot more plausible. Either that or Glenroy wanted to lead them to an ambush rather than escape. As for why Glenroy didn't kill Uriel right away? This is because Renault and Baurus were still alive and likely not involved in the plot. Baurus being the most formidable swordsman meant Glenroy would have to wait for the Mythic Dawn to pick them off through brute force. It's important their cover is not blown. However Glenroy was killed in the skirmish. Glenroy would have no problem with dying in battle he gets sent to Paradise and his cover is not blown.

I have been consuming copious amounts of skooma and have figured this all out.
Legutóbb szerkesztette: GAMMA; 2023. aug. 27., 17:01
GAMMA eredeti hozzászólása:
These fanatics have no problem dying for the cause as they gain access to paradise. Killing a few of their own to maintain cover makes sense. Looking further into this Glenroy raises suspicion. he does in fact want to kill the prisoner, he says "Dammit, it's that prisoner again! Kill him, he might be working with the assassins." A clear attempt to tie up loose ends with an extrajudicial killing. Glenroy also says "We should find a defensible spot and protect the Emperor until help arrives." This shows other Blades knew about this route and would come at a later point making the mole theory a lot more plausible. Either that or Glenroy wanted to lead them to an ambush rather than escape. As for why Glenroy didn't kill Uriel right away? This is because Renault and Baurus were still alive and likely not involved in the plot. Baurus being the most formidable swordsman meant Glenroy would have to wait for the Mythic Dawn to pick them off through brute force. It's important their cover is not blown. However Glenroy was killed in the skirmish. Glenroy would have no problem with dying in battle he gets sent to Paradise and his cover is not blown.

I have been consuming copious amounts of skooma and have figured this all out.

HAHA! That's just what a Mythic Dawn agent WOULD say!

But seriously, I do truly think that Glarthir's confused. Given that the Marukhtati Selectives were so arrogant and fanatic that they caused a Dragon Break, the chances that Akatosh would have left any of them around is incredibly unlikely. It's just too dangerous to reality to ignore anybody who has that level of fanaticism.
Legutóbb szerkesztette: Valden21; 2023. aug. 30., 10:12
< >
6175/104 megjegyzés mutatása
Laponként: 1530 50